Live-Action Punisher Vs. Red Hood

I don't see how Jason could have won.

Frank H2H isn't as glamorous but efficiently brutal. Guns are the what supposedly make his less deadly.

nice Nolan like Gun-Fu scene

I do not agree with most of these results but this I can agree with while Frank is not as fast, agile or skilled in h2h combat he is more experienced and IMO has a higher pain tolerance which is what would give him the victory.

Nah, it was. He got you good Jonny boy.

PIS. Jason should have dominated H2H, after taking a couple shots from range.

Not really, Jason is but a shade of his former glory. He's basically running around pretending he's Dick now.

Feel like this wasn't new 52 Jason

, if this was new 52 Jason this would have been boarder line spite bc his feats amazing

Well that was incredibly disappointing and totally not worth the 3 month wait.

Cool video but theres was no way Punisher could ever Red Hood.

I could make any number of "Jason is dead again" jokes, but instead I'm just going to say that AWESOME WAS JUST REDEFINED!!!

@dondave: Well in order for it to be fair they clearly had to nerf Todd. I mean come on otherwise Punisher gets his face punched out the back of his skull right?

Nah he's still a badass.

I don't understand why most people are disagreeing with the result. Honestly it went almost exactly how I had always pictured it. Frank beats Jason in a close and bloody fight. For those complaining because Jason is more skilled in H2H, they didn't really pay attention to the vid. Jason completely outclassed and dominated Frank in H2H and used his agility to give him trouble, but Frank won because of his pain tolerance, dirtier tactics and overpowering Jason.

Accurate result

Too bad Frank didn't kill this Robin reject for real.

Is there anyone that Jason can't one shot

@homicidalmaniac: Maybe Lucifer Morningstar but even then he'd probably find a way to do it.

@dondave: I know you're joking, but why?

That dialogue was terrible.

BURN!!!!!!!!!!

@lukehero: Like I said, not really.

I don't think I really agree with this one. As stated in previous posts, Jason has beaten Shiva who is one of the best H2H combatants in the DCU.

I don't think I really agree with this one. As stated in previous posts, Jason has beaten Shiva who is one of the best H2H combatants in the DCU.

Notes: 00:47 REALLY? REALLY?!?!

00:53 PUNISHER SHOULD BE CRYING RIGHT NOW

1:26 CUTE HOW PUNISHER IS JUST STANDIND THERE

JASON SHOULD OF TAKEN THIS!

No. Wolverine beat Batman because commonsense states he'd take a clear majority. Even "most" hardcore fans have a hard time justifying Bruce taking Logan in a random.

And if you think for one second Wolverine's more popular than Batman in any medium or in any community then you're completely off your rocker.

Jason should have won, great vid though.

Jesus Christ I can't take the horrible dialogue and acting!\

Other than that, great stuff.

that'll teach those batards! :>

Still pissed about this.There better be an alternate ending where Jason wins

I call shenanigans.

Jason should be one-shotting Punisher.

Jmarshmallow

Jason would win. That, and he's a cooler superhero. How did punisher win ? o.o

Personally I think Red Hood should've won, but that's just me.

Punisher is smarter stronger tougher more resourceful better with weapons more brutal and more experienced and Jason had training from Batman then got killed by the Joker. Punisher kicked his ass and rightfully so, it really gets on my nerves how people hate on the fight just because their preferred character lost.

That's... Not... What... PIS... Means...

@nickzambuto: lol I know

At least Red Hood is getting some attention.

Facts

Heresy!

This was a fan vote contest, the victory could be for one way or the other. I don't want to be a fan boy (which i am) but i like to think that the Punisher won with all the justice.

Okay Red Hood is better h2h fighter and trained with the better fighters/assassins of DCU but i like to think that the Punisher experience gets the better of Red Hood skills.

This version of Frank might probably have more than 20 years of crime fighting over Jason Todd's, Frank himself is master of many styles of martial arts too, he isn't only a guy with guns like many people call him. He is more than that.

Both actors nailed their characters and was a great fight, the wait for this episode really paid off.

Personally i would like to see these two team up to takeout a common threat but maybe next time.

Puncher all the way!

Popularity contest... Punisher's more popular than Jason... That sucks.

That ending was well disappointing.

Honestly, I knew the Puinisher would win just by seeing who was orchestrating the the battle. The battles on this channel are decided by pure popularity. This is the same garbage that they pulled with Captain America and Master Chief.

No offense but Franks victory is how it would go in comics i mean he has battled the best of them and you look at his feats he helped cap and his rebellious heroes infiltrate the baxter building in the civil war story he has fought wolverine captain america he has fought daredevil solidly he beat bullseye he has fought deadpool and done well the guy has basically wiped out the hole organised crime syndicate based in the marvel universe when redhood is basically a poor mans Punisher people say he is better at fighting but who killed him the joker frank would kill the joker never mind send him to arkham, also red hood is brash cocky his anger clouds his judgement also Punishers pain tolerance is far superior look what daken did to him he was still standing till he was decapitated and almost cut his head off red hood may have been trained as robin, that doesn't mean hell Frank has fought the best while being the underdog and done considerably well i can say super power beatdown chose right with Punisher Winning.

New 52 Jason would have stomped

Has it occurred to anyone that this may be pre 52 Jason? Then I could see the fight playing out like this

@psycho_soldier:Well wolverine beating batman makes sense as good at fighting healing factor speed advantage great intelligence. People don't like when dc characters lose Punisher beating red hood makes sense he has faced more consistent fights red hood is up and down yes Frank gets bad showings but his better showings are superior to red hood for example fighting bullseye and such who has better marksmanship than red hood he also fights opponents like wolverine daredevil captain america daken these are very consistent.