Legolas vs Kili

Legolas obviously wins in a ranged fight, so this is going to be a melee fight. Legolas has sword and 2 knives, kili has his sword. Fight is in lake town, start 10 ft. apart. They are both bloodlusted and fighting over Tauriel lol. Who wins?

Legolas would probably solo the Company ... I guess?

Legolas pulls down Kili's knickers and whupps dat ass

wait okay seems like a mismatch then. I'll remake it vs thorin

No way would he solo the company. He would have a good fight with the more experienced dwarves in one on ones like Kili and Thorin. He struggled just as much as Kili did with Bolg, and even would have lost to him on a few occasions but was saved by the environment and plot reasons.

I'd say that Legolas wins a solid majority with Kili, but he will have to work for it.

legolas

@martinceld: Make it Legolas vs Thorin and Kili.

This is not a mismatch. I'd favor Legolas for the majority, but Kili could take a few victories.

Yeah, Bolg killed Kili, it's true. But Legolas at best was stalemating Bolg 1 on 1. He had to use an environmental kill to beat Bolg.

Legolas for 7-8/10.

That would be too much I think. He would take a majority over Kili but he'd have to work for it, and a closer match between thorin perhaps.

@mandarinestro how about legolas and thranduil vs thorin and gimli (melee fight) ? would that be a more interesting match?

yes legolas wins this. However put Dain, Thorin or Dwalin there and u get a 8/10 result over here for the epic Dwarves xD