I'd say it`d be 50/50 for pretty much all of them. They are all main characters who save the ship on nearly a weekly basis.
The thing that I find funny is that everyone thinks data is just going to destroy them in hand to hand but you all are forgetting his secret shut down button. Now Spock or Kirk don't know this, but Picard does. But how would they get access to this information? Simple. Kirk distracts data getting his as* pummeled around (which happens often) but probably able to dodge most of data's attacks, data is never shown to be very mobile on the series or fast, just strong and smart. Spock easily dispatches Picard, then begins a mind meld and probes his mind for any weaknesses on data because he sees Kirk getting his as* kicked. Once that's done its a simple matter of both kirk and spock double teaming data. I'd imagine them knocking him to his feet maybe a tackle or some type of improvised rope (made from cloth, bonus kirk is now shirtless or not bonus?). Spock is still weaker then data, but I'm sure with a burst of adrenaline he`d be able to hold data down long enough for kirk to reach the button and shut down data.
If that's too complicated, spock could take picard hostage and force data to shut down or picard now has a snapped neck.
I'm well aware that one punch from data in the noggin is game over. The thing is spock/kirk make a better team. They know how to work together better then Picard and data do. But Data's strength would definitely be a huge obstacle. Far from insurmountable though.
If it was data vs 1 of any of them he`d win hands down. Picard actually is hurting their odds in a physical brawl strangely enough.
Log in to comment