#1 Edited by PrinceAragorn1 (20260 posts) - - Show Bio

So basically, you have to say who will fair how against whom, or stop at which round. I can't really find a good way to put this many match ups, so I'll probably start a series of threads. But this is where I'll collect the results if I do.

Killer/Mastermind side:

Warmup Round for detectives: Carl Elias - The bigger picture. (Person of Interest)

Trust me. This warm up is quite serious, maybe worthy of being a round. But he doesn't have that many feats as of now.

Round 1: The Boston reaper (Criminal Minds)

Foyet wins by killing the detectives. Detectives win by capture.

Round 2: Dexter Morgan (Dexter)

The detectives come looking for The Bay Harber Butcher. They win by capturing dex, Dexter wins by avoiding capture.

Round 3: Hannibal Lector (Hannibal)

The detectives come to solve an unrelated case, hannibal is just a normal psychiatrist to them. Will hasn't joined yet, so hannibal doesn't have to worry about him. The case spans for months.

Detectives win by noticing hannibal's presence AND capturing/killing hannibal, hannibal wins by evading capture in any way.

Round 4: Walter White (Breaking Bad)

The detectives come to catch heisenberg. Detectives wins by capture/killing, walt by avoiding it.

Round 5: Jim Moriarty (Sherlock)

Detectives have heard rumors of a 'consulting criminal.'

Jim isn't playing around here. Detectives win by capture/kill, Moriarty by outwitting them.

Round 6: Red John (The Mentalist)

Simple enough. detectives come to solve the red john case, win by capture, or killing. Red john wins by doing whatever he does as usual.

Round 7: Prof. James Moriarty (Sherlock holmes, movie)

Vs

Warm-up Round: Miami Metro Homicide. Dexter will only act as analyst.

Round 1: CSI: Las Vegas crew. (from earlier season, if they underwent any changes)

Round 2: Will Graham and FBI (Hannibal)

Round 3: Team Shawn Spencer (Psych)

Round 4: Cal Lightman and Team Lie to me (Psych series)

Round 5: Sherlock Holmes and John Watson (Sherlock),

no mycroft.

Round 6: B.A.U. Criminal Minds crew.

Both Jason and David are on the team.

Round 7: Jack Baeur (24)

Round 8: Patrick Jane, with resources of Fbi

Round 9:

Harold Finch, Reese, and Team. They are backed by root, Harold is currently Admin of God Mode.

And Begin!

#2 Posted by PrinceAragorn1 (20260 posts) - - Show Bio
#3 Edited by RogueShadow (11977 posts) - - Show Bio

@princearagorn1: It's actually Cal Lightman.

Overall, I'd say Moriarty [BBC] can put down any of the detectives if he really isn't playing around, minus Jack if Jack has Chloe and the CTU he probably has the best shot at taking down Moriarty in my opinion, Chloe could be the deciding factor in my opinion.

#4 Edited by PrinceAragorn1 (20260 posts) - - Show Bio

@rogueshadow: I know. Idk how I wrote carl..

Do the gauntlet orders look alright to you?

And.. could jim really take out finch when backed by machine?

#5 Posted by RogueShadow (11977 posts) - - Show Bio

@rogueshadow: I know. Idk how I wrote carl..

Do the gauntlet orders look alright to you?

And.. could jim really take out finch when backed by machine?

At first I thought that Jack should b lower down, but when I saw Moriarty was out for blood, I decided that he gets the furthest of anybody here.

And I don't know, I know nothing about Person of Interest, CSI & Criminal minds.

The only one that seems out of order to me is movie Moriarty, I think he should be underneath BBC Holmes and above Heisenberg.

#6 Posted by Shawnbaby (10869 posts) - - Show Bio

@princearagorn1: I'd just point out that Patrick Jane doesn't work with the FBI...he works with the CBI and his resources should reflect that.

#7 Posted by PrinceAragorn1 (20260 posts) - - Show Bio

@princearagorn1: I'd just point out that Patrick Jane doesn't work with the FBI...he works with the CBI and his resources should reflect that.

Well, he currently does.

@princearagorn1 said:

@rogueshadow: I know. Idk how I wrote carl..

Do the gauntlet orders look alright to you?

And.. could jim really take out finch when backed by machine?

At first I thought that Jack should b lower down, but when I saw Moriarty was out for blood, I decided that he gets the furthest of anybody here.

And I don't know, I know nothing about Person of Interest, CSI & Criminal minds.

The only one that seems out of order to me is movie Moriarty, I think he should be underneath BBC Holmes and above Heisenberg.

Well, movie moriarty was more of a mastermind than a consulting criminal.. so I put him a above sherlock one. and he can sing ;)

As for person of interest, it's God mode is the machine fully backing a person called admin. Basically like having a low level brainiac looking after you. It's connected to every electronic device, can hack into any system, has records dating back decades, and has several ways of tracking people sophisticated to the point of sound/pattern of their footsteps almost anywhere there is a device. Finch isn't lacking in intelligence, considering he built the machine, nor resources has several (dozens) aliases who are billionaires at the very least.. exists on no known databases in the world and so on.

#8 Posted by RogueShadow (11977 posts) - - Show Bio

@shawnbaby said:

@princearagorn1: I'd just point out that Patrick Jane doesn't work with the FBI...he works with the CBI and his resources should reflect that.

Well, he currently does.

@rogueshadow said:

@princearagorn1 said:

@rogueshadow: I know. Idk how I wrote carl..

Do the gauntlet orders look alright to you?

And.. could jim really take out finch when backed by machine?

At first I thought that Jack should b lower down, but when I saw Moriarty was out for blood, I decided that he gets the furthest of anybody here.

And I don't know, I know nothing about Person of Interest, CSI & Criminal minds.

The only one that seems out of order to me is movie Moriarty, I think he should be underneath BBC Holmes and above Heisenberg.

Well, movie moriarty was more of a mastermind than a consulting criminal.. so I put him a above sherlock one. and he can sing ;)

As for person of interest, it's God mode is the machine fully backing a person called admin. Basically like having a low level brainiac looking after you. It's connected to every electronic device, can hack into any system, has records dating back decades, and has several ways of tracking people sophisticated to the point of sound/pattern of their footsteps almost anywhere there is a device. Finch isn't lacking in intelligence, considering he built the machine, nor resources has several (dozens) aliases who are billionaires at the very least.. exists on no known databases in the world and so on.

Yeah... He should win, haha.

#9 Posted by PrinceAragorn1 (20260 posts) - - Show Bio

@rogueshadow: Finch is a good guy though, that's why he limited the machine. I could add a few dialogue lines from episode 2*21, but it was too brilliant to give away any spoilers..

#10 Edited by PrinceAragorn1 (20260 posts) - - Show Bio

@rogueshadow: Heh.. these threads almost become like a PM. Shame on Comicvine lol.

@shawnbaby: What about the remaining?

#11 Posted by DigitalShooter9 (2016 posts) - - Show Bio

Heisenberg solo/stomps anyone and everyone here... Then he dissolves their bodies in acid and pours them in the ocean....

Online
#12 Edited by PrinceAragorn1 (20260 posts) - - Show Bio

@digitalshooter9 said:

Heisenberg solo/stomps anyone and everyone here... Then he dissolves their bodies in acid and pours them in the ocean....

care to explain more?

#13 Edited by AllaithAlsaleh (492 posts) - - Show Bio

Hmm, Top detectives I would say are: Jane, Sherlock, and Cal Lightman as for Killers: Red John ah, Red John, Dexter and Hanibal both versions of Moriarty aren't THAT impressive, Jane can probably solve everything except Dex and Red John and I know what you're thinking;Jane already killed Red John, Blah, Blah, anyway Season 6 of The Mentalist was like a Non-Canon it dosn't even make sense to the rest of the series Red John promised Jane that he would kill him when he has the chance and he had it like 3 times so I'm considering that this is Red John from seasons 1 to 5 the superhuman one I mean; the guy who can see through the future who can read minds who is OBVIOUSLY isn't getting caught here so RJ clears easily, Sherlock either stop at Hannibal or Red John, Jane will stop at Red John as well but may stop at Dexter too, Cal Lightman clears EASILY if he met all the criminals which I guess is not an option with Red John and Moriarty, the others stumble across the way and for some final notes;here we have a bunch of VERY intelligent men but only two of them are actually Superhuman:Red John and Shawn Spencer, Shawn is too goofy and RJ is...well... like Doctor Strange mixedwith Red Skull, while most killers here are Villians only Red John is a SUPERvillian because he can see the future and read minds and because Season 6 of The Mentalist is a Non- Canon I mean why would you want to save your archenemy's life while being killed by another criminal on a rooftop, an ACTUAL Red John would walk away and let Jane die, so... only Red John clear and no one is passing him nor Dexter, The End.

#14 Edited by AllaithAlsaleh (492 posts) - - Show Bio

this is a cool battle.