Katniss vs Merida

Location: A generic forest

Both are placed in the forest and told to hunt the other

Both know they are being hunted

Both get one bow with 10 regular arrows

Morals OFF

Win by death or incapacitation

Merida from the Disney film Brave

Katniss from Hunger Games film series

Who wins??

Obviously the warrior princess

Katniss actually hunts to survive, and can move quietly in the forest, but the princess has some serious skill. i.e the whole robin hood thing, landing a bulls eye and then splitting the first arrow in half with another.

6/10 to Merrida. Katniss gets the wins she does get from stealth, but Merrida is a just plain better shot I think. If Katniss misses the first shot, which she is capable of, she losses her main advantage. Also if it somehow comes down to hand to hand, Merrida is a beast in comparison. If she can cross swords with her father, a man three times her size, I'm sure she can punch out Katniss with ease.

Merrida.

Merida

@kotetsu454: agreed

Didn't Merida fight a bear or something? I'm tempted to give her the win.

Merida.

Merida

@the_stegman: yes she did

merida split an arrow with her own arrow ala robin hood, and intercepted 3 arrows with one single arrow