#1 Posted by JayceeFoli (6 posts) - - Show Bio

ROFLMAO, Who wins. Canon ball Run style, Across the galaxy, no rules. mano e mano.

#2 Posted by Quartermaim (617 posts) - - Show Bio

Are we talking a throwdown or a firefight?

#3 Posted by guttridgeb (4831 posts) - - Show Bio

@JayceeFoli: More details please

#4 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

Kirk has insta-KO punches.

#5 Posted by WillPayton (9058 posts) - - Show Bio

I have no idea what the rules of this battle are.

#6 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio
#7 Posted by WillPayton (9058 posts) - - Show Bio

@Shawnbaby said:

You're saying he would do this to Han Solo? Hahahaha...

#8 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

Han Solo fights dirty, he wins.

#9 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

@WillPayton said:

@Shawnbaby said:

You're saying he would do this to Han Solo? Hahahaha...

It just goes to show you how powerful Kirk's fist is. Even that terribly thrown punch is enough to knock out this space chick.

#10 Posted by WillPayton (9058 posts) - - Show Bio

@Shawnbaby said:

@WillPayton said:

@Shawnbaby said:

You're saying he would do this to Han Solo? Hahahaha...

It just goes to show you how powerful Kirk's fist is. Even that terribly thrown punch is enough to knock out this space chick.

Well, she WAS dazed and stunned by Kirk's kiss. So, if Kirk can get a liplock on Solo, game over man, game over!

#11 Posted by Floopay (8582 posts) - - Show Bio

Somehow, I think Bones has summed up my entire argument for me:

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

#12 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio
#13 Posted by dccomicsrule2011 (22930 posts) - - Show Bio

Han Solo, because he's Han Solo.

#14 Posted by Fetts (4363 posts) - - Show Bio
@Shawnbaby said:
Lol. Dat man-bra
#15 Posted by Sufferthorn (1734 posts) - - Show Bio

......Han Solo can't compete with Kirk's H2H combat feats.

#16 Posted by Israphael (350 posts) - - Show Bio

Captain Han Kirk via force lightning.

#17 Posted by PlasticBag (1222 posts) - - Show Bio

@dccomicsrule2011 said:

Han Solo, because he's Han Solo.

#18 Posted by Sufferthorn (1734 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

Han Solo fights dirty, he wins.

You think Kirk doesn't fight dirty?

Kirk wins in H2H

Han Solo wins in a shootout.

#19 Posted by rpottage (839 posts) - - Show Bio

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

#20 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@Sufferthorn said:

@Xanni15 said:

Han Solo fights dirty, he wins.

You think Kirk doesn't fight dirty?

Kirk wins in H2H

Han Solo wins in a shootout.

Han kills him before the battle even begins.

#21 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

#22 Posted by Sufferthorn (1734 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15:

Yes....he wins in a shootout, Han Solo is a distinguished gunslinger and smuggler.

But Captain Kirk wins in about every other professional alleyway. He can command a Starship and gain the undying loyalty of his crew, and he can kick literally anyones ass in a close-quarters combat situation.

Winner depends on the situation in my opinion.

#23 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@Sufferthorn:

I'm not even talking about just a shootout, Han would kill Kirk before the battle even started, blaster or not. Take Greedo for instance.

Commanding a ship is irrelevant, that's Kirk's job. It would be like be saying that Han is a better smuggler than Kirk. Solo showed to be a great commander on Endor, as well as piloting the Falcon for so many years and eluding capture.

True, in certain circumstances Kirk can pull out a W.

#24 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@Sufferthorn:

I'm not even talking about just a shootout, Han would kill Kirk before the battle even started, blaster or not. Take Greedo for instance.

Commanding a ship is irrelevant, that's Kirk's job. It would be like be saying that Han is a better smuggler than Kirk. Solo showed to be a great commander on Endor, as well as piloting the Falcon for so many years and eluding capture.

True, in certain circumstances Kirk can pull out a W.

Official canon is that Greedo shot first...:D

#25 Posted by rpottage (839 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

#26 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@Shawnbaby said:

@Xanni15 said:

@Sufferthorn:

I'm not even talking about just a shootout, Han would kill Kirk before the battle even started, blaster or not. Take Greedo for instance.

Commanding a ship is irrelevant, that's Kirk's job. It would be like be saying that Han is a better smuggler than Kirk. Solo showed to be a great commander on Endor, as well as piloting the Falcon for so many years and eluding capture.

True, in certain circumstances Kirk can pull out a W.

Official canon is that Greedo shot first...:D

We all know the real truth. :P

#27 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

#28 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

He's just "boldly going where no man has gone before"

#29 Posted by rpottage (839 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

@Shawnbaby said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

He's just "boldly going where no man has gone before"

Lol.

#30 Posted by KalTheHokage_2007 (651 posts) - - Show Bio

Han Solo. fanboyism rules. completely disregard my answer as being feat-based. Anyone who posts that is being a fanboy, you simply point out the obvious.

#31 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

#32 Posted by KnightRise (4785 posts) - - Show Bio

Kirk: double-fist overhead downward punch

/thread.

#33 Posted by rpottage (839 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

#34 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

#35 Posted by YourNeighborhoodComicGeek (19892 posts) - - Show Bio

@Shawnbaby said:

Uhhhhhhhhhhhh......

#36 Posted by rpottage (839 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

No, it doesn't. I mean a guy who lands one lady, after a lot of work, can't claim to have powers of seduction.

And since you insist on the "who's easier" thing; how hard is a chick that kisses her own brother?

#37 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

No, it doesn't. I mean a guy who lands one lady, after a lot of work, can't claim to have powers of seduction.

And since you insist on the "who's easier" thing; how hard is a chick that kisses her own brother?

I'm simply saying that a woman who wants to be seduced is an easier target than actually seducing someone who at first hates your guts.

Really? That was purely to get back at Han so context is kinda of important. Kirk was seducing skanks, Han went after a dignified person.

#38 Posted by rpottage (839 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

No, it doesn't. I mean a guy who lands one lady, after a lot of work, can't claim to have powers of seduction.

And since you insist on the "who's easier" thing; how hard is a chick that kisses her own brother?

I'm simply saying that a woman who wants to be seduced is an easier target than actually seducing someone who at first hates your guts.

Really? That was purely to get back at Han so context is kinda of important. Kirk was seducing skanks, Han went after a dignified person.

And I'm saying seducing one woman does not make you good at seducing.

Actually it was to point out it's easy to call a girl "easy" or a "skank" because you want to make a point; but you have no evidence any of that is true.

#39 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

No, it doesn't. I mean a guy who lands one lady, after a lot of work, can't claim to have powers of seduction.

And since you insist on the "who's easier" thing; how hard is a chick that kisses her own brother?

I'm simply saying that a woman who wants to be seduced is an easier target than actually seducing someone who at first hates your guts.

Really? That was purely to get back at Han so context is kinda of important. Kirk was seducing skanks, Han went after a dignified person.

And I'm saying seducing one woman does not make you good at seducing.

Actually it was to point out it's easy to call a girl "easy" or a "skank" because you want to make a point; but you have no evidence any of that is true.

Nor does seducing a million women who are desperate and looking to be banged. Whatever you think, Leia was a lot harder to seduce than anyone Kirk tried.

And you have no evidence of the contrary, except I could point out that Leia hated Han when she met him so he was working from a disadvantage and his seduction powers took over form there. Kirk started out on an easier level.

#40 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

@YourNeighborhoodComicGeek said:

@Shawnbaby said:

Uhhhhhhhhhhhh......

We all know what happens to Red Shirts in Star Trek...

#41 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

No, it doesn't. I mean a guy who lands one lady, after a lot of work, can't claim to have powers of seduction.

And since you insist on the "who's easier" thing; how hard is a chick that kisses her own brother?

I'm simply saying that a woman who wants to be seduced is an easier target than actually seducing someone who at first hates your guts.

Really? That was purely to get back at Han so context is kinda of important. Kirk was seducing skanks, Han went after a dignified person.

And I'm saying seducing one woman does not make you good at seducing.

Actually it was to point out it's easy to call a girl "easy" or a "skank" because you want to make a point; but you have no evidence any of that is true.

Nor does seducing a million women who are desperate and looking to be banged. Whatever you think, Leia was a lot harder to seduce than anyone Kirk tried.

And you have no evidence of the contrary, except I could point out that Leia hated Han when she met him so he was working from a disadvantage and his seduction powers took over form there. Kirk started out on an easier level.

Leia almost banged her own brother...hardly an example of "The Chaste and Pure Princess" :D

#42 Posted by turoksonofstone (13199 posts) - - Show Bio

@Shawnbaby said:

This.

#43 Edited by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@Shawnbaby said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

No, it doesn't. I mean a guy who lands one lady, after a lot of work, can't claim to have powers of seduction.

And since you insist on the "who's easier" thing; how hard is a chick that kisses her own brother?

I'm simply saying that a woman who wants to be seduced is an easier target than actually seducing someone who at first hates your guts.

Really? That was purely to get back at Han so context is kinda of important. Kirk was seducing skanks, Han went after a dignified person.

And I'm saying seducing one woman does not make you good at seducing.

Actually it was to point out it's easy to call a girl "easy" or a "skank" because you want to make a point; but you have no evidence any of that is true.

Nor does seducing a million women who are desperate and looking to be banged. Whatever you think, Leia was a lot harder to seduce than anyone Kirk tried.

And you have no evidence of the contrary, except I could point out that Leia hated Han when she met him so he was working from a disadvantage and his seduction powers took over form there. Kirk started out on an easier level.

Leia almost banged her own brother...hardly an example of "The Chaste and Pure Princess" :D

Oh, psh. PIS, Lucas had no clue what he was doing. :P And as far as we know, Princess Leia was as pure and innocent as they come. ;)

#44 Edited by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

@Xanni15 said:

@Shawnbaby said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

@Xanni15 said:

@rpottage said:

Kirk stomps.

He's got an endless suply of powerful starships (Seriously, how many times did he destroy the Enterprise then get a new one), an endless supply of redshirts, plus he's got mad fighting skills which are surpassed only by his mad seduction skills.

And Han is able to evade the Empire, a "team" more powerful than Starfleet, plus evade numerous bounty hunters. As for seduction, check out TESB and look at Han's seduction skills, slow and sweet.

Yeah, no. He can evade them, kind of (they were tracked a few times and barely got away with help and he was frozen at one point), but that's not an ability to fight. And his seductions are nothing on Kirk. He had three movies and only got the girl after she kissed her brother. Kirk has a new girl like every episode. He the universes biggest manwhore.

Han's been a smuggler for a long time, plus he has military training from his youth, and he's been in a few relationships. You could say that the "women" Kirk has are easier than the ones Han has seduced.

Better smuggler:yes. His military training doesn't compare with Kirk's training/wicked fighting style (we have to base it on what we saw, and Kirk is demonstrated as an awesome fighter, even though it's often more funny than serious).

They're not really easier (well not all of them), it's just that Kirk is portrayed as a ladies man. Objectively, Kirk takes is.

Actually, we don't. OP doesn't specify versions so all forms of media are then allowed, this Han's training is okay to use.

Kirk's fighting is less realistic and to be honest PIS, except in the newer Star Trek . We can't know for sure is they're easier or not (but he does get shot down in Star Trek), but I would imagine getting with female aliens who have never seen a human before would be quite the advantage Han had to work to get his.

I didn't mean saw as in only live-action; I meant saw as in what's been demonstrated. Kirk demonstrated the ability to seduce chicks left, right, and center with ease. Han had trouble with one girl. It's an easy win there for Kirk.

But see, that says more about the type of women Kirk was able to attract than the quality of his seduction powers. Also, more women doesn't mean he was better, he just means he had more opportunities. Han turned a relationship into marriage and children, he sealed the deal.

No, it doesn't. I mean a guy who lands one lady, after a lot of work, can't claim to have powers of seduction.

And since you insist on the "who's easier" thing; how hard is a chick that kisses her own brother?

I'm simply saying that a woman who wants to be seduced is an easier target than actually seducing someone who at first hates your guts.

Really? That was purely to get back at Han so context is kinda of important. Kirk was seducing skanks, Han went after a dignified person.

And I'm saying seducing one woman does not make you good at seducing.

Actually it was to point out it's easy to call a girl "easy" or a "skank" because you want to make a point; but you have no evidence any of that is true.

Nor does seducing a million women who are desperate and looking to be banged. Whatever you think, Leia was a lot harder to seduce than anyone Kirk tried.

And you have no evidence of the contrary, except I could point out that Leia hated Han when she met him so he was working from a disadvantage and his seduction powers took over form there. Kirk started out on an easier level.

Leia almost banged her own brother...hardly an example of "The Chaste and Pure Princess" :D

Oh, psh. PIS, Lucas had no clue what he was doing. :P And as far as we know, Princess Leia was as pure and innocent as they come. ;)

Lucas still has no clue what he's doing.

I also question the amount of time she spent alone with R2D2...

and as far as innocence goes...she kissed Luke the day she met him...and then Kissed him again just to make Han jealous.

#45 Posted by The Stegman (22798 posts) - - Show Bio

Solo solos

#46 Posted by Xanni15 (6758 posts) - - Show Bio

@Shawnbaby:

Uh... I have no official comment on that. It's about to get weird in here. XP

#47 Posted by Shawnbaby (10387 posts) - - Show Bio

In all seriousness...whether its a fistfight or a shootout I believe Kirk would win either way.

Kirk has h2h feats

Phasers are more accurate than Blasters.

#48 Posted by JayceeFoli (6 posts) - - Show Bio

OK I'll add to, To make it more realistic and give them both the benefit of there set skills. Kirk has to capture han. Can he do-it. He has his starship and resources, So does Han. Just remember, I think the Empire had more powerful ships and tech than the federation, and han has Outsmarted them. Yes, before anyone asks, han gets chewy and kirk can have spok.

#49 Posted by Quartermaim (617 posts) - - Show Bio

In a firefight Han would win without a problem. In a fist fight Kirk has this he's taken down people stronger than himbutself with is unique hand to hand combat skills. In a mixed fight I see Kirk winning but seriously injured with Han Knocked out. Krik would totally take him to a bar afterwards for Romulan ale.