#1 Posted by navkool (12 posts) - - Show Bio

Morals off

No prep

Fight takes place in New York City

#2 Posted by NeonGameWave (7784 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor.

#3 Posted by Simon_the_digger (2973 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor

#4 Posted by datguyobed (15 posts) - - Show Bio

Thor

#5 Posted by GypRosetti (347 posts) - - Show Bio

Icon is way too overpowered but doesn't have much in terms of feats.

http://www.comicvine.com/icon/29-47395/

Powers/Abilities
Icon is a powerful member of the Termian race, a powerful alien race whose abilities are similar in strength and power to Kryptonians under a yellow sun.
Superhuman Strength
Icon possess vast strength due to his alien heritage and the maximization of his DNA given him limitless strength. He has shown to be far more powerful then Superman.
Superhuman Speed
Icon possesses the ability to move at superhuman speeds, although his top speed is unknown. Icon has shown to be as fast as Flash himself, but since his top speed is unknown it's believed he is even faster then Flash.
Phasing
Icon can move through objects. He uses this power to ignore most attacks, physical dangers and gravity.
Invisibility
Icon has the power to become completely invisible at all levels, including heat and scent.
Superhuman Reflexes
Icon possesses the ability to think, move, and react at superhuman speeds.
Superhuman Stamina
Due to specialized training, Icon is now at the point were he no longer gets fatigue, thus granting him limitless stamina.
Flight
Icon flies by manipulation of gravitons, manipulation of magnetic fields, control of his absolute molecular movement, and utilizing his superhuman speed. Icon has shown that he can fly faster than the speed of light.
Superhuman Senses
Icon possesses superhuman senses of sight, smell, taste, touch, and hearing.
Self-Sustenance
Icon can survive in harsh environments without air, food or water. He's also able to survive unaided within the vacuum of space.
Enhanced Mental Perception
Icon is immune to all forms of mind control and possess a super genius intellect.
Superhuman Agility
Icon has perfect balance and/or perfect equilibrium to a point far in excess to that of a normal human being in Earth's gravity.
Invulnerability
Icon is capable of withstanding tremendous impact forces, high-caliber bullets, exposure to temperature and pressure extremes, and powerful energy blasts without sustaining injury.
Regenerative Healing Factor
When Icon is injured, his body is capable of quickly repairing damaged tissue, organs, and lost limbs.
Telepathy
Icon's telepathic abilities also allow him to create realistic illusions, trace and locate people, shut down people's minds, influence thoughts, and transfer information directly into people's brains.
Telekinesis
Icon is capable of controlling/manipulating objects even at the subatomic level.
Indomitable Will
Icon can control his emotions and impulses, overcome fear, and resist mind control.
Positronic Energy Manipulation
Icon is able to generate and manipulate positron energy. A low power force bolt can flick on a light switch while a force bolt at maximum power can stagger Superman, but the amount of damage a maximum power bolt can do is unknown. Icon uses his positron energy to construct tools, objects, weapons and other items, create semi-living constructs, and create structures/buildings. Icon's creations have been shown to be extremely powerful and durable. Icon can focus his positron energy into his fists or as a pulse, which he can then use to shatter any substance.
Optic Blast
Icon is able to project beams of pure heat from his eyes.
Energy Shield
Icon can create very powerful positron energy shields that can deflect energy as well as absorbed energy and turn it back on the person who discharged the energy.
Positron Field
Icon can detect the presence of Bang Babies within his vicinity by flooding an area with a field of positrons. The field interacts with the invisible quantum well surrounding a Bang Baby, who then glows as he or she gives off mild gamma particles. Hence, Icon can use these fields to distinguish Bang Babies from other metahumans as well as normal humans.
Shapeshifting
Icon can change his clothes and DNA structure at will. Icon can turn into other people, animals, and even other types of alien species. Icon's shapeshifting is so advanced, whatever he turns into, he can cops it's DNA structure perfectly.
Decelerated Aging
Icon possesses extraordinary longevity, enabling him to age at a vastly slower rate than that human beings. Hence, though centuries old, he appears to be no older than forty. Icon's lifespan is typical for a Terminan and the only power that is not the result of his genetic maximization. Icon will always be in top physical condition, but never show signs of old age.
Solar/Lunar Battery
Icon is capable of absorbing energy from all types of suns. Icon is also able to absorb the light of the moon. Icon's cells are capable of retain the light from the sun and moon at the same time. Icon can use the energy to increase his powers, and the light from the Moon and Sun can revive Icon.
Highly Advanced Master Combatant
Icon is well trained in unarmed and armed combat, having fought in major conflicts ranging from the Civil War to World War II. Some opponents underestimate Icon because of his initial attempts of diplomacy.
Bilingual
Icon is fluent in English and Galactic Standard, the native language of the Cooperative. Icon can instantly learn and translate any language perfectly when he hears it, reads it, or sees it.
#6 Posted by Postacrat (496 posts) - - Show Bio

This battle may have been done before and I believe Icon won the majority votes.  Icon is on Par with Superman in strength and has a plethora of other powers at his disposal and he has no magical weaknesses.   This guy rocked Superman on at least two occasions and Supes has said himself that nobody has ever hit him harder than Icon.  Think Superman with all of his powers except without the weakness to Kryptonite or magic add Telepathy, Telekinesis, energy manipulation, energy shield, shapeshifting etc.  He is part of an alien race that is similar to Kryptonians under a yellow sun.  Come on let's be honest Thor has been a joke lately, powerful he may be but he's not beating Icon.  If not for a lack of feats it is still very debatable if Icon may even be more powerful than Superman.