Ichigo vs Naruto vs Luffy vs Natsu

Luffy and Zoro (east blue)

Natsu and Gray (current)

Ichigo and Renji (end of SS arc)

Naruto and Sasuke (pre-shippuden

Morals on but going for the kill

Natsu, Ichigo or Luffy.

@dbvse7: reasons?

Naruto has chance as well

Luffy.

@nyas: reasons?

Natsu.

Do you mean the feats during that one episode or the character at that moment.He's probably referring to the second choice which is true.

@sondeatheater: the character at that moment

Flashback feats work too

Very first episode for all? Luffy because I don't really think anyone here can hurt him at this point.

@cosmic_lantern: why not? I'm pretty sure all have sharp weapons? Espicially Kurosaki

Luffy can basically do all the things he could do in East Blue.Chapter 1 of the manga, he one shotted a sea monster with a casual technique.

A volume afterward, he's shown doing things like deflecting cannon balls even though he hasn't actually improved in the series until Alabasta apparently

He also fought with a guy who threw water droplets with the force of a shotgun which requires supersonic+ speed, launch people out of towns, took a cutting attack that could easily cut thick trees to the head to simply being angered.

@sondeatheater: how does he beat the other contenders?

Because

a)they are below supersonic at that time so they can't touch him

b)they don't have enough fire power to even exhaust or put down Luffy

c)Luffy can one shot all of them

@sondeatheater: ok

Natsu or Luffy

Please edit this to give everyone (and by everyone i mean Naruto, Natsu and Ichigo) a fighting chance.

STATS are:

*Ichigo:

Speed level = human

Durability = fodder Combat ability = unskilled

Strength = negligible

*Naruto:

Speed = human

Durabilhty = fodder

Combat ability = stupid

Strength = negligible

*Natsu:

Speed = human

Durability = slightly fodder

Combat ability = below average or average

Strength = above average

*Luffy:

Speed = above average

Combat ability = feral

Durabiliy = impervious to what most of these guys have

Strength = very high

Luffy rather easily.

luffy=was a little kid ,not so impressive.

Naruto=a loser nontheless.

Ichigo= it took him a lot time to become impressive

Natsu= was actually pretty powerful. Even distroyed a port thus winner

@A1l_S2a3m4E5N: what? natsu distroyed a port in intro episode. what human can do that?

First episode wise Luffy solostomps everyone.

Current versions, however...

From what I recall of the first episodes:

Naruto: capable of creating over a thousand clones, and slightly superhuman stats and skill considering the attack on mizuki.

ichigo: one showing of killing a superhunan monster, casually cutting it's arm. Possible superhuman speed with no durability feats.

Natsu: ate fire to punch a man across the city and caused a lot of destruction.

Luffy: took down dozens of fodder, a pirate captain. Strong enough to break a barrel and send a big person flying.

...overall,

natsu doesn't have any feats without the fire amp available here.

naruto has the advantage against the other two due to clones but cannot take down luffy (he didn't use kunai/shuriken iirc)

Luffy easy.

Either Luffy or Natsu. Naruto was pretty pathetic in his first chapter, and Ichigo also had almost no power other than being top human level and having a huge sword (did he even get the sword in the first chapter? I feel that didn't come until chapter 2 or 3...)

Luffy on the other hand could one-shot a massive sea creature and Natsu could destroy a port and his fire would allow him to negate Luffy's number 1 defensive advantage, so they'd be on a pretty even playing field I think.

Lelouch vi Britannia stomps all

.

.

.

.

.

.

Oops, wrong thread

I said natsus strength was above average. and hundred clones not useful here except against ichigo.

Luffy

@theirishdoctor: did luffy beat the sea king in episode 1 or 2? Iirc it was second? Natsu had just eaten a fireball.. wouldn't that count as amp? lol

@PrinceAragorn1: sea monster not king.

and if natsu was amped in first cha. then he can be used in amped state.

even thought i cant say he was amped just because he ate some fire.

Natsu and Luffy kill the other two quickly and fight it out. Idk who wins this but I'd think Natsu because of his fire. I'll say Natsu 6/10.

dont know if it was ep2 but it was not ep1

ep1 feats are only beating Alvida and her men iirc

@princearagorn1:

Luffy would have zero chance vs Sea Kings, even currently.

They're so big they could effectively sink islands.

Natsu actually stomps this

@brainstorm01: @itachi_totsukablitz: Sea monster. Okay,

It would be Natsu vs Luffy and this is where it gets difficult to decide due to the lack of feats.

luffy

@a1l_s2a3m4e5n: edited op

is everyone forgetting naruto still has kurama chakra and gamabunta in chunin exams?

The op edited, originally it was end of episode 1 for each character.

@nyas ahhh got it.

Luffy's the biggest threat, 2nd place is Naruto, since Gaara was a threat even Jonin couldn't take down.

With these versions? Luffy most likely.

Edited op

@itachi_totsukablitz: Luffy even need to move to deal with sea kings now lol.

From the edited OP, Ichigo curbs pretty handily, he's wayyy too fast for anybody here.

Luffy >>>> Natsu >>> Ichigo > Naruto.

Jmarshmallow

These versions? Ichigo stomps by blitzing everyone here.

Ichigo> Natsu >Naruto >Luffy

IMHO