Hit Girl vs Punisher (movie versions)

War Zone Punisher

Hit Girl

Rules

• Morals off
• Standard equipment
• Takes place in warehouse
• No prep
• KO or Death

Feats for Punisher

Punisher

Punisher but very close like 5.5/10 IMO

War Zone Punisher is freakin brutal. Holy hell lol. I'm taking him.

It's probably awful but now i'm gonna check it out

Never saw War Zone, but his speed doesn't seem all that impressive. Was the movie any good?

Good question because I have not seen the movie.

He blitzed hordes and hordes of armed men, was closer to the comic book version. He also punched through someone's face. And the movie was crap.

WZ was brutal... but nothing HG cannot handle. She takes him to school.

good day

@frozen: So what you are saying is, I would do best to just watch the clip montage and save myself the rental fee? Gotcha=)

Regardless, think I'll go against the grain and back movie Hit Girl for a slight majority. It would be a good fight though.

@wyldsong: Yes, watch the clip - it demonstrates all of his kills/vast gear.

Oh boy what is with all these kick ass battles I dont know I think punisher will win

MONGOOSE

Punisher punches her face off.

Punisher

Standard equipment for warzone Punisher is too much.

This. She is faster and would actually beat him in CQC, he was getting beat by a detective and a louny guy. Sure there was a tad more context, but Hit-Girl is simply better imho.

Yeah, he guns down lots of guys, lots of good action. Yet again his H2H skill was lacking (like Thomas Jane Punisher), he would get dominated imho if this was no guns, with guns It could be closer. But I am still giving Mindy the edge.

Punisher all day every day wins as this won't be a hand to hand encounter even thou Hit girl scenes were extremely exaggerated for a human being.

That of the Punisher, it looked normal? xD

She actually could win if she use properly adrenaline.

@allstarsuperman:

"This. She is faster and would actually beat him in CQC, he was getting beat by a detective and a louny guy. Sure there was a tad more context, but Hit-Girl is simply better imho"

I think you know full well there's more than a "tad" of context you're choosing to leave out. I don't even care about the thread, I just don't see why you have to so blatantly lowball the character. I've already explained the context so I don't feel like there's a need to do it twice

Lmao...the number of Hit-Girl threads is growing by the day!...it's the Hit-Girl fever! lol.

Not growing. Just getting repeatedly bumped.

Link?

@frozen:

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles-7/big-daddy-vs-punisher-movie-versions-1594879/#28

Post 18 I believe

Punisher

Like what? Why are you freaking out. All I said was his H2H really is not that good. He was more a brawler. And Mindy is simply better, Punisher never shown skill on the level of killing someone with their own finger. Sure his assault rifles and automatic handguns would be a problem, but I think HG can close the gap.

@allstarsuperman:

This. She is faster and would actually beat him in CQC, he was getting beat by a detective and a louny guy. Sure there was a tad more context, but Hit-Girl is simply better imho.

...We don't even wanna play this that way, especially with the infamous Frank debate people would bring in?

Let's just do this clean.

The Indoor advantage is very huge for her, because she was amazingly accurate up close.

He's obviously stronger & I would think overall more durable.

She is much faster, but she's untaggable here.

She has the advantage of adrenaline, but she will have to time it right as to when to use it.

She has seemingly more versatile weapons, but he has the overall better weapons. He has better guns: he had machine guns, and explosives.

I believe he has has armor piercing rounds, I think he had that convo with the fat guy.

He's got a automatic weapon with a grenade launcher, logically honestly he wins the majority.

I would love to see a CaV on this though, battlefield shouldn't be a Warehouse though. Honestly he doesn't even have to be very accurate here he can just spray like a mother...I'm actually going to go 10/10, he has some majorly unfair weapons advantages here.

@frozen: You need to take away his machine guns and explosives. It's got to many weapon advantages.

My favorite Punisher video is Punisher: Dirty Laundry.

@wyldsong:

You can watch it here. :)

Yeah, that's the major problem here, his arsenal is too much, even though Hit Girl has more variety, he has too many advantages with automatic weapons, machine guns, and explosives.

weapons: both use military grade weapons but the punisher is exstensivly skilled to the point not only is he a master marksman he is also a master gunsmith and moddifies the weapons he uses.

armor: it does show that hit girl has used body armor but given her size and age she is using either level iiia armor plates or the III rifle plates. the punisher with his size and stature would be able to accommodate the thick and heavy level IV rifle plates. now if your going with the warzone punisher you have to add the .500S&W which would punch a hole through a anything less than a level III rifle plate. if hit girl lived she would be knocked out by the shear force of the round.

hand to hand combat: hit girl is fast and agile this doesnt make up for the experience, strength, and endurence that the punisher has. its even been comented by several people in the marvel universe that the punisher has a very high thresh hold for pain to the point that he doesnt use painkillers or any narcotic for fear of dulling his senses.

victor: the punisher