Heavy Rain vs the Last of Us

2 vs 2, fight to the death- Takes place in an abandoned warehouse- No prep, random encounter

Norman Jayden and Scott Shelby from Heavy Rain

Joel and Ellie from the Last of Us

Well, Ellie is probably one of the toughest little girls around, but she's still a little girl. Heavy Rain has the advantage right off the bat.

Norman and Shelby have the advantage of actual training on their side, but Joel most definitely still has the better feats (the big black guy in the garage who nearly killed Jayden would get stomped by Joel for example)

Shelby actually has pretty impressive gun skills as per the final sequence of his game... but so does Joel. And we can assume Norman has more than Ellie at least.

However, I just can't picture Joel losing here. He's outmatched throughout the entire game but always wins through wits and stealth. He can do it here to, and Ellie is a big help. Last of Us ftw.

Nice match btw.

@nickzambuto: thanks :) and awesome breakdown! These are my two favourite games, so when I thought that the characters could have a pretty even fight I had to create a battle :D

@masteraction: I'd love to comment but I've yet to acquire funding to purchase The Last of Us. :-(

@the_last_son_of_czarnia: it will be well worth the wait my friend :)

I`m going with team Heavy Rain, this matchup is awesome and unique!!

@neongamewave: thank you, glad you like it :)

Bump since I've just completed Heavy Rain.

Norman is a weak link. Scott is actually pretty impressive but he would still get beaten even by Ellie. Team 2 stomps.

@nickzambuto: Little girl or not, she takes down legions of battle hardened men. Like when Joel was injured.

"Legions" is definitely an overstatement, I don't believe there was ever a point where she fought more than half a dozen men.