Who takes the win?
No parallax kthx. Regular Hal, one GL ring, standard equipment.
Composite rainbow Hal can shut up.
I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have.
" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
Oh, man, much as I love Hal Jordan......oy...Silver Surfer would probably take it. The fact of the matter is, Silver Surfer wields the Power Cosmic, and can survive in most any environment, especially space, a lot longer than Hal.
Remember, Hal is still human despite his powerful GL ring, and would eventually tire. Surfer doesn't have such weaknesses, is near invulnerable. Yes, Hal can erect a protective aura and all, but how long can he maintain it? His willpower is key, but again, natural fatigue would set in.
Also, keep in mind Surfer's strength is incredible, in the 100 Class, or am I mistaken? I can't recall, I should look it up but I am going off memory here. Yes Hal can use the ring to assist in the strength department, but Surfer's strength is not dependent on a ring nor anything else.
Also, I think given the powerful cosmic nature of Surfer's blasts, they'd tear right through anything Hal would create and shoot.
I really, really want to say Hal, but just due to the fact how incredibly powerful Surfer is, he'd take it.
I could be wrong.
Hal Jordan could win and thats who my vote is for. Silver Surfer is very powerful, but the green lantern ring is one of the most powerful weapons ever made. Both Hal and Norrin have had their powers bestowed upon them by very powerful immortals. I just think Hal is the better warrior here.
"@Emerald_General_Jai said:How the hell is Hal as strong as the Silver Surfer ? The Surfer has a far greater range with his powers... "" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
"@King Saturn said:Most of which can be accomplished w/ a GL ring if used correctly. If you go based on the normal everyday powerset they use (not their most exotic) Hal can match him in EP blasts and has his constructs. Norrin isn't really a warrior, whereas Hal is. I don't think he can simply overpower him, or any GL really (w/e gap there is, it isn't that large) and Hal has what he needs to beat SS. ""@Emerald_General_Jai said:How the hell is Hal as strong as the Silver Surfer ? The Surfer has a far greater range with his powers... "" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
"@Emerald_General_Jai said:Rephrase: how do you know what the gap is? because their powers are similar or what?""@King Saturn said:Most of which can be accomplished w/ a GL ring if used correctly. If you go based on the normal everyday powerset they use (not their most exotic) Hal can match him in EP blasts and has his constructs. Norrin isn't really a warrior, whereas Hal is. I don't think he can simply overpower him, or any GL really (w/e gap there is, it isn't that large) and Hal has what he needs to beat SS. ""@Emerald_General_Jai said:How the hell is Hal as strong as the Silver Surfer ? The Surfer has a far greater range with his powers... "" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
Surfer can win and Hal can win. Its very close.
I think Hal might take it since his personality is more hardcore, if we stay true to Surfer the Silver guy is a peacemaker. He came from a peaceful race, he likes to talk while fighting and never totally unleashes himself say like doing something totally hardcore like turning his opponent to vapor. Surfer is not a true destructive fighter, just an advanced man transformed by Galactus with incredible powers. I think Hal will be able to eventually do something to win
That's not saying Surfer can't win, the fight could easily go his way. A GL once lost to Silver Surfer, there is no shame in it. Surfer is incredibly powerful can beat just about anyone, Wonder Woman, Superman maybe even stomp Darkseid.
if we stay true to Surfer's personality I think Hal can win since he's more aggressive and cunning
Hal wins, just barely
" Yeah maybe I'm a little biased saying Hal takes itSurfer can probably win this "
i'd bet that Norrin could drain Hal's ring and leave him powerless. even if he couldn't, Norrin is nigh invulnerable and is far faster and stronger. Plus, his energy projection is arguably higher.
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;)" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
" @Sexy Merc said:He always was in my eyes, even as a kid, lol. I just finished my collection of every appearance he has in comics a week ago. Had to buy that hideous Marvel vs DC crossover." @The Mjolnir Wielder said:Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;) "" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:I sold that crossover already, 99.9% of the fans had no idea where any of them stood as characters." @Sexy Merc said:He always was in my eyes, even as a kid, lol. I just finished my collection of every appearance he has in comics a week ago. Had to buy that hideous Marvel vs DC crossover. "" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;) "" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
"Silver Surfer takes down a large section of the Green Lanterns by himself."No, he doesn't
" @Sexy Merc said:Well, I had to make sure I had all of his appearances and to my knowledge, I finally do." @The Mjolnir Wielder said:I sold that crossover already, 99.9% of the fans had no idea where any of them stood as characters. "" @Sexy Merc said:He always was in my eyes, even as a kid, lol. I just finished my collection of every appearance he has in comics a week ago. Had to buy that hideous Marvel vs DC crossover. "" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;) "" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
" @Sexy Merc said:Pre-Crisis Hal would win pretty easily." @difficlus said:If we were going by classic versions? =] "" SS wins this probably 10/10 "Using only current versions, he maxes out at 8. "
" @Sexy Merc said:He's been able to react to people like Hank who has higher combat speed than Surfer and he's able to physically compete with class 100s. On top of that, he is very versatile." @difficlus said:how does Hal win the other 2 times? "" SS wins this probably 10/10 "Using only current versions, he maxes out at 8. "
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment