I'd say that John Stewart and Alan Scott would be the easy front runners here, due to John's mastery of USMC Combatives and Alan's training under the late Charles McNider (the 1st Dr. Mid-Nite), the late Terry Sloane (the 1st Mr. Terrific), and his continuing training under/with Wildcat over the past 60 years or so takes him WAY outside of the novice bracket. I'd say that Hal might come in third due to combat training in the USAF, and while Kyle got embarrassed in h2h by Sinestro during the Darkest Night, he lasted longer than Guy did against Batman (lol). I don't know who "Baz" is, so I won't speak on (Is Baz a guy)?
@beatboks1: Alan comes last because without starheart power he will cease to exist
Damn. If he could still remain mortal without his powers, he'd be tied with John in first place. But alas...:(
@frozenphoenix: LOL! Thanks, bro!
@moonman78: John, and then guy, the rest is a wash
Didn't Hal already beat Guy in h2h combat twice before without his ring on? I could be wrong, but I could've sworn that Hal put him in his place already.