1.I see your point.I didn't know Batman reminds Deadshot of his brother.If it's valid,then I am convinced.Good point btw.
2.I understand what you are saying but there comes another question to be put in the game.Why would Grodd chose to mind control Shiva if not for her fighting skill?
I don't know. Maybe she still had access to her technique and it was just the way she chooses to use her technique.
This reminds of a movie called the Game with Gerard Butler.I don't know if you 've seen it but it actually explains what you just posted.
Pre new 52,all of their fights indicated that either Shiva is slightly more skilled or they are just equals.
I haven't seen that movie but I think we are in agreement. Personally I think batman and shiva are about equal skill wise.
3.As for the new 52,I believe Batman is the superior h2h combatant because of more feats.
Well,the debate started cause a hothead said Shiva has 'stomped Batman in almost all their fights'.Shiva only stomped Batman once with the help of a poison dart in the new 52.I just wanted to make it clear.