Greatest Asset to Xmen?

Who would they miss the most?

Round 1 Comics

Rond 2 Films

Wolverine Cyclops storm

@heymanjack: thats 3 and you didn't specify which category, try again..

Round 1 Hope Summers, Round 2 Hugh Jackman

@The_Mayhem_Theory: so you think he should stay because he can't die and is popular as a pose to a unique skill set he can provide?@BringnIt: Don't you think seeing as they started off without her they could probably continue without her?

@The_Mayhem_Theory: so you think he should stay because he can't die and is popular as a pose to a unique skill set he can provide?@BringnIt: Don't you think seeing as they started off without her they could probably continue without her?

@The_Mayhem_Theory: I think they could function without him, as all he seems to bring to the team is his strength and semi invinciblity, both of which can kind of be replicated by colossus

@The_Mayhem_Theory: I think they could function without him, as all he seems to bring to the team is his strength and semi invinciblity, both of which can kind of be replicated by colossus

@The_Thunderer They would miss Hope the most because of her theorized potential to jump start he mutant race again. After House of M, no mutant is more pivotal.

Prof X (he kinda made the whole team himself)

@BringnIt: ah cool.. @troller if you watch xmen 3 you can see that they have managed to function ok without the professor..

@The_Thunderer: This was an application for the comic round.

And how well would they have functioned had Prof X never made the team (answer= not well)

@troller: i think you misunderstand the thread, its not who is the best to start it, but onc it was formed, who was irreplacable?

@The_Thunderer: Still prof X.

Plus the OP didn't specify, so don't blame me for your inability to make usable OPs

Round 1. Professor X

Round 2. even though the x men lost the professor they did well without him, so I'll have to say storm or kitty pride.

Professor X

@Rainy: KITTY PRIDE?!!!!!

WHAAAAAAAAAAT?!!!!

@troller said:

@Rainy: KITTY PRIDE?!!!!!

WHAAAAAAAAAAT?!!!!

Movie version is just a girl if she dies everybody would feel like shit since she was so young and innocent.

Wolverine for Both Round IMO :)

@Rainy: I would have felt happy if she died, but that's just me

@troller said:

@Rainy: I would have felt happy if she died, but that's just me

Cause she insulted the Juggernaut?

Professor X is not that pivotal anymore. He's come and gone many times throughout the X-Men's history and they got along just fine, principally because of Mr. Scott Summers.

If we're talking ALL TIME most pivotal X-Man, then yes, perhaps Xavier is our guy. He started it after all.

If we're going with most recent; Cyclops, Wolverine & Hope are the top ringers.

Wolverine because he's now running the only school for mutants. He is also an integral part of the Avengers and therefore in a position to bring a more 'heroic' light on mutants (say what you want about him, he tries to embody honor and integrity - however misguided at times).

Cyclops because of his leadership and commitment. Period.

Hope because she's the best chance the mutants have at a better tomorrow (apparently).

Comics: Cyclops

Movies: Wolverine.

No mention of Storm or Colossus, have they got replacements or are they just unnecessary?

Who would they miss the most?

Wolverine for 1 and 2, he is the best and coolest and most popular

@Namtomex: @Rainy: I'll just add I kinda meant miss in terms of leave a big gap in the team e.g. if their only psycic left, it could cost them, not as in who is the most popular

@The_Thunderer said:

@Namtomex: @Rainy: I'll just add I kinda meant miss in terms of leave a big gap in the team e.g. if their only psycic left, it could cost them, not as in who is the most popular

It would be scott and wolverine.

Well if cyke,wolvie,and storm are gone then who would lead the x-men?

@stormphoenix said:

Well if cyke,wolvie,and storm are gone then who would lead the x-men?

Beast,Magneto,Mystique,ect,

@stormphoenix: Beast, Hope, Colossus, Ice man, Angel

@Rainy: No, because I know that I will never have her

@The_Mayhem_Theory: Laura is actually soooo much different that wolvy although I would LOVE to see her take his spot ^_^

@FourthDeity: I wouldn't

@troller: chill out

@The_Thunderer: I can't help how hot I am

Easily Magneto. They wouldn't have the experience, dedication, and discipline had he not been such a dangerous enemy so early, and for so long. On the other side, when he's on the team he's invaluable. His power has saved them many times, his leadership is second to none... Without him on one side or the other, the'd be lost.

@troller said:

@Rainy: No, because I know that I will never have her

Psssh you deserve better ;D

Comics - Hard to say. I think the X-Men who have added the most value and influence is Xavier, Wolverine, Storm & Cyclops. I also think Magneto deserves a mention.

Movies - Storm, Wolverine & Magneto

@Rainy: Can I have you

PLEEEEEEEEEEEASE?

@troller: shut up and get off my threads.

All members of the Extinction team

@troller said:

@Rainy: Can I have you

PLEEEEEEEEEEEASE?

If I was female maybe.

Wolverine easy. Now he's even the leader of the first x men nonsense.

@Rainy: How do you know that I am not female?

And you have no choice, soon you must sleep....

@ozeol: sorry who?

@The_Thunderer:

All members of the Extinction team

That is what he said in case you missed it.

You can thank me later

@troller: perhaps if you look closely i said "who", the answer to which would be the members of the extinction team, whereas you have either misread or are stupid and so answered my question (which was never for you) as though I had mis heard what ozeol had said.