• 108 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
#1 Posted by heymanjack (713 posts) - - Show Bio

Who wins this one?

They fight serious here. No playing around.

Magneto starts with his shields up.

No BFR's just a fight to the death/KO

#2 Posted by heymanjack (713 posts) - - Show Bio

Bump

#3 Posted by AssertingValor (5574 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto .. if the surroundings are equally suited to both characters....

#4 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

Grand Master Luke easily...

#5 Posted by Magethor (1054 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto bends the light of the light saber since he controls photons and plasma.

#6 Posted by MrBossAwesomeDude (238 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto wins. He is too much of a badass for Grand Master Luke to handle. Plus Luke has a hand made of metal and a metal handled light saber. It could possibly be a good fight though if Luke could somehow force shield his hand and saber, but I don't see Luke getting through Mags shield. An knowing Mags, first thing he will do is crush the saber.

#7 Posted by FMStyyx (738 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto takes control of the light saber and tries to kill luke with it while throwing other metalish material at him.. luke would prolly use force push but i dnt think hed be able to keep up with the number of objects..

#8 Posted by MrBossAwesomeDude (238 posts) - - Show Bio

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

#9 Posted by FMStyyx (738 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

#10 Edited by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Magneto wins. He is too much of a badass for Grand Master Luke to handle. Plus Luke has a hand made of metal and a metal handled light saber. It could possibly be a good fight though if Luke could somehow force shield his hand and saber, but I don't see Luke getting through Mags shield. An knowing Mags, first thing he will do is crush the saber.

Whether he crushes the saber or not is irrelevant. Luke can still spank him with the Force, and can speedblitz him before he can crush any saber.

#11 Posted by JediWaffles (746 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

Damnit, you always beat me to it. Anyway, yeah, Luke speedblitzes Magneto.

#12 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@JediWaffles said:

@ShootingNova said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

Damnit, you always beat me to it. Anyway, yeah, Luke speedblitzes Magneto.

LOL, at least you agree.

#13 Posted by FMStyyx (738 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Magneto wins. He is too much of a badass for Grand Master Luke to handle. Plus Luke has a hand made of metal and a metal handled light saber. It could possibly be a good fight though if Luke could somehow force shield his hand and saber, but I don't see Luke getting through Mags shield. An knowing Mags, first thing he will do is crush the saber.

Whether he crushes the saber is irrelevant. Luke can still spank him with the Force, and can speedblitz him before he can crush any saber.

i didnt know he could do that :)

GL needs to get off his lazy bum and get some more movies or REAL good games out for star wars..

in episode one qui-gon and obi used a force dash or something and they were gone like in a flash whats that called??

#14 Edited by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@FMStyyx said:

@ShootingNova said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Magneto wins. He is too much of a badass for Grand Master Luke to handle. Plus Luke has a hand made of metal and a metal handled light saber. It could possibly be a good fight though if Luke could somehow force shield his hand and saber, but I don't see Luke getting through Mags shield. An knowing Mags, first thing he will do is crush the saber.

Whether he crushes the saber is irrelevant. Luke can still spank him with the Force, and can speedblitz him before he can crush any saber.

i didnt know he could do that :)

GL needs to get off his lazy bum and get some more movies or REAL good games out for star wars..

in episode one qui-gon and obi used a force dash or something and they were gone like in a flash whats that called??

Force Speed. Luke can move so fast Anakin and Leia can't even see him, only sense him as a blur of Light Side energy.

#15 Posted by JediWaffles (746 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: Only problem i could see here though is if Magneto's shield could somehow negate the effects of the Force against him.

#16 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@JediWaffles said:

@ShootingNova: Only problem i could see here though is if Magneto's shield could somehow negate the effects of the Force against him.

Not if they are used before he can react. Same conclusion as in the Magneto vs. Sith Council thread, search it up yourself if you need to see it.

#17 Posted by FMStyyx (738 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova said:

@FMStyyx said:

@ShootingNova said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Magneto wins. He is too much of a badass for Grand Master Luke to handle. Plus Luke has a hand made of metal and a metal handled light saber. It could possibly be a good fight though if Luke could somehow force shield his hand and saber, but I don't see Luke getting through Mags shield. An knowing Mags, first thing he will do is crush the saber.

Whether he crushes the saber is irrelevant. Luke can still spank him with the Force, and can speedblitz him before he can crush any saber.

i didnt know he could do that :)

GL needs to get off his lazy bum and get some more movies or REAL good games out for star wars..

in episode one qui-gon and obi used a force dash or something and they were gone like in a flash whats that called??

Force Speed. Luke can move so fast Anakin and Leia can't even see him, only sense him as a blur of Light Side energy.

Force speed.. interesting.. what is GL doing the star wars brand has so much that could be done with it and all hes doin is making these really bad games.. lego, knect, and something else :/

#18 Posted by JediWaffles (746 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: No, but Mags starts with his shields up according to the OP.

#19 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@JediWaffles said:

@ShootingNova: No, but Mags starts with his shields up according to the OP.

Luke force crushes him, scares him to death with an illusion, owns him with an Force Power that afflicts him internally, or just Forces him to deactivate it or deactivates it himself.

#20 Posted by JediWaffles (746 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: I was sort of thinking along the lines that an argument could be made that Mags' shield prevents any influence from the Force at all. Making him thereby immune to Luke's Force skills. The illusion would still work though, so i guess Luke still wins, but only in a limited way.

#21 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@JediWaffles said:

@ShootingNova: I was sort of thinking along the lines that an argument could be made that Mags' shield prevents any influence from the Force at all. Making him thereby immune to Luke's Force skills. The illusion would still work though, so i guess Luke still wins, but only in a limited way.

He could make Magneto suicide with it. He has countless more telepathic/mental/internal assaults and attacks, he could just crush is body from the inside, wore it apart from the inside, or blow it apart from the inside.

#22 Posted by JediWaffles (746 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: Do Mags' shield prevent telepathic/mental assaults? Also, if you use the Force to crush someone internally, where does the Force originate? From Luke, or directly from within the intended target?

#23 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@JediWaffles said:

@ShootingNova: Do Mags' shield prevent telepathic/mental assaults? Also, if you use the Force to crush someone internally, where does the Force originate? From Luke, or directly from within the intended target?

It doesn't go externally, it blows the target apart from the inside the energy is concentrated in Magneto, so he can't stop it.

#24 Posted by JediWaffles (746 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: I see. Well, that's about the only thing i wanted to clarify. This thread seems about wrapped up.

#25 Posted by Nessy (569 posts) - - Show Bio

All these Star Wars threads where people only judge the Jedi by their high end feats.

If people did that with Marvel and DC characters half of them would be celestial level, since at one point or another they have all done some ridiculous thing once that they never do again.

#26 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@Nessy said:

All these Star Wars threads where people only judge the Jedi by their high end feats.

If people did that with Marvel and DC characters half of them would be celestial level, since at one point or another they have all done some ridiculous thing once that they never do again.

So your point is?

#27 Posted by MrBossAwesomeDude (238 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto can track metal. Lukes hand is metal he can just kill him with his own hand right from the beginning, plus Mags has some good reaction speeds.

#28 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Magneto can track metal. Lukes hand is metal he can just kill him with his own hand right from the beginning, plus Mags has some good reaction speeds.

Firstly, you need to check the Magneto vs Sith Council thread, it ended with Sidious speedblitzing him. Luke can move just as fast, if not faster. He moves so fast Force-Sensitives, not to mention those who aren't, to see. Anakin has sublight combat speed, he couldn't even see Sidious, Luke fought just as fast.

#29 Posted by MrBossAwesomeDude (238 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: That's a different battle though and Sidious doesn't have a huge chunk of metal in his body for Mags to see/manipulate.

#30 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@ShootingNova: That's a different battle though and Sidious doesn't have a huge chunk of metal in his body for Mags to see/manipulate.

Its not huge, not much difference given how I was talking about speed here, and Sidious has a lightsaber. Still. you have yet to prove Magneto can even react to Luke Skywalker's speed. Silver is an expert on SW and knows a lot about Magneto and said that Luke/Palpatine would speedblitz him.

#31 Posted by MrBossAwesomeDude (238 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: Mags stopped a giant metal bullet in space moving at light speeds. Lukes hand is his downfall.

#32 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@ShootingNova: Mags stopped a giant metal bullet in space moving at light speeds. Lukes hand is his downfall.

Not if Luke can move faster than Magneto can react.

#33 Posted by MrBossAwesomeDude (238 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova: Can he move faster than light? Cause Mags can see metal no matter how fast its going.

#34 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@ShootingNova: Can he move faster than light? Cause Mags can see metal no matter how fast its going.

Perhaps he can. His lightsaber can. Luke moves faster than Force-Sensitives (who can see and predict things accurately before they happen) can see.

#35 Posted by Nessy (569 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova said:

@Nessy said:

All these Star Wars threads where people only judge the Jedi by their high end feats.

If people did that with Marvel and DC characters half of them would be celestial level, since at one point or another they have all done some ridiculous thing once that they never do again.

So your point is?

My point is that Luke has a few high end feats that put him above Magneto's average feats, while Magneto's high end feats shame Luke.

If you don't see it unfair that people are judging Luke only at what he is absolutely theoretically capable of and ignoring his usual average self, while everyone just compares him vs Magneto's mid-level feats then maybe the battle section isn't the place for you.

#36 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@Nessy said:

@ShootingNova said:

@Nessy said:

All these Star Wars threads where people only judge the Jedi by their high end feats.

If people did that with Marvel and DC characters half of them would be celestial level, since at one point or another they have all done some ridiculous thing once that they never do again.

So your point is?

My point is that Luke has a few high end feats that put him above Magneto's average feats, while Magneto's high end feats shame Luke.

If you don't see it unfair that people are judging Luke only at what he is absolutely theoretically capable of and ignoring his usual average self, while everyone just compares him vs Magneto's mid-level feats then maybe the battle section isn't the place for you.

If you know nothing about Luke, don't post. Luke has a HORRENDOUS amount of powers he could use to obliterate Magneto.

#37 Posted by MrBossAwesomeDude (238 posts) - - Show Bio

Idk much on the Star Wars universe except what I've seen on the movies lol. To me though it seems like his hand and saber will be his downfall. Mags has some really good reaction times when it comes to metal.

#38 Posted by ShootingNova (19894 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Idk much on the Star Wars universe except what I've seen on the movies lol. To me though it seems like his hand and saber will be his downfall. Mags has some really good reaction times when it comes to metal.

Read the novels then. You need to know what Luke can do before arguing like that.

#39 Posted by Bo88gdan (4864 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto Ftw

#40 Posted by Fetts (4580 posts) - - Show Bio

Magneto dies horribly.

#41 Edited by daak1212 (7867 posts) - - Show Bio

@ShootingNova said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Magneto wins. He is too much of a badass for Grand Master Luke to handle. Plus Luke has a hand made of metal and a metal handled light saber. It could possibly be a good fight though if Luke could somehow force shield his hand and saber, but I don't see Luke getting through Mags shield. An knowing Mags, first thing he will do is crush the saber.

Whether he crushes the saber or not is irrelevant. Luke can still spank him with the Force, and can speedblitz him before he can crush any saber.

No it didn't the hell are you talking about? It ended with me and Silver giving up because he kept on plugging drain and I said his EM link would stop that. SIdious isn't going to CHARGE HIM WHICH SPEED BLITZ IS. Even Silver said Sidious isn't that fast

#42 Posted by The_Thunderer (2894 posts) - - Show Bio

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Idk much on the Star Wars universe except what I've seen on the movies lol. To me though it seems like his hand and saber will be his downfall. Mags has some really good reaction times when it comes to metal.

Luke in the novels > Sidious,

" > Yoda and Mace

> Anakin

>Obi-Wan

> Vader

> Emperor

no one in the movies is even remotely a threat to Grand Master Luke excpet Yoda.

#43 Posted by VercingetorixTheGreat (2823 posts) - - Show Bio

@FMStyyx said:

@ShootingNova said:

@FMStyyx said:

@ShootingNova said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

No. Do you even know how powerful Grand Master Luke is? The Magneto vs. Sith Council thread ended with Sidious speedblitzing him, Luke can move just as fast, can speedblitz Magneto, one shot him with telekinetic abilities like Electric Judgment and Lonize. Even if Magneto can manipulate Luke's lightsaber, Luke can control it far better, as Mag doesn't have the Force. Luke can just telekinetically get it back, or telekinetically wield it against Magneto.

@FMStyyx said:

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

@FMStyyx: If Luke is holding his metal handled light saber in his metal hand... He will be screwed from the start lol.

Oh yea, i forgot about that hand.. yea.. its connected to his nerves too, magnus wins

No.

@MrBossAwesomeDude said:

Magneto wins. He is too much of a badass for Grand Master Luke to handle. Plus Luke has a hand made of metal and a metal handled light saber. It could possibly be a good fight though if Luke could somehow force shield his hand and saber, but I don't see Luke getting through Mags shield. An knowing Mags, first thing he will do is crush the saber.

Whether he crushes the saber is irrelevant. Luke can still spank him with the Force, and can speedblitz him before he can crush any saber.

i didnt know he could do that :)

GL needs to get off his lazy bum and get some more movies or REAL good games out for star wars..

in episode one qui-gon and obi used a force dash or something and they were gone like in a flash whats that called??

Force Speed. Luke can move so fast Anakin and Leia can't even see him, only sense him as a blur of Light Side energy.

Force speed.. interesting.. what is GL doing the star wars brand has so much that could be done with it and all hes doin is making these really bad games.. lego, knect, and something else :/

star wars 1313 looks good. But damnit GL give us battlefront 3!!!!!

#44 Posted by daak1212 (7867 posts) - - Show Bio

@VercingetorixTheGreat: KOTOR3, I dont want to play crappy TOR

#45 Posted by VercingetorixTheGreat (2823 posts) - - Show Bio

Could the force affect Magneto because he lives in a seperate universe. Maybe he would be seperate from the force like the Yuuzhan Vong

#46 Posted by VercingetorixTheGreat (2823 posts) - - Show Bio

@daak1212: and that commando game for xbox and that pod racing game. Man GL is either trying to kill starwars with all the crap he is giving us or he is stupid.

#47 Posted by daak1212 (7867 posts) - - Show Bio

@VercingetorixTheGreat said:

@daak1212: and that commando game for xbox and that pod racing game. Man GL is either trying to kill starwars with all the crap he is giving us or he is stupid.

Republic Commandos?

#48 Posted by Killer_of_trolls (1851 posts) - - Show Bio

bloodlusted: depends on who starts first.

#49 Posted by VercingetorixTheGreat (2823 posts) - - Show Bio

@daak1212: I loved that game!!!! Remember that pod racing game on the n64 that was another great game. I mean its not hard. Give us what we want GL and stop with the crap (kinect Star Wars, crappy cgi clone wars show, give us the original copies for the movies)

#50 Posted by ReVamp (22885 posts) - - Show Bio

I was about to say, I'm no Star Wars expert but Luke's fast.