#1 Posted by lemonfryer (74 posts) - - Show Bio
  • Fight takes place in Ozymandias' lair
  • No Prep
  • Round 1:Comic Rorschach
  • Round 2: Movie Rorschach
  • If you want Earth one Batman Feats click here and scroll down

#2 Posted by AllStarSuperman (22965 posts) - - Show Bio

still Batman for round 1, round 2 idk, probably rorschach

#3 Posted by lemonfryer (74 posts) - - Show Bio

bump

#4 Edited by beatboks1 (7520 posts) - - Show Bio

@lemonfryer: The feats on that thread are a joke compared to what E1 (pre COIE) Batman did.

To name but a few

  1. Dug his way out of his own grave. he was placed in a lead coffin in a Worlds Finest issue so Superman wouldn't see where he was and buried alive. To escape he had to use Yoga to turn himself around in the coffin and dig his way out ( only the bottom had a removable part)
  2. skydived over vegas without a chute and directed his fall toward a building where he then somersaulted and wrapped his cape around his hands so he could grab onto a light display on the side of the building and use the busting light bulbs to slow his fall so he wouldn't be killed.
  3. Taking down the likes of Blockbuster, Grundy etc
  4. Killing a lion with his bare hands

E1 Bat's was uber and rarely used his gadgets the way more recent versions do. I used to Love batman back then because he actually got hurt and shot but kept on fighting.

Online
#5 Edited by Frozen (16201 posts) - - Show Bio

@beatboks1: You mean Earth-One Batman (pre-crisis) killed a Leopard with his bare hands? When did he kill a Lion? Post-Crisis Batman choked out a White Tiger by wrestling it. In the pre-crisis issue Batman #232 or Batman #233 he killed a Leopard.

@allstarsuperman: Earth-One Batman (New-52) is far below the movie incarnations; even the Nolan version and the Keaton one. Honestly.

#6 Edited by Black_Arrow (3941 posts) - - Show Bio

round 1 Batman round 2 Rorschach

#7 Edited by Black_Arrow (3941 posts) - - Show Bio

@beatboks1 said:

@lemonfryer: The feats on that thread are a joke compared to what E1 (pre COIE) Batman did.

To name but a few

  1. Dug his way out of his own grave. he was placed in a lead coffin in a Worlds Finest issue so Superman wouldn't see where he was and buried alive. To escape he had to use Yoga to turn himself around in the coffin and dig his way out ( only the bottom had a removable part)
  2. skydived over vegas without a chute and directed his fall toward a building where he then somersaulted and wrapped his cape around his hands so he could grab onto a light display on the side of the building and use the busting light bulbs to slow his fall so he wouldn't be killed.
  3. Taking down the likes of Blockbuster, Grundy etc
  4. Killing a lion with his bare hands

E1 Bat's was uber and rarely used his gadgets the way more recent versions do. I used to Love batman back then because he actually got hurt and shot but kept on fighting.

His talking about the new 52 earth one Batman. Not the pre COIE

#8 Posted by Frozen (16201 posts) - - Show Bio
#9 Posted by Black_Arrow (3941 posts) - - Show Bio

@frozen said:

@black_arrow: Why is round 1 close?

na I edit it now I said that Batman wins because Rorschach doesn't have the feats to beat Batman.

#10 Edited by Frozen (16201 posts) - - Show Bio

@black_arrow: What feats did Earth One Batman have that was impressive?

#11 Posted by beatboks1 (7520 posts) - - Show Bio

@black_arrow: I don't think of Nu52 Batman as "earth 1", besides since most of pre FP history is still true for Nu52 batman that gives him a crapfest of ridiculous feats that are the highest of all. I mean post COIE batman was when he became the "batgod"/ "prepgod" that made me hate the character.

Online
#12 Edited by DarthAznable (8117 posts) - - Show Bio

Gonna say Batman because Batman.

Rorschach moie version was far more impressive than any of the Batman movie counterparts.

#13 Edited by AllStarSuperman (22965 posts) - - Show Bio

@beatboks1: New 52 Batman is called Earth 0/Prime Earth, Pre-Flashpoint Batman is called New World, Silver/Bronze Age Batman is Earth 1, The Batman in this Battle is Earth One, not Earth 1. Earth 1 is not Earth One.

#14 Edited by Frozen (16201 posts) - - Show Bio

@black_arrow: I don't think of Nu52 Batman as "earth 1", besides since most of pre FP history is still true for Nu52 batman that gives him a crapfest of ridiculous feats that are the highest of all. I mean post COIE batman was when he became the "batgod"/ "prepgod" that made me hate the character.

The post-crisis years gave Batman his best stories; such as The Dark Knight Returns, Batman Year One, Knightfall, Batman Noel, etc.

Gonna say Batman because Batman.

Rorschach moie version was far more impressive than any of the Batman movie counterparts.

Have you read Earth One? This version of Batman was below the movie versions of Keaton and Bale......