Dr. Manhattan vs Superman and Silver Surfer
Manhattan easily. Movie Surfer had some trouble with the military and is limited to his board, not the power cosmic. Surfer was captured using such a weak device and could not break the holds on him while imprisoned. Movie Supes is good, even lifting an island while surrounded by kryptonite which is quite a feat but still loses to Manhattan horribly.
"Manhattan easily. Movie Surfer had some trouble with the military and is limited to his board, not the power cosmic. Surfer was captured using such a weak device and could not break the holds on him while imprisoned. Movie Supes is good, even lifting an island while surrounded by kryptonite which is quite a feat but still loses to Manhattan horribly."Okay... you make good points here... but how would Manhattan beat the Team then ? Would he be able to easliy dismantle Superman and Silver Surfer on the Molecular level like he did those humans in the Watchmen film ?
"Of course he can. Manhattan is basically god in the movie. Nothing can stop him escept for that one weakness with chlorylons or whatever that I forgot. "Manhattan is God because he is among mere men... The Silver Surfer and Superman arent just regular humans... I dont know if he could effect them like he did those humans... simply because the Surfer himself can effect Matter... and Superman has been resistant to Matter Manipulation before in the past
"what will Superman do to Manhattan? anything physical just phases through him if he wants it to.Dont Know... Heat Vision or Freeze Breath may could effect him...
"
I think Silver Surfer may just win this one because Dr. Manhattan's god like view comes from all the humans he's around
"King Saturn said:How do we know he can ?"Phones said:"what will Superman do to Manhattan? anything physical just phases through him if he wants it to.Dont Know... Heat Vision or Freeze Breath may could effect him...
"
"
not if manhatton atomizes him."
" Using the Movie Versions of these Characters. Who do you think would win in an all out battle ?Donner Super win
"
Reeve Superman spins the Earth backward to a time when Jon was just a man, then he chucks a mortal Manhattan into the sun and Dr Jon dies instantly
After that he steals Surfer's board and goes Surfing back to Krypton to fix that exploded planet problem
Manhattan always wins. he is unaffected by everything and is intangible and infinitely perceptive. everything is made of atoms so even superman could get killed. manhattan could turn him into a bag of chips
The movie versions could do it. Manhattan was blowing up tanks one at a time while Surfer took out an Army at once.
Manhattan Vs. Superman AND Silver Surfer? Either Superman or Silver Surfer solos this. do some research on their powers. Supes and Surfer outclass him.
Dr. M has this, ....Manhattan can think and annihilate a city ^ if he wanted. Both movie or comic versions honestly. Unless he's facing Prime, CA or something lol
Manhattan can just teleport at will so the lightspeed is a good weapon but how good against a teleporter that's instantaneous?
He would take both down since he has full control over all matter and both SS and Supes are matter like anything else.
" @High Revolutionary: Surfer can turn intangible as well and also can restructure matter,transmute elements just like Manhattan. Plus he's got other advantages. He can make himself stronger than Hulk, both he and Superman can travel at faster than light speeds, Even when not intangible he is immune to temperature extremes disease physical harm etc. and the same for Superman. Plus Surfer can easily level a city with a cosmic blast (not making this up) waaay stronger than Manhattan's blasts. "
You are correct. But if you look at the conditions of the fight, it says that you have to pick based on the powers shown in the movies.
docotor manhattan culd turn them into kittens and snow flakes like the comedian said he culd have down to the bottle and the gun. Even if the othrs have superpowers there still mad of molecules wich doctor manhattan can manipulate he culd possible even make supermans molecules to dense or unreceprive to the sun nuetralizing his powers
DR.MANHATTAN WINS.
I hope this will end this once and for all.
1). Dr. Manhattan cannot be hurt. He can simply turn his body into thin air because he can control any molecules or atoms structure. Supe's punches will just land on thin air.
2). Kagetaicho claims silver surfer can win cauz he can destroy a city. THAT'S THE MOST IDIOTIC THING I'VE HEARD IN LIKE 8 FUCKING YEARS. Dr. Manhattan can destroy a planet using JUST his imagination.
DR.MANHATTAN PAWNS SILVER SURFER.
3). Dr. Manhattan would atomized ANYTHING MADE OF MATTER AND HAS MASS. Superman and Silver Surf are strong alright, but they are made of mass. They would get deatomized into atoms.
4). Dr. Manhattan can't be killed. If he gets blasted into pieces (not that anyone could do that), he would simply just rearrange the atoms and come back to life.
So for those of you superman fanboys who get wet just by thinking about superman's face, WATCH THE MOVIE WATCHMAN.
"Of course he can. Manhattan is basically god in the movie. Nothing can stop him escept for that one weakness with chlorylons or whatever that I forgot. "
Cosmic awareness( so he can find M weakness) then SS uses that thing against him. SS for the win here.
The other way to win this is as some1 allready said. Superman turns back the time to when M was just a man and kills him easy.
Manhattan takes this if it's based on movie versions and the surfer doesn't have the power cosmic Manhattan just demolecuralize
" @King Saturn said:Reeve wins" Using the Movie Versions of these Characters. Who do you think would win in an all out battle ?Donner Super win Reeve Superman spins the Earth backward to a time when Jon was just a man, then he chucks a mortal Manhattan into the sun and Dr Jon dies instantly After that he steals Surfer's board and goes Surfing back to Krypton to fix that exploded planet problem "
"
and he brought peace to Earth, unlike Dr M who failed and ran away to Mars like an emo
Superman is a non-factor in this battle and yes superman can be disintergrated...(what is superman made of.... atoms)
Silver surfer wasnt that good in his movie...comic surfer can stand up to manhatten ...but movie version dies do to not having the ability to transmute like manhatten...so all and all manhatten teabags superman and turns the surfer into a kitten...THEN DRINKS ITS BLOOD...MAHAHAHAHAH...cough...cough...sry...
Dr. Manhattan would win and even if Superman was going to go back in time and kill Dr. Manhattan when he was a little boy, Dr. Manhattan would such kill him before he even goes to Outer Space and spii the planet backwards.
Superman goes so fast he reverses time to the point Manhattan didn't gain his powers yet, and then the team takes him out with absolute ease.
They nurfed surfer pretty hard in that movie.
Comic surfer would solo Dr. M, who i do believe was pretty accurately depicted in watchmen movie.
"Manhattan deatomizes superman first. Surfur tries to use power cosmic but he realizes it doesnt work on manhattan. and then he's screwed. "
I would so much like you to prove me that PC does not work on Manhatan.
The only thing that looked depowered about SS is the fact that his power is attached to his board. Realy now what is nerfed about SS ? The only thing that affected him was that stupid thing that MR .F made. Now realy why do you guys say his depowered here, if anything he is overpowred he was able to take down Galactus with that blast :D
I realy whant someone to show me why SS was depowered here.
I think permanent molecular dispersion, board entrapment, time travel, or dimension dumping will all work, too." In all honesty, I think the only way Surfer can beat Manhattan is to pull him to the astral plane and pwn him there. But the movie Surfer never really exhibited such ability, su Manhattan wins here. "
But that's off topic, since this isn't the 616 version of the Surfer.
"@AtPhantom said:I think permanent molecular dispersion, board entrapment, time travel, or dimension dumping will all work, too." In all honesty, I think the only way Surfer can beat Manhattan is to pull him to the astral plane and pwn him there. But the movie Surfer never really exhibited such ability, su Manhattan wins here. "
But that's off topic, since this isn't the 616 version of the Surfer. "
Then again we have no idea if those things will work on Movie SS right ? Movie SS never had the time to show us all he can do but what he was able to do is play around with the other dudes like they where nothing to him. They needed a plot divice to slow him down.
" @Morpheus_ said:Yes, but an estimation can be given strictly from what the characters displayed in the films. We cannot take for granted film SS will be capable of them just because 616 SS is, especially coming from a film as flawed and unfaithful to the original versions of the characters, as F4: ROTSS."@AtPhantom said:Then again we have no idea if those things will work on Movie SS right ? Movie SS never had the time to show us all he can do but what he was able to do is play around with the other dudes like they where nothing to him. They needed a plot divice to slow him down. "I think permanent molecular dispersion, board entrapment, time travel, or dimension dumping will all work, too." In all honesty, I think the only way Surfer can beat Manhattan is to pull him to the astral plane and pwn him there. But the movie Surfer never really exhibited such ability, su Manhattan wins here. "
But that's off topic, since this isn't the 616 version of the Surfer. "
" @Xan said:" @Morpheus_ said:Yes, but an estimation can be given strictly from what the characters displayed in the films. We cannot take for granted film SS will be capable of them just because 616 SS is, especially coming from a film as flawed and unfaithful to the original versions of the characters, as F4: ROTSS. ""@AtPhantom said:Then again we have no idea if those things will work on Movie SS right ? Movie SS never had the time to show us all he can do but what he was able to do is play around with the other dudes like they where nothing to him. They needed a plot divice to slow him down. "I think permanent molecular dispersion, board entrapment, time travel, or dimension dumping will all work, too." In all honesty, I think the only way Surfer can beat Manhattan is to pull him to the astral plane and pwn him there. But the movie Surfer never really exhibited such ability, su Manhattan wins here. "
But that's off topic, since this isn't the 616 version of the Surfer. "
The problem with this is SS never showed ANY limits, he never had to blow up solar systems and what not but he never had any limits in that film, he was even able to take down something that eats planets for breakfast with little effort to (even if he was also KO'ed :P).
I say SS can solo this.
The Hell? Did my post just disappear?
Anyway,
@Morpheus_ said:
All these tactics presume the foe has a physical body to interact with. To Manhattan, a body is like a suit. You can burn it of, destroy it, but this in no way harms the one wearing it. Manhattan is a disembodied consciousness, and this is why I only support beings capable of soul attacks against him." @AtPhantom said:
I think permanent molecular dispersion, board entrapment, time travel, or dimension dumping will all work, too." In all honesty, I think the only way Surfer can beat Manhattan is to pull him to the astral plane and pwn him there. But the movie Surfer never really exhibited such ability, su Manhattan wins here. "
But that's off topic, since this isn't the 616 version of the Surfer. "
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment