Manhattan wins
Dr. Manhattan Vs. Silver Surfer
This topic is locked from further discussion.
NOT
THIS
SHIT
AGAIN!
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/dr-manhattan-vs-silver-surfer/18869/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/silver-surfer-vs-dr-manhattan/554642/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/dr-manhattan-vs-silver-surfer/588098/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/doctor-manhattan-vs-silver-surfer/394049/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/silver-surfer-vs-dr-manhattan/552930/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/dr-manhattan-vs-silver-surfer/542061/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/silver-surfer-vs-dr-manhattan/534733/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/silver-surfer-vs-doctor-manhattan/14642/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/doctor-manhattan-vs-silver-surfer/395607/
http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/doctor-manhattan-vs-the-silver-surfer/376380/
And the list keeps going and going and going and going.
They've even had duels of philosophy:
Prove that Manhattan is "Omnipotent". Infact, what is your definition of "Omnipotence" in the Watchmen universe?@isaac_clarke:
Manhattan is Omnipotent. Surfer isn't.
Manhattan stomps.
@JediXMan said:
@sypdermun said:I'm ending this with two words: Prove it. And you had better not say "supposedly" or "in theory." Use solid feats to back it up.@isaac_clarke:
Manhattan is Omnipotent.
Now, now. You and I both know that's impossible.
Any battle thread involving Dr. Manhattan is going to involve heavy speculation, since his feats are...limited.
I, for one, believe that Dr. Manhattan would not be too troubled by the likes of the Silver Surfer.
And I have absolutely nothing to back that up with! :P
@sypdermun said:
@isaac_clarke:
Manhattan is Omnipotent. Surfer isn't.
Manhattan stomps.
Based on what exactly??He did admit he couldnt stop all the missiles, if he were he could right??
@JediXMan said:
@sypdermun said:I'm ending this with two words: Prove it. And you had better not say "supposedly" or "in theory." Use solid feats to back it up.@isaac_clarke:
Manhattan is Omnipotent.
and that :)
Exactly! No feats, and there's nothing Manhattan can do that Surfer can't do better.@JediXMan said:
@sypdermun said:I'm ending this with two words: Prove it. And you had better not say "supposedly" or "in theory." Use solid feats to back it up.@isaac_clarke:
Manhattan is Omnipotent.
Now, now. You and I both know that's impossible.
Any battle thread involving Dr. Manhattan is going to involve heavy speculation, since his feats are...limited.
I, for one, believe that Dr. Manhattan would not be too troubled by the likes of the Silver Surfer.
And I have absolutely nothing to back that up with! :P
Um... Dr. Manhattan can manipulate EM through direct photon control. He's precognitive in the fashion that he's living every moment of his life at the same time. He's capable of teleportation with limitless range. Manipulating and controlling time, again through particle manipulation, reversing or speeding particle motion and speeding or reversing time as percieved by others. He's completely invulnerable in the fact that you can destroy every single particle in his body and his consciousness can recreate it instantly. Or simply prevent it happening in the first place because he's already aware of it having happened. He's capable of utter intangibility by again, manipulating particles not interact with others. There are no forms of energy he cannot control.
The Surfer has no in here, every single thing he can do, Dr. Manhattan can do better, faster, and already knowing the outcome. Surfer can destroy a planet, Dr. Manhattan can turn a planet into a star, or a black hole or a giant bowl of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream if he wanted to, instantly.
Uh-huh.
Prove he has ever controlled time. Prove that his teleportation is limitless.
Surfer has:
Stopped/slowed time.
Destroyed planets with no effort.
Changed an entire planet's atmosphere. (and I believe accelerated their evolutionary cycle)
Entered the Astral Plane (powerful telepath)
Has also reformed himself after being shattered.
Effortless light speed travel.
Surfer is a powerful molecule manipulator and has displayed his powers beyond anything Manhattan has and ever will show.
Also, Manhattan has already shown that he has no power over the future. He is just as much a puppet to time as he always was. He can't change anything.
Next.
Um... Dr. Manhattan can manipulate EM through direct photon control. He's precognitive in the fashion that he's living every moment of his life at the same time. He's capable of teleportation with limitless range. Manipulating and controlling time, again through particle manipulation, reversing or speeding particle motion and speeding or reversing time as percieved by others. He's completely invulnerable in the fact that you can destroy every single particle in his body and his consciousness can recreate it instantly. Or simply prevent it happening in the first place because he's already aware of it having happened. He's capable of utter intangibility by again, manipulating particles not interact with others. There are no forms of energy he cannot control.
The Surfer has no in here, every single thing he can do, Dr. Manhattan can do better, faster, and already knowing the outcome. Surfer can destroy a planet, Dr. Manhattan can turn a planet into a star, or a black hole or a giant bowl of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream if he wanted to, instantly.
Just asking, if he's capable of all that, why didn't he just stop comedian from killing that woman and those missiles?
Just asking, not too familiar with Manhattan. except from what I've seen in the movie.
@SurelockeHomes said:
@sypdermun said:Um... Dr. Manhattan can manipulate EM through direct photon control. He's precognitive in the fashion that he's living every moment of his life at the same time. He's capable of teleportation with limitless range. Manipulating and controlling time, again through particle manipulation, reversing or speeding particle motion and speeding or reversing time as percieved by others. He's completely invulnerable in the fact that you can destroy every single particle in his body and his consciousness can recreate it instantly. Or simply prevent it happening in the first place because he's already aware of it having happened. He's capable of utter intangibility by again, manipulating particles not interact with others. There are no forms of energy he cannot control.
The Surfer has no in here, every single thing he can do, Dr. Manhattan can do better, faster, and already knowing the outcome. Surfer can destroy a planet, Dr. Manhattan can turn a planet into a star, or a black hole or a giant bowl of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream if he wanted to, instantly.
Just asking, if he's capable of all that, why didn't he just stop comedian from killing that woman and those missiles?
Just asking, not too familiar with Manhattan. except from what I've seen in the movie.
Like Comedian himself said, Manhattan was detaching himself from the human race. He could have stopped him from killing that woman, he just didn't see the point.
Anyway, this has already been done. Surfer wins based on feats.
True with the woman. Though it was mentioned that Manhattan would only be able to stop a large percentage of the nukes and not all of them. I forget the exact number.@SurelockeHomes said:
@sypdermun said:Um... Dr. Manhattan can manipulate EM through direct photon control. He's precognitive in the fashion that he's living every moment of his life at the same time. He's capable of teleportation with limitless range. Manipulating and controlling time, again through particle manipulation, reversing or speeding particle motion and speeding or reversing time as percieved by others. He's completely invulnerable in the fact that you can destroy every single particle in his body and his consciousness can recreate it instantly. Or simply prevent it happening in the first place because he's already aware of it having happened. He's capable of utter intangibility by again, manipulating particles not interact with others. There are no forms of energy he cannot control.
The Surfer has no in here, every single thing he can do, Dr. Manhattan can do better, faster, and already knowing the outcome. Surfer can destroy a planet, Dr. Manhattan can turn a planet into a star, or a black hole or a giant bowl of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream if he wanted to, instantly.
Just asking, if he's capable of all that, why didn't he just stop comedian from killing that woman and those missiles?
Just asking, not too familiar with Manhattan. except from what I've seen in the movie.
Like Comedian himself said, Manhattan was detaching himself from the human race. He could have stopped him from killing that woman, he just didn't see the point.
Anyway, this has already been done. Surfer wins based on feats.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment