Debaters Tournament Round 3

It's been 2 years since the last round, so I thought I would bring this back :) Basically, We will nominate 16 users than randomly generate matches. We will keep going until we have a winner. Please try to nominate the best of the vine!

Rules:

1. You may nominate two users. You are NOT allowed to nominate yourself.
2. Once the rounds are set up, you may vote for who you believe the winner would be (in a debate) and if you choose to do so, elaborate on why. If you say why, keep it polite.
3. There is NO debating against each other in this thread. You place your votes, and wait for the next rounds. If you have an issue with someones vote, PLEASE discuss it in a PM with them. I want to keep this as friendly as possible and avoid having it locked. So again, NO commenting on how others vote in this thread.
4. Once 16 users are nominated, I will create the tournament in random order. I will literally write down the names, shuffle them, and randomly select them. Yes, I am that lame.
5. We are looking for newer users. Anyone that has been nominated in the past 2 rounds are not eligible. Round 1 and Round 2.

I'll start of the nominations by nominating beatboks1 and god_spawn

@Killemall: Thanks.

I'll vote Floopay and you, Killemall.

I vote for jashro44 and Strider92.

The list thus far:

1. beatboks1
2. god_spawn
3. Deranged Midget
4. ShootingNova
5. Floopay
6. CadenceV2
7. Killemall
8. jashro44
9. Strider92

@ShootingNova: Floopay has already been nominated. You have 1 nomination left :)

@Killemall: Beat you to the punch :P

To Everyone: I think CitizenBane, Super_SoldierXll, and Lvenger deserve a nomination as well. If only I had more XD

@Strafe Prower: Oh..... right. Lvenger then, since you said so.

@Strafe Prower said:

@Killemall: Beat you to the punch :P

To Everyone: I think CitizenBane, Super_SoldierXll, and Lvenger deserve a nomination as well. If only I had more XD

Ah darn it! Lvenger is indeed an incredible debater. It's a shame I can't have another vote.

@ShootingNova: Got it!

1. beatboks1
2. god_spawn
3. Deranged Midget
4. ShootingNova
5. Floopay
6. CadenceV2
7. Killemall
8. jashro44
9. Strider92
10. Lvenger

@Deranged Midget: Don't worry, I voted Lvenger for you.

@ShootingNova: @Killemall: Awesome! :D

@Killemall: It's up to you if you want to nominated a retired debater. As long as they weren't in the last 2 rounds, they are eligable.

Super_SoldierXll is great. Look at the Captain America vs. Hawkeye, Gambit, and Cyclops thread for a debate I had with him (and god_spawn for that matter)

@Killemall said:

while CitizenBane is or rather was an awesome debater, he left the site about 3 months ago after he felt Erik was unfairly banned and Morpheus_ left. Do we still nominate people who are no longer active?

He, apparently, isn't even interested in returning to the forums, so if we nominate him, will he try to debate?

Not that I have anything against him, he is an excellent debater and Viner overall, so he totally deserves respect.

@Killemall said:

this is an interesting thread, we should make one where we decide who among the debtor would win in a trolling contest :p

Indeed.

Also, I hate you for voting me.... I'll totally fail this!

@Killemall: And then I'll get stomped in a debate.

@ShootingNova said:

@Killemall said:

while CitizenBane is or rather was an awesome debater, he left the site about 3 months ago after he felt Erik was unfairly banned and Morpheus_ left. Do we still nominate people who are no longer active?

He, apparently, isn't even interested in returning to the forums, so if we nominate him, will he try to debate?

Not that I have anything against him, he is an excellent debater and Viner overall, so he totally deserves respect.

Not likely, as he has moved on to another forum now. Luckily, this tourney goes by votes and there is no debating required :)

Agreed.

@Killemall: LOL. :D

@Strafe Prower: So after we nominate 16 guys, we keep nominating till we finish, or we debate against another of the 16 until it's the last one standing?

@Killemall: Comics Ledger

@ShootingNova: We nominate the 16 users, then we vote based on random matches. For Example:

Vance Astro vs. k4tzm4n

Silver2467 vs. JediXMan

There is no actual debating, just voting based on who you think would win a debate.

@Strafe Prower: Oh, right. Ok, thanks.

@Killemall: Haha LOL.

I guess you'll kill anybody who doesn't vote for you, that way nobody can vote against you LOL.

@Killemall: Well, it's too bad you can't kill an immortal like me!

@Killemall: (Dooku laugh) A bold claim!

Then I'll simply do this to you:

Seriously though, we can stop making this more and more off-topic.

1. nickzambuto
2. nickthedevil

@Killemall said:

Nominated thus far:

1. god_spawn
2. Deranged Midget
3. Floopay
4. Killemall
5. jashro44
6. Nickthedevil

4 more to go.

Since all of these would have been my prime choices

Dedmanwalking and Citizenbane. I would have gone either Sherlock or Revamp next (hint hint)

So am I being nominated for a random debate like Challenge a Viner at some point? And I'll nominate @TheAcidSkull and @Vance Astro. Both of these guys have impressed me though I'm not sure Vance will be available to participate. If he can't I'll give my vote to @YourNeighborhoodComicGeek, another fantastic debater.

@Killemall said:

So the nominess thus far are,

Nominated thus far:

1. beatboks1
2. god_spawn
3. Deranged Midget
4. ShootingNova
5. Floopay
6. CadenceV2
7. Killemall
8. jashro44
9. Strider92
10. Lvenger
11. Nickzambuto
12. Nickthedevil
13. TheAcidSkull
14. YourNeighborhoodComicGeek
15. Sherlock

@TheAcidSkull: Since both Lvenger and me have already been nominated you still have 1 more vote to go, and we only need 16 anyways.

I think you missed my nom last page (dedmanwalking and citizenbane). that would now make it 17 with the noms of lvneger and acidskull you added after.

@Killemall: Which person left the site 4 months ago who's on this list?

@Killemall said:

@Lvenger said:

@Killemall: Which person left the site 4 months ago who's on this list?

Our beloved CitizenBane.

Oh I knew that. I thought it was someone else. I don't envy whoever will be in a hypothetical match against him!