There is no way in hell that comet (in "Superman TAS: Season 2, EP 28: Little Lost Girl") weighed anything close to 10000 tons which he even struggled to move and half of it came off.
Plus going off estimates- Manhattan weighs roughly at least 2.3 million tons, so Thor affecting 1% of that weight will place him much higher than 10000 tons, and that's forgetting to factor in the HUGE land mass under the falling city which will increase the estimate exponentially.
Why wouldn't it be? It apparently was large enough and moving at enough speed to destroy the Earth. It also only split apart after Superman moved it away from Earth. He still made more of an impact to that than Thor did to that chunk of Manhattan.
That's a section of Manhattan, not the entire borough. The picture you provided even shows its only a section of Manhattan. The entire borough (including the rock underneath) weighs around 2.3 million tons. So in actuality the weight was way less than 2.3 million tons. There's still nothing to show Thor even really made any impact to its descent, and whatever impact he did make, doesn't put his strength beyond either Superman.
and MoS Superman has never lifted anything close to 10000 tons. His best lifting strength feat puts him at 200 tons tops(holding the spire of an Oil Rig) and the World Engine feat only places him around 20 tons tops because all he had to do was resist his own increased weight.
This is a pretty big misconception about this feat (that's explained a bit in the novel). Superman can jump pretty high and fly because he isn't affected by Earth's gravitational pull. So the fact that the World Engine had enough gravitational force to have Clark go from resisting Earth's gravity with no difficulty whatsoever, to barely being able to stand up from Krypton's gravity, shows a massive difference in weight resistance. Also noting that the field expanded and grew stronger (enough to flatten skyscrapers, turn steel, metal, rock etc, into powder, and vaporize humans) as time went on, meaning the longer Clark stayed under the beam the more force he felt. That would make the force he felt much greater than 20 tons. You can't exactly argue a guy who lifted 200 tons of weight suddenly can't handle 20 tons. The difference in gravity is ridiculous. Add to that Superman was weakened as well, its pretty much around the several thousand ton range.
He broke out of it(you actually see him breaking out). He'd have to if he needed to go from the bottom, to the top/side of it because he got buried and pushed into the gaping hole Graviton left when he took the city out of its place.
Your still not addressing the fact that he would of had to have some space to get out. He can't simply dig himself out of a weight that he clearly couldn't lift at all. He would have needed space to dig out, not to mention he shouldn't have been able to move at all (especially if his arms and legs are extended outward) if he was being crushed from such a weight. Mjornir can't do the work if its owner is too busy being crushed by a weight thats hopelessly beyond his strength limit. Your picture doesn't make sense either since if the city was put back into place where it was, there should not have been a wide enough space for Thor to fly out. Thor must have had some space to move once the city fell as far down as it could.
I was talking about durability and how Thor was able to survive a beating from the Frost Giants and Loki who are both actually quite strong.
Lifting feats don't equate to striking feats. You already know this. What striking feats do frost giants and Loki have that indicate that Thor "surviving" a beating from them shows better durability than either Superman?
Thor on the other hand was able to hold off Kang's cannon for a short while and redirect it, before getting knocked out.
Still put him in a coma for several days. Superman was still hit by the cannon. We also have actual evidence of that weapon destroying the city. No evidence Kang's weapon would have done the same. The Avenger's even just say Kang was targeting the city. Doesn't mean he would have destroyed the whole city in one blast.
Wow, but I guess that is just your opinion after all, I simply disagree with it. Thor doesn't need that massive lightning bolt to beat animated Superman, the guy has been knocked out so many times by electricity it's not even funny. And there really sin't anything MoS Superman could do to harm EMH Thor. Nothing.
And MCU(cinematic and comic(canon comics)) Thor still has better striking feats than the MoS Superman (both cinematic and novels combined), the novels which btw actually hilariously contradict what was shown in the official movie.
If you want to go down that route, I've got plenty of ridiculous feats from MCU comic Thor which contradict the official canon story(from comic book stories which came out before Marvel started doing tie-in canon comics, much like the MoS novel). We can exchange those feats, or we can just stick to canon and what makes sense.
I've already addressed that I think the Thors win due to animated Superman's weakness to lightning and magic. I've yet to see how neither Superman can't hurt animated Thor when both have displayed striking power superior to characters that have been able to hurt Thor. Present the striking feats that Thor has tanked that say he can't be harmed at all from the supermen. That Vision feat isn't enough. Both characters have inconsistent showings.
Kindly point out which canon comics MCU Thor has that shows greater striking power. Because i haven't seen any. People have shown the one where Thor fights Kurse and Malekith, which clearly isn't canon since it was made years before the movie and features the same characters in completely different stories, settings, and costumes. Comics not considered canon. Man of steel's novel was made with the original screenplay. You can argue the events in the book are slightly different, but the timeline the events took place in and the characters are all the same. Almost all of the dialogue is the same as well. Above everything else, its canon. MOS Clark with his novel feats has greater striking power than MCU Thor.
Log in to comment