Team DC: Donna Troy, Fire, Jade, Stargirl
vs
Team Marvel: Invisible Woman, Ms Marvel, Rogue, Storm
All DC's are pre-52. All Marvel are versions show in pics.
Random encounter. Win by KO or death. Who wins?
Team DC: Donna Troy, Fire, Jade, Stargirl
vs
Team Marvel: Invisible Woman, Ms Marvel, Rogue, Storm
All DC's are pre-52. All Marvel are versions show in pics.
Random encounter. Win by KO or death. Who wins?
Depends on bloodlust and morals.
Off - Sue does the ol bubble in the brain business.
On - Those DC ladies are too tough. Storm and Rogue are almost non-factors. Jade is going to be extremely hard for Ms. Marvel to put down. Then when Fire and Donna finish the others they all go to work on Sue's shields.
Definitely leaning toward Marvel. I don't think Star Girl is that tough and Fire also seems a bit outclassed by all the Marvel women too.
@captainmarvelthunder: you dont have any idea who Stargirl is
@zhurong: Saw her in the Justice League Unlimited tv show, read her appearances in the New 52, read the Stars and Stripes trade paper back, and I read about her in some of the New Earth JSA trades. I read plenty of her. Unless she goes into some godmode (which is not how she is usually depicted and Miss Marvel has a mode like that too anyway) that I have not read about She is probably the weakest and most inexperienced character here (maybe Fire is weaker).
@captainmarvelthunder: Actually Stargirl is the most powerful in this battle and here is why: the cosmic converter belt alone makes that human girl a 50 tonners with sonic speed a force field and a healing factor who can fire energy blasts and manipulate and control the neurons in the brains of others.Add in the cosmic rod which is a device on or above the level of a green lantern that allows almost complete control of the electromagnetic spectrum. Energy constructs , control of gravity, heat, earth, and more. Cosmic rod also prevents and blocks mind or soul control, and much more.Frankly she the MVP of the DC team IMO
@zhurong: That's great but she never actually performs like that in what I have read and seen of her. Also invisible Woman can just create a force field insider her and expand it killing her easily (granted that is alos not her normal way of fighting either but it is something she can do). Miss Marvel and Rogue strong enough to lift 50 tons. Actually are we using Rogue that has Miss Marvel's powers? I thought we were.
She can be potentially the most powerful, but that is not how she normally is written. She is almost always the inexperienced rookie like character, that has potential but still often needs a lot of looking after when the going gets tough.
@zhurong: Jade is another character that goes into super mode too from time to time. But I am going with how they usually perform (same for Miss Marvel).
@captainmarvelthunder: Thats fine but Stargirl can create a blackhole in Sue's head. It has been debated that Stargirl can beat the likes of Hulk with no effort. Stargirl has a weapon that can level a star system but you think a woman who got owned by Jean Grey is too much for her.
@zhurong: Just going off of what I have seen of Stargirl. She never really fights like that for the most part. She has a lot of power but usually does not know how to wield it properly. It would be kind of a scenario of who attacks first if she is able to wield her power to the fullest and Invisible Woman wanted to kill her immediately.
@zhurong: getting owned by jean grey is not embarrassing jean without PF could beat all here both teams 1v1
@comicsrulebutdbzdoes2: Jean fought Storm and Ororo got the best of her. Donna Troy is basically Wonder Woman. Jade can go head to head with Lanterns.
@zhurong: scans of storm beating a jean grey who wants to hurt storm? If jean wanted she could just MC storm and make her kill herself
Definitely leaning toward Marvel. I don't think Star Girl is that tough and Fire also seems a bit outclassed by all the Marvel women too.
@beatboks1 knows much more about Stargirl.
Marvel:
Rogue's power drain and Ms Marvel's energy drain simultaneously amping them and taking out an opponent is going to be a bit much in a 4 vs 4.
I'm going to go with DC as Carol has trouble absorbing magical energies and that version of Rogue doesn't have control over her powers. Plus you basically have Wonder Woman - lite and a Green Lantern vs mid tier Marvel characters.
@willpayton: Mabey he does but I have read multiple things with her and none of them have her using her powers to any super levels that make her way stronger than everyone else in fact she is one of the weakest member with superpowers (or in her case a super gadget). She may be potentially ultra powerful but she is not written wielding that power often. Also Miss Marvel has some crazy powers as Binary (but I am not counting those because she does not usually use them).
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that in the case of this fight, the readers win.
I think it'd be an awesome fight.
marvel stomps
how?
marvel stomps
how?
I'm curious to this as well...
DC seem's to have the heavier hitters. Aren't Sue's shields weak enough for Donna Troy to break out of?
Also feats for Stargirl would be nice.
DC seem's to have the heavier hitters. Aren't Sue's shields weak enough for Donna Troy to break out of?
Also feats for Stargirl would be nice.
Check out this thread for feats and information about Stargirl and her equipment:
http://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/battles-7/hulk-vs-stargirl-1500587/
marvel stomps
how?
marvel stomps
how?
I'm curious to this as well...
Too tanked with the likes of Storm and Invisible Woman.
I don't see anyone stopping invisible women.
marvel stomps
how?
marvel stomps
how?
I'm curious to this as well...
Too tanked with the likes of Storm and Invisible Woman.
I don't see anyone stopping invisible women.
if there is enough brute force, her shields can be disrupted. But yeah, by then Marvel would win.
Here: Invisible Woman would do a shield around Fire and block her oxygen, not only it gets the fire out but it also suffocates her.
Storm is overkill at the best of the days, and she managed to defeat Wonder Woman:
IF, Donna manages the drop on her, as in someone distracting her, PERHAPS. But Ororo is no slouch in h2h, maybe not in the likes of WW, since she never managed to get close enough for us to know, if Jade and Fire combine their powers perhaps, but they can't stand still or else, Susan takes both down if Rogue (depensing on the version) doesn't get there first.
Ms Marvel is infinitely worse, Stargirl and Jade wouldn't stand a chance, only if Donna keeps her suficiently distracted and overpowers her in h2h, air or ground.
Rogue wouldn't be able to do much (unless we are talking about the current, most modern version of her), in which case if she can fly, then they re toasted, one touch and it's night night. Fire, Jade and Stargirl would have to attack from a distance and KEEP that distance. Perhaps Jade or Stargirl, Fire is not very fast.
And all that is why... Marvel stomps so hard!!
@bbbbgardengolden: ....Wonder woman vs Storm is non- canon.
I'm also pretty sure that fight was literally decided via popular vote, as in there was a poll posted and people voted
@blackestnight93: Yes it is canon. However that is not 616 Storm. It is Fanforce Storm.
@blackestnight93: Yes it is canon. However that is not 616 Storm. It is Fanforce Storm.
fanforce storm? Sounds like a joke
@blackestnight93: No, Fanforce Storm can beat Iceman, Magneto, Iron-man, Hulk and Thor at the same time.
@blackestnight93: No, Fanforce Storm can beat Iceman, Magneto, Iron-man, Hulk and Thor at the same time.
ah. crap, I forgot that fanforce storm is basically a skyfather
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment