#1 Posted by DeadlyCarnage (291 posts) - - Show Bio

Location ; Coruscant. Jedi Temple.

Standard winning conditions.

Durge is blood-lusted.

Vader is in character.

Vader has only one lightsaber.

No prep.

#2 Posted by Immortal777 (7735 posts) - - Show Bio

Darth Vader

I'm biased


#3 Posted by Racob7 (6123 posts) - - Show Bio

Vader in a close match.

#4 Posted by BobSaysHi25 (182 posts) - - Show Bio

Darth Vader is a flipping beast not sure about the other guy so Im not giving any straight forward answer

#5 Posted by steelhound56 (1074 posts) - - Show Bio

Vader should likely win. Anakin was able to defeat Durge on his own merit. I see Vader as being more powerful than Anakin if we're talking prime versions. Anakin is the faster and more agile swordsman, but he lacks the knowledge and understanding of the Dark Side (and the Force in general), self control, and experience that his older self possesses.

We have examples of Vader collapsing cathedrals, throwing small spaceships, and overwhelming high level Force users with his raw Force power, engaging and defeating multiple Jedi at once in lightsaber combat without showing any strain on his abilities, and showing that he can take a lot of punishment himself due to his mechanical limbs and other cyborg implants.

Not to say Durge wouldn't put up one hell of a fight, his Gen'Dai physiology would enable him to take a LOT of punishment before he fell in combat. But Vader, in my opinion is more deadly due to his extremely potent command of the Force, his willingness to use it to gain an edge in combat, and his overall efficiency in eliminating threats to his person give him the win here....