Maul, 10/10. It wouldn't be an absolute slaughter, though. Malak is comparable in power (if not rivaling Maul), strength and durability (especially pain tolerance), and by reasonable inference, should thus be comparable in speed as well.
Skill is the main deciding factor here, and, to be honest, Maul is just plain better. He has fought as Obi-Wan's equal, has beaten Ko Solok and Bruu Jun-Fan, held the upper hand against Judd, dominated Savage in their fight, stomped Aayla whilst fending off Mace Windu, etc. Malak's only showing is stomping Bastila, who has no feats of her own minus outdueling a featless Sith/Dark Jedi, and wrecking a guard with a single kick, though the latter feat was a feat of martial skill rather than blade skill, which was what Malak held the edge over her in. Malak hardly even compares to Maul in this area. He could present a minor challenge, but he would lose every time.
Log in to comment