Darth Malak vs Darth Maul

Darth Malak vs Darth Malgus

• Darth Malak during KOTOR
• Darth Maul during Son of Dathomir (Pre Phantom Meance EU)

Three Rounds:

1. Lightsaber Duel
2. Force Battle
3. All Out Fight

• Darth Maul has the Darksaber
• Both Characters at their Full Level of Power
• Both In Character
• 1v1 Fight to the Death

Fights Takes Place:

@wollfmyth209, @gunsout, @thevivas, Thought You would be interested

Lightsaber Duel

Maul.

Force Battle

Malak.

All Out Fight

Maul.

@wollfmyth209: Poor Malak...

@bat_siri: Nah. S'a good fight.

Maul wins all, ouch.

@i_like_swords: Don't let Ant hear you, Swords.

@wollfmyth209: lol

@darthant66 Malak dies

@i_like_swords:

"Implying Maul can hold his own against REVAN is laughable."

Source: Ant

@wollfmyth209: That is True to be Fair, he was stated to be a better duelist than Revan, so i'd like to see this Fight Play Out

@wollfmyth209: Beats him in a duel at least.

@bat_siri: That "statement" is from Drew, who also thought Meetra was a better duelist than Revan, and that's just absurd. Let's also not forget that Revan beat him, shall we?

@i_like_swords Does he beat Malak or Revan in a duel?

@wollfmyth209: I know, but that statement adds to Revan's lightsaber skills though as he can beat duelists better than him

@wollfmyth209: Either

@i_like_swords: Of course, of course. Maul > Darth Revan as a duelist, for sure.

I'm pretty sure we gave Anthony a heart attack, by now.

Why does OP say Darth Malgus?

@wollfmyth209

Lightsaber Duel

Maul.

Force Battle

Malak.

All Out Fight

Maul.

Exactly.

@i_like_swords: Not seeing how Malak loses the force battle TBH.

Maul

Malak

Maul

Darth Maul

...

:P

I like Maul here, force battle only would be tough for Maul. But Maul takes the rest.

Inferior power feats tends to do it.

Maul in all

The wealth of convincing arguments in favour of Malak is just too much to handle at the moment, slow down guiz.

I'm still confused as to why the OP says "Darth Malak vs Darth Malgus".

Maul in all

Malak takes Force. He enjoys having the rest of his face taken in sabers and all-out, though.

Maul wins all but Force.

Yep.

@bat_siri: malak takes the force, maul takes the others

Maul wins force too. He overpowered Kenobi in force like Dooku had. Kenobi would wreck Malak in sabers and match Malak in force feats. Maul wrecks the half ass Sith Lord.

Prime Malak should also be on Dooku's Force tier (if not higher).

no he shouldn't unless you're talking sf malak where i guess there's a debate but i'd still say is below dooku

All but one of said times had context. On florrum he did it when

a. Kenobi had his back turned and was attacking opress

b. When he was angry/desperate( makes darksiders stronger) about his brother and waited for kenobi to lunge and not have his force defenses up. Maul then proceeded to ragdoll a kenobi who had just survived a crash landing after running from the madolorians. Maul's only showing which wasn't circumstantial was in sith hunter. Kenobi then improved in rots to the point he could deflect force blasts(per the rots novel) from anakin who while hindered had also massively improved from the clone wars where he could force push dooku. So maul's ability to replicate that one showing vs rots kenobi without a circumstantial factor at play is very questionable.

I think it's safe to say that Malak would win a Force battle against Maul, but there's no way he'd beat him in 'sabers. I'd wager Maul'd probably win an all-out battle as well.

@echostarlord117: malak is also physically inferior

@kbroskywalker: And...?

Maul wins all rounds, with the force being the closest.

1. Maul could win sabers
2. Malak wins the Force battle
3. I'd say this could be an even split or Malak takes a SLIM majority

Malak takes all rounds.Force and all-out isn't even close.

Malak narrowly takes saber, godstomps in force, and easily takes all-out

Wait wait wait, hold on, you ACTUALLY think that Darth Malak, who is astronomically inferior to Revan, can stomp Maul, but also believe that Yoda, who isn't that far ahead of Maul due to the wealth of quotes stating that Maul and Savage had a very close duel with Sidious, to easily stomp Prime Revan?

Maul shreds Malak

@darthor: It's officially stated by KOTOR's writer that Malak > Revan as a duelist. What we saw in KOTOR wasn't Malak at his full power. And since Revan is apparently such a good duelist according to you, Malak should be able to take sabers. And don't try to convince yourself that Revan could beat Yoda. Yoda is way stronger than Maul and outclasses even Prime Revan in everything.