Darth Bane vs Grand Master Satele Shan

Let's just say they randomly encountered each other aboard the Allusis.

Who would win in a fight?

Darth Bane

VS

Satele Shan

Both are at their peak of their power.

This is one of the few threads you've made.

@ShootingNova dOESN'T satele shan have better force feats then bane?

@MasterJohn: I don't even remember making this before anyways. When did I make it?

Yeah, Satele does.

@ShootingNova said:

@MasterJohn: I don't even remember making this before anyways. When did I make it?

Yeah, Satele does.

According to the OP, you created this 6 months ago.

Satele should take it.

@MasterJohn: Apparently I did, but I don't think I did. I can't remember.

Bump.

Satele is more powerful in the Force while Bane may be a tad bit faster (though the disparity is neglectable) and a better duelist (although once again the disparity is so small it won't make much of a difference)

That being said, I'm giving Satale the majority 6-7/10

Bump

Satele is pretty powerful in the force, I'd say just a bit more than Bane, as Bane also has some decent feats, while Bane is the better duelist. But if this is Grand Master Satele, I'd say it most likely ends in a tie.

Base on her feats, I am siding with Satele.

But Grand Master Satele vs Dystany of Evil Bane (Pretty sure thats the 3rd book), Bane wins it.

Probably an even split or a slight majority to Satele, she's faster, more powerful, and maybe a tad bit more skilled (stalemating Baras/holding her own against Malgus in hope briefly). These feats are at least somewhat more impressive than Bane only beating a Sith trainee

Bump

Gonna go with Bane after all. Comparable force power, faster, physically stronger, better duelist, and the list goes on...

Probably, Dessel.

Prolly bane.

Bane's nexus power showings scaled down should be enough to contend with Satele's. Physically there isn't really anything to split them. Bane contending with Kas'im before his prime and stomping the best Sith cadet or whatever is probably better than losing to Malgus and stalemating beings who lack real showings or accolades.

Bane wins.

Satele

Bane duelling advantage is greater than Shane's force power advantage IMO, espicially since he spent his training years sparring against a Saberstaff wielding blademaster, who also happened to be one of the most talented swordmen in the galaxy.

Plus he's stronger and more durable, though I guess that doesn't count for as much.

Proof Banes "scaled down" showings surpass Sateles, and lol Bane has no speed feats surpassing blitzing Sith

Executing several battles sequences before Sith accolades can perceive him is a excellent feat. And before you scream Nexus - the Sith Accolades were also on the Nexus, so there is that. Fighting faster than Cognus can properly perceive from a safe distance away, is also a impressive feat.

Didn't say that, I said contend. Which they do, unless you think Satele would achieve noticeably different results when blasting that temple with the same nexus?

and lol Bane has no speed feats surpassing blitzing Sith

Not surpassing, but he's more or less done exactly that anyway, hence why I said there should be no difference between him and Satele.

@dccomicsrule2011: The other Sith being amped is irrelevant, Bane doesnt have the focused darkside energies of the academy here- and unless you have proof that Bane can blitz Sith off nexus, There is no reason to believe he can replicate that feat. Satele blitzing multiple Sith at once with her own power surpasses Bane doing the same with energies he has no access too here

And those Sith likewise wouldn't have the same energies to draw from that they used trying to comprehend Bane's movements. Let's stop being unreasonable.

He was using the force in an are designed to focus his power and it made him faster than he'd normally be. Proof that the Sith wouldt be able to comprehend his speed? Even when he was amped with Orbalisks fodder was capable of reacting to him and even dodging his lightning. His speed is being wanked hard here

@burnface:

The other Sith being amped is irrelevant

Yes it is. That means both of them were amped equally,which means that his normal speed un-amped is still vastly superior to theirs

Bane doesnt have the focused darkside energies of the academy here- and unless you have proof that Bane can blitz Sith off nexus, There is no reason to believe he can replicate that feat.

Fighting faster Than Cognus can properly perceive while she was dozens of feet away is an impressive feat that tells me he can blitz fodder Sith. Especially considering fodder Sith can be killed by zombies.

Satele blitzing multiple Sith at once with her own power surpasses Bane doing the same with energies he has no access too here.

Even if I did agree, the speed advantage is nowhere big enough to have an impactful income in this bout.

Agreed on your final point at least

Bane with low-mid difficulty. But I love Satele more <3

can anyone see my comments?

And likewise the acolytes and Sirak would have amplified perceptions, so it irrefutably balances out. Take the nexus away and we're back to square one.

The fact that "fodder" could perceive him proves they aren't fodder.

I get that Bane is overrated, but trying to lowball him in every, single, thread, takes away reasonable discussion altogether.

Bane imo.

Bane wins solidly.

Dessel stomps.

@shootingnova: bane obviously