CW Arrow vs Red Hood

This is the CW TV version of Arrow and the pre 52 version of Red Hood (Jason Todd). Both are in-character but are fighting all out (like when Oliver fought Slade and Ra's etc).

1. Strictly hand-to-hand, takes place on the rooftop in Starling City where Oliver fought Merlyn in the Season 1 finale. They start 15 away from each other.
2. Standard gear, takes place in an abandoned warehouse in Starling City (unfamiliar to both characters), and they start 100 feet apart and visible, with cover in between

Fights are to the death, KO, or incapacitation and neither has any prior knowledge of the other. Oliver has no access to the rest of his team. Who wins each round and why?

Ollie wins cos he takes hits from 10 tonners and outskilled China White, the Triad's leader.

:p

Red Hood one-shots

Jason punches his head off.

You say that like it isn't actually true.

jason

Hahahaha. Mismatch.

@zazam@616vulture@risingbean@serrure@the_red_viper@pr0metheus@transformers1024@comicdude360@koays

@nickzambuto: You are needed here

And another mismatch at the hands of nfactor1995 in favor of Red Hood (not that I'm surprised anymore.)

@nfactor1995: I can't... I just can't anymore... I'm too old... So tired... Can't deal with this bull anymore *dies*

Red Hood

Todd

CW arrow of course! I mean, this is still CWVine.com right?

I'll go with Arrow just for argument sake and because he is dope. Round 1 Red Hood all day. Round 2 I would give it to Arrow there are a few time I seen him disarm people with his bow. If he does that and stay far away I think he has a chance.

Live action characters should never fight comic counterparts.

It is very rare when a live action character is put against a comics character and wins.

This isn't one of those times though.

Arrow.

@impervious: I, uh, don't really ever make Red Hood threads...or mismatch threads for that matter...only a couple and those are by accident..

this needs to be said a lot more often. Live action doesn't stand a chance

Never read Pre-52 JT but someone has @allstarsuperman

Arrow.

LOL

Still watching arrow so I don't know.

Just because something is live action doesn't make it automatically inferior to the comics.

I think he needs a break.....

@jashro44: What episode are you on?

I finished episode 2 of season one yesterday (I did start watching a few episodes a while ago but I got sidetracked with school so I restarted from episode one 2 days ago). I'm watching it with my family since my sister wanted to see arrow; so I wont be done for a long time. All though I did have to explain for 5 minutes to my mom and sister that Arrow wasn't superhuman during the first episode LOL.

Pre-52 Jason's has still cut Green Arrows and Speedys arrows out of the air. And blocked a bullet in mid air while doing a back flip. This is simply beyond Arrows speed and agility.

Skill and Physical wise, Jason while brain dead was able to one shot 4 league of assassins ninja. And he beat Batman in the first UtRH fight. He did, deal with it haterz.

Gear wise, Ollie is out classed. He would never land a hit on Jason while Jason has tagged Nightwing with throwing knives. Jason has tasers that can drop Cyborg and Beast Boy, and even killed Captain Nazi. Arrow gets easily one one shotted with them.

@nfactor1995: Doesn't change the fact that a lot of your battle threads were complete mismatches.

@allstarsuperman: isn't Captain Nazi a villain from Watchmen that doesn't really appear but is mentioned?

@the_red_viper: hurm....maybe I have the name wrong. In Under the Red Hood there's a guy hired to kill Jason, and he was said to be able to fight Captian Marvel, but Jason was able to kill him with a taser.

Captain Nazi is a captain marvel villains but he is a jobber IIRC.

@jashro44: is he a jobber because Jason killed him, or does he have other showing to suggest being a jobber?

He lost to catman as well (I have been told catman used a needle of some sort) and I recall Mr.Terrific owning him in addition to the Jason showing.

@allstarsuperman: oh I know who you're talking about. Don't recall his name (it did have "Nazi" in it though) but I watched the Watchmen movie again recently and I'm pretty sure they mentioned a Captain Nazi in there too.

Red Hood very easily. He is better than Ollie in every way except marksmanship.

Red Hood wins without much difficulty, and I don't know how this is even close.

I stand by this.

@jashro44: it's not that their inferior, its just that their feats can't and won't be as good as their comic book counter parts

That isn't always the case.