Chaos Vs Mordor

Scenario: Two armies face off in Mordor. The Chaos army is at the black gate, they are sieging the land of mordor. The forces of Mordor must defend their land or be destroyed by the Chaos army. Keep in mind this is Fantasy Chaos, not 40k.

Setting:

Chaos

Army:

Archon, Everchosen (leader)

Warriors of Chaos - 4,000

Chosen Choas Warriors- 1,000

Chaos Knights (mounted on horseback)- 2,000

Bloodletters of Khorne- 1,000

Daemonettes of Slaanesh- 1,000

Plaguebearers of Nurgle - 1,000

Pink Horrors of Tzeentch - 1,000

Bloodletters of Khorne ( mounted on Flesh Hounds)- 500

Seekers of Slaanesh - 500

Screamers of Tzeentch - 500

Bloodcrushers of Khorne - 100

Flamers of Tzeentch - 100

Beasts of Nurgle - 50

Fiends of Slaanesh - 100

Heralds of Khrone ( mounted on a Juggernaut)- 6

Greater Deamons of Nurgle - 4

Greater Deamons of Slaanesh - 6

Greater Deamons of Tzeentch - 6

Bloodthirsters - 3

Nurgle Sorcerers - 30

Chaos Sorcerers - 40

Tzeentch Sorcerers - 30

Chaos Champion for each of the four gods of Chaos

Total: 12,977

Siege weaopns:

Catapults ( Heavy duty trebuchets) - 10

Battering rams ( Large ) 3

Steel Ladders - 20

Mordor

Army:

The Dark Lord Sauron (leader)

Mordor Orcs - 2,000

Uruk Kai- 1,000

Mordor Black Guards - 2,000

Orc Archers - 2,000

Trolls - 4,000

Nazgul (on Dragons)- 8

Witch King of Angmar (on dragon)

Mordor Orc Commanders - 100

Black Guard Commanders - 100

Mouth of Sauron

Mordor Orc Captains - 100

Warg Riders - 300

Orc Shamans - 300

Orc Shamans (on wargs) - 100

Goblin (on spiders) - 300

Goblin Warriors - 1,000

Goblin Archers - 1,000

Saruman

Gothmog

Balrogs - 2

Total: 14,312

Defenses:

The Gate

Catapults ( heavy duty trebuchets) - 6

Ramparts for archers

Troll rock throwers - 20

Who wins?

I dont know most of the chaos troops but im pretty sure 30 catapults is unstoppable with the right leader. 
 
actually now that i just did my quick run over before clicking post i just noticed Trolls - 4,000  now if there was ever anything tactically unbeatable its 4,000 trolls. 
 
so in conclusion idk. 

@Blood_guts: i like both armies so much, im so undecided as well hahah

^BUMP^ 
 
come on does anyone know anything about chaos? i only have an elementary knowledge of them and im curious how well their forces would stack up.

Orc Shamans? Mordor didn't have any orc shamans.

Also? Chaos rapes them. Orcs are in general bellow human soldiers in skill and power. Chaos warriors, to my knowledge, are not.

Also? Chaos rapes them. Orcs are in general bellow human soldiers in skill and power. Chaos warriors, to my knowledge, are not.

@AtPhantom: well, i searched for some units used in many things. in the tabletop war game, mordor does have orc shamans.... im not say this is fact but i thought it would help mordor a bit in their lack of magic.

@nick_hero22: ok clearly not dude, not at all. this is a very even fight, i worked on this for hours. DO NOT say spite EVER.

*COUGH* 4,000 TROLLS *COUGH*

Chaos Champion for each of the four gods of Chaos

Kharn The Betrayer would do serious damage in this fight combined with the other 3 champions this is a stomp.

The problem is how did the chaos army get into Mordor.. remember "One doesn't simply walk into Mordor."

Didn't Gothmog die before Sauron's rise to power/Morgoth's fall? Oh, wait, you're talking about the other one...

Mordor has a huge tactical advantage, being fortified. Even if Chaos would beat Mordor in a "fair" fight, they will take a lot of casualties just breaching the gate, and then there are 4000 trolls, 9 immortal warriors that "can't" be destroyed and the most powerful wizard in Middle-Earth. I'm leaning towards Mordor here.

Also, if Sauron is currently in possession of the ring(not specified), I'm sure Mordor would win.

@odinswrath said:

@AtPhantom: well, i searched for some units used in many things. in the tabletop war game, mordor does have orc shamans.... im not say this is fact but i thought it would help mordor a bit in their lack of magic.

Man that makes no sense. LOTR magic doesn't work that way. What the hell were they thinking?

@Blood_guts said:

however i would like to *ahem* you to the part where mordor has 4k trolls

What kind of trolls?

I dont know anything about Chaos, but the Mordor team is formidable. I cant decide because i have no idea about Chaos capabilities.....but 4000 trolls making up a large percentage of their army will be very hard to beat

Trolls may be morons but you can't argue with 4000 of them.

I went blank with all them Chaos terminologies I have no knowledge of. Nyehehe! To be honest, I can't decide until someone expounds on the Chaos side.

@Blood_guts said:

*COUGH* 4,000 TROLLS *COUGH*

AKA Comicvine! Nyahahahaha! And i'm one of them trolls! Woot Woot!

@Nova`Prime` said:

The problem is how did the chaos army get into Mordor.. remember "One doesn't simply walk into Mordor."

ROFLMA :D

Are Bloodthirsters anywhere near as cool and powerful as Balrogs? cuz if they aint, Mordor for the win. If they are, the i wouldn't know lol

@odinswrath: 

Chaos Champion for each of the four gods of Chaos

 

Kharn The Betrayer would do serious damage in this fight combined with the other 3 champions this is a stomp.

The problem is how did the chaos army get into Mordor.. remember "One doesn't simply walk into Mordor."

I dont know anything about Chaos, but the Mordor team is formidable. I cant decide because i have no idea about Chaos capabilities.....but 4000 trolls making up a large percentage of their army will be very hard to beat

@Blood_guts: LOL yes yes I did and it was good.

@AtPhantom said:

@Blood_guts said:

however i would like to *ahem* you to the part where mordor has 4k trolls

What kind of trolls?

The internet kind.

@Blood_guts: LOL yes yes I did and it was good.

@AtPhantom said:

@Blood_guts said:

however i would like to *ahem* you to the part where mordor has 4k trolls

What kind of trolls?

The internet kind.

@Blood_guts said:

truth

No thanks, I already learned the hard lesson to Never Again Volunteer Yourself from my time in the service.

But thanks again.