Catwoman vs Catwoman (movie versions)

we choose to Catwoman Batman Returns, and faced with Catwoman Batman Dark Knight Rises

in a confrontation in Gotham City, at night

No prep?

Who Wins?

I thought these were movie versions?

They look like cartoons to me according to the scans.

Batman returns Catwoman.

@CrimsonCake said:

Batman returns Catwoman.

Why?

If it's movie versions then its a stalemate.

Same characters, Just different actresses playing them is all.

@EnhancedHuman said:

@CrimsonCake said:

Batman returns Catwoman.

Why?

I use this argument a lot.Nolan wanted to make the world that batman lives in "realistic". Nolan Catwoman doesn't fight at the same capacity as you see in Burton Catwoman.

@Xanax said:

I thought these were movie versions?

They look like cartoons to me according to the scans.

corrected detail

Nolan's Selina Kyle, she actually has fighting feats, the only thing Burton's did was whip  a gun out of a guard's hand and die eight times.

@CrimsonCake said:

@EnhancedHuman said:

@CrimsonCake said:

Batman returns Catwoman.

Why?

I use this argument a lot.Nolan wanted to make the world that batman lives in "realistic". Nolan Catwoman doesn't fight at the same capacity as you see in Burton Catwoman.

why not? ...I think the new Catwoman is more "sophisticated" and a more complete equipment (weapons, motorcycle, etc).. The previous Catwoman is more "primitive" and only has a whip

and the new catwoman has better skills and techniques of martial arts

@Xanax said:

If it's movie versions then its a stalemate.

Same characters, Just different actresses playing them is all.

Not the same versions of the characters.

@CrimsonCake said:

Batman returns Catwoman.

No.

http://www.comicvine.com/forums/battles/7/cat-womanbatman-returns-vs-cat-womanthe-dark-knight-rises/681921/

Been done, by the way, Anne Hathaway stomps this. Michelle Pfeiffer has done nothing, absolutely 0, to prove she can take Anne.

As I said before ..the new Catwoman is more "sophisticated" and a more complete equipment (weapons, motorcycle, etc).. The previous Catwoman is more "primitive" and only has a whip

and the new catwoman has better skills and techniques of martial arts

Catwoman stomps