@Cochise said:
-Are X-23's arms filled with poison? No, but each hand and foot is armed with claws that can cut through steel with a casual swipe. One hit from those and Cassandra's in big trouble: losing an arm or leg, sustaining massive internal trauma, losing blood... I'm not really sure how this can be ignored. Characters like Cap have a special defense against this (the shield), and people like Logan hacve high-end healing factors and unbreakable skeletons to minimize the damage, but Cassandra doesn't have any of this. Why will she just bounce back from a slash that cuts through her quadriceps, or biceps, or guts?
Let me ask you a question. I've read most of X-23's appearances in New X-men and X Force, I've read nearly all of the miniseries that she appeared in, and I've read every issue to date of her ongoing. I haven't seen her face a single fighter so far with abilities and skills like Cass. Here's my question, how many times have you seen Laura fight someone who was her equal in speed that lost a limb or was cut so bad that they nearly bled to death? And how many of those people could effectively predict her movements? I may have missed or just haven't read it yet but I haven't seen it happen yet and until she faces someone like Mister X and nearly kills him with just one slice then I don't see anything like that happening against Cassandra. We both know Mister X has similar reading abilities to Cass and possibly even greater speed and that Wolverine is superior to Laura in h2h, speed, and strength but even he wasn't able to kill someone who could read him with just one slice or stab. Getting tagged doesn't mean that it will be that easy.
Cassandra can be hit.
This has been the base of your debate so far, but it's an over simplification.
Nightwing has done so on at least two occasions.
He has only done so through extreme difficulty in one instance and the other was plot induced, it had nothing to do with her not being fast enough or skilled enough to avoid being hit.
I'm not sure why that would be considered a "lucky shot." They've fought to a standstill
Because he himself admit that she's difficult for him to hit just not impossible. Their fight was very short and was interrupted, I don't think we could take that to mean he could beat her or even match her.
She was tagged by Joker during their only encounter.
The fact that you think Joker could actually tag her makes me not even know what to say. The joker has no h2h skills at all and when martial arts masters struggle to tag her that should let you know it's not plausible for him to be able to tag her at all.
She was tagged by Robin (Drake) in his series.
That would be in the poorly written story arc.
She was tagged by Shiva on multiple occasions.
Here's on of those that makes me question how much you know about each of these characters. Lady Shiva is the most skilled martial artist in the DCU aside from Richard Dragon, and aside from being that she's also been said to be able to read body language just like Cass can. Her speed is also comparable to Cassandra's.
She was tagged by Mr. Fun during their fight.
You can't be serious.
She was tagged by Black Canary during a sparring session.
There is a big difference between a spar and an actual fight. In a spar Cass is usually not even going all out and against Dinah she wasn't, and it was mostly used to show how much Dinah has grown in skill after training with Lady Shiva.
I'm sure for each of these events you have an explanation: She was drugged, she was angry, she was tired, they were sparring, it was that time of the month LOL etc. At the end of the day, it happens too often to write each one off due to circumstance. Note that I'm not arguing she's a bad fighter or lost these fights either!! Look at the opponents I've listed, most of them are great fighters. I'm just saying it isn't impossible to hit her... To say otherwise really begins to seem like favoritism.
Just as you can be sure that being tagged does not equate to being hit easily by any opponent. There's also the fact that Laura rarely eve shows her martial arts skills and that most of these fighters are at the very least near her skill set. Laura has never once killed someone by cutting them just once, so what makes you think the fight would end with Laura tagging Cass just once?
So why would X-23 have problems tagging her? Why do you think there's this massive skill gap between Cassandra and X-23? I'm genuinely curious because I don't see it. Both are A-list martial artists. Saying it's so because Cassandra beat Shiva doesn't cut it because X-23 can beat Shiva, along with plenty of other martial artists in the Marvel Universe.
For the exact same reason that every single person you named does, she can predict her movements. She won't just walk up and stab Cass through the chest then walk off and it will take more than just one hit to permanently put Cass down. It's like I've said many times, Laura doesn't even do severe damage to people who aren't able to read her so how could she tag someone just as fast as she is who can also read her moves?
Log in to comment