Casey Jones vs Catwoman

In character

IDW Casey Jones

Pre and Post New 52 Catwoman feats apply

Random encounter

Standard gear and abilities

Fight takes place at an unpopulated city block at night

Winner by KO, incapacitation or death

Who'd win? For what reasons?

Casey Jones takes her head off with his baseball bat

A Casey Jones battle? Nice!!!

@tparks: who do ya think would win, though?

Catwoman seems pretty bad ass taking on numerous opponents at once. Casey just had to retreat in the last issue I read and was saved by angel. but I won't hold that one issue. Does he have lots of training?

I know Cat Woman has fought evenly with Batman on at least a few occasions if we use Pre New 52, so I'm tempted to say her, but Casey Jones keeps up with Raph while fighting fodder, and has survived some pretty massive beatings and confrontations from Hun. It takes a lot to keep Jones down, and he is clearly superior to ninja fodder, but not really superior to any named characters in the series. He might be even or above Angel, who has at least somewhat held her own for a brief fight with Mikey. Mikey could have ended it pretty easily though, he was pretty much toying with her, since he wasn't even sure if she was an enemy or not.

If I had to throw a number out, I'd probably say 5/10 for both.

I think pure skill goes to Catwoman but as parks said Casey trumps in durability. Its gonna take alot to keep him down which could squeak him out a few wins. Not to mention punching a hockey-mask is no good for your hands :-) I say Catwoman 6/10.

BTW am I the only one who misses the original 80's version of Casey Jones who always had "THE OVERWHELMING URGE TO BREAK SOMETHING" and crazy hair.

Bumping my sexy@$$ thread

Maybe 50/50.

Slight majority for Catwoman. Casey's gonna make her work for it though.

Casey beats the pussy up.

Hahaha.......Doubt it, Selina is way more skilled and much faster than Casey. She would own him, in bed or otherwise.

@ancient_0f_days: got any feats for Catwoman?

Yeah.....props to @saren for initially making the post.

Bullet dodging:

Those are from fodder thugs. These are bullet dodging feats against Deathstroke and Deadshot. The latter is more impressive because she moves fast enough to swing Captain Boomerang around before the bullet can hit her.

Beats a Clayface-esque shapeshifter:

Beats Black Mask:

Scan 1: Moves fast enough that Captain Cold (who is pretty damn fast himself) is impressed by her speed. Scan 2-4: Beats Mr. Freeze.

Beats Hush, and tags Zeiss, a man who sees in slow motion and reacts several times faster than human beings are capable of:

Solo's the JLA. *straight face*

From the DCnU, beats up Reach:

Beats Wildcat:

Beats him again in a sparring match:

Apparently Selina was an inspiration for Babs or some such:

Carry on, Jeeves.

@ancient_0f_days:

Solo's the JLA

...Where is this from?

Catwoman #77 "Waking Up on the Wrong Side of the Universe 3"

Assuming she had no power amp, that's some of the worst PIS I've seen in a long time.

Blame Will Pfeifer.

What feats does Casey have that put him on Selina's level?

Hmm I'm leaning Casey here but not easily.

There isn't a single version of Casey that can beat Catwoman.

Catwoman has the skill and the speed to take down Casey, He is durable to be sure but Selina can wear him down. Her whip gives her a range advantage and Casey isn't throwing out anything she hasn't seen before. Casey won't go down easy but he will go down.

Pretty much.