#1 Edited by Sufferthorn (1734 posts) - - Show Bio

vs

Round 1:

Captain Kirk is alerted to a strange phenomenon in deep space, he orders the ship to pursue and detect what the phenomenon is.

Meanwhile Captain Picard is on an unspecified mission time-traveling in the past when he runs into the Enterprise 1701.

Kirk tries to order Uhura to hail this odd ship, but Picard doesn't respond. Kirk warns that he will attack if they will not comply, and so the battle begins.

VS

Note: For the sake of arguement....the Enterprise D(Galaxy Class) has somehow had it's Shield, Engine, Warp, and Weapons Capacity lowered to the level of an early Constitution-Class Starship.

This is somehow due to the Time-warp magnetic-displacement field-thingie-a-bobber.

Scenario 2:

The Following characters must fight each other in a H2H combat match, winner by KO. Who wins each bout?

Round 1: Kirk vs Picard.

VS

Round 2: Spock vs Worf

VS

Round 3: Chekov vs Wesley

VS

Round 4: Scotty vs Geordie.

VS

Round 5: Doctor McCoy vs Dr Crusher.(Drinking contest instead of Boxing)

VS

Scenario 3: Shootout.

Each of the Star and Co-starring characters are armed with a type 2 hand-phaser and a combat-knife.

They fight in this city on Vulcan

Exceptions: Spock's bladed weapon is

this

Worf's weapon is this.

They carry them on their backs.

#2 Posted by Kellar21 (444 posts) - - Show Bio

Hmm.Galaxy class is like 6 times bigger than a constitution so even if their tech is equal Galaxy has more power and would win.

Round 1: Kirk vs Picard.No contest here Kirk is younger,stronger and far more agile.Picard was never much of a fighter he preferred diplomacy or strategy.

Round 2: Spock vs Worf This one is hard but I think Spock is stronger and could use a Nerve Pinch,but wouldn't be an easy fight for any of them.

Round 3: Chekov vs Wesley Chekov is older and has best H2H feats he crushes Wesley

Round 4: Scotty vs Geordie.Hmm Geordie has best H2H feats.

Round 5: Doctor McCoy vs Dr Crusher.(Drinking contest instead of Boxing)No idea here.

On the shootout I think Next Generation crew can win I think they are better at strategies and teamwork.

Also nice Enterprise where it is from??

#3 Posted by Quartermaim (617 posts) - - Show Bio

Round 1: Kirk

Reason:Younger, faster, and more aggressive than Picard would probably overwhelm him. But Picard will probably bust his nose before going down.

Round 2: Spock

Reason: The calm before the storm, Worf will lose himself in the moment and Spock will take advantage.

Round 3: Chekov

Reason: Because he's beating up a teenager who has no training.

Round 4: Scotty

Reason: Even though Gordie has more feats, Scotty is more creative and will probably use his girth to overwhealm him.

Round 5: Doctor McCoy

Reason: Do you have any idea how much Romulan Ale that man consumes on a regular basis?

Scenario 3: Next Generation

Reason: Old Trek were like Cowboys, Newer Trek is more like the military. Next Generation works well together and do so on a regular basis.

#4 Posted by ClarkJosephKent1938DC (682 posts) - - Show Bio

Give Picards crew Data and he could kill all Kirks officers in h2h attacking him at once.

#5 Posted by Quartermaim (617 posts) - - Show Bio

@ClarkJosephKent1938DC said:

Give Picards crew Data and he could kill all Kirks officers in h2h attacking him at once.

Which is most likely why the OP didn't have Data in the fight.

#6 Posted by ClarkJosephKent1938DC (682 posts) - - Show Bio

Still Data was an essential part of TNG, It's like leaving out Spock from Kirks crew. It just isn't right.

#7 Posted by Quartermaim (617 posts) - - Show Bio

@ClarkJosephKent1938DC: True but is necessary to prevent a lock on this thread. Data could essentially waste both crews without difficulty.

#8 Posted by Kovak (748 posts) - - Show Bio

Overall, Kirk's crew has this.

#9 Posted by ClarkJosephKent1938DC (682 posts) - - Show Bio

Also Why no Riker? He could probably take out most of Kirks crew one on one possibly having trouble with Spock.