#1 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio

Well, would be an interesting battle indeed. But, if I had to choose, it would be Captain Atom... What do y'all think?

#2 Posted by Donnieman v5.1 (44323 posts) - - Show Bio

Gotta go with Surfer

#3 Posted by Dr. Victor von Doom (3118 posts) - - Show Bio

No clue

#4 Posted by lordraiden (6948 posts) - - Show Bio
Static Shock said:
"Well, would be an interesting battle indeed. But, if I had to choose, it would be Captain Atom... What do y'all think?"

if it's current Surfer, he trumps! He's been a beast since his upgrade, especially over in Nova!
#5 Posted by Alpha (7324 posts) - - Show Bio
I will go with the Surfer. Though CA would be a good opponent. The Power Cosmic would prove too much for him.
#6 Posted by Apparition (11349 posts) - - Show Bio

ss

#7 Posted by Theracles (1366 posts) - - Show Bio

Silver Surfer.

#8 Posted by SeSAW (3677 posts) - - Show Bio
Static Shock said:
"Well, would be an interesting battle indeed. But, if I had to choose, it would be Captain Atom... What do y'all think?"

No Static you gave Cap props with the respect thread but thats as far as it goes Caps not beating someone who can bust that suit and splatter his energy all over the place then absorb all the radiation. Surfer in a beat down..................
#9 Posted by Scarlet Thor (1112 posts) - - Show Bio

SS would beat captain Atom but if it was monarch then it's another story

#10 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio

Forgot all about this thread....

#11 Posted by VulCanDoItAll (10 posts) - - Show Bio

Monarch loses to Silver Surfer when he has the crunch Silver Surfer beats Captain ATom

#12 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio

if its the universe creating captain atom he wins in a stomp

if its monarch he wins in a stomp

#13 Posted by Ball Buster (2041 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if its the universe creating captain atom he wins in a stomp

if its monarch he wins in a stomp

"
I dont think so.
#14 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
Ball Buster said:
"Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if its the universe creating captain atom he wins in a stomp

if its monarch he wins in a stomp

"
I dont think so.
"
dude monarch is a universe buster and he stale mated superman prime
surfer gets housed badly
#15 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
Ball Buster said:
"Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if its the universe creating captain atom he wins in a stomp

if its monarch he wins in a stomp

"
I dont think so.
"
try to think before you speak dude
#16 Posted by Ball Buster (2041 posts) - - Show Bio

Dude?Why dont  u not say anything at all.

#17 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
Ball Buster said:
"Dude?Why dont  u not say anything at all."
because i actually know what im talking about
and not just some blind fanboy like some people are
#18 Posted by Ball Buster (2041 posts) - - Show Bio

I would say your a big time fangirl.

#19 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
Ball Buster said:
"I would say your a big time fangirl."
then your no good here

im ordering you to close your account and leave comicvine forever
#20 Posted by Ball Buster (2041 posts) - - Show Bio

Please.Do yourself a favor and stick your head in toilet and flush.

#21 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
Ball Buster said:
"Please.Do yourself a favor and stick your head in toilet and flush."
that is known as a swirley
#22 Posted by Ball Buster (2041 posts) - - Show Bio

Its called flushing brown waste,but as I was stating I don't think Cap Atom or Monarch would stomp SS but would very good fight.

#23 Posted by lordraiden (6948 posts) - - Show Bio
Ball Buster said:
"Its called flushing brown waste,but as I was stating I don't think Cap Atom or Monarch would stomp SS but would very good fight."

SS>CA
Monarch>SS

for the record :-)
#24 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio

superman prime would snap surfer in half and monarch stalemated him

monarch stomps surfer badly

and the captain atom that created a universe stomps surfer

#25 Posted by Vance Astro (91122 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"superman prime would snap surfer in half and monarch stalemated him

monarch stomps surfer badly

and the captain atom that created a universe stomps surfer"
FANBOY!
Moderator
#26 Posted by SeSAW (3677 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"superman prime would snap surfer in half and monarch stalemated him

monarch stomps surfer badly

and the captain atom that created a universe stomps surfer"
Superman prime can't beat Surfer, Monarch would be a good match but if his suit gets breeched he dies and surfer could just telport away.
#27 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm gonna say Captain Atom, but not by much.... I had to say it.

#28 Posted by E Man 4 (176 posts) - - Show Bio

The Power Cosmic too much 4 CA,or any other heroe 4 that matter. Norrin can do too many things. Only the Mystics I.E. Zatanna,Strange,Fate,Shazam,Stranger could stand against the Surfer.

#29 Posted by Hedatary (3768 posts) - - Show Bio

Cap atom would win.

#30 Posted by Vance Astro (91122 posts) - - Show Bio

I don't know much about Captain Atom so does anyone have a good explanation on why he wins?

Moderator
#31 Posted by Rapist (182 posts) - - Show Bio

ss

#32 Posted by Vance Astro (91122 posts) - - Show Bio
Vance Astro said:
"I don't know much about Captain Atom so does anyone have a good explanation on why he wins?"
Moderator
#33 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio
E Man 4 said:
"The Power Cosmic too much 4 CA,or any other heroe 4 that matter. Norrin can do too many things. Only the Mystics I.E. Zatanna,Strange,Fate,Shazam,Stranger could stand against the Surfer."
What makes you think the power Cosmic is too much for Atom? Can you explain?
#34 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio
Vance Astro said:
"I don't know much about Captain Atom so does anyone have a good explanation on why he wins?"

I think that Captain Atom's power over the Quantum Field could be enough for him to go toe-to-toe with the Surfer.
#35 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
Vance Astro said:
"I don't know much about Captain Atom so does anyone have a good explanation on why he wins?"
if hes monarch hes a universe buster

another version could create a universe

if its either of these two then surfer gets housed badly
#36 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio

Just a comparision....

I just think that the Quantum Field should be enough here. As for the Power Cosmic, there are plenty of things that the Surfer can do with it, but a lot of those things aren't used offensively (accelerate the evolution of lifeforms, see the past by peeling back the layers of time, time travel, trans dimensional travel, granting limited cosmic powers to others). With the Quantum Field, Atom cannot do these things (except for time travel), but most of the things Surfer can do offensively, Atom can do as well (matter/molecular manipulation, atomic transmutation, energy blasts, power over fundamental forces (including weak/strong force energy), power over all forms over energy, ability to negate energy manipulation abilities, infinite power source). While both possess superhuman strength (Atom on the level of Superman, and Surfer on the level on an enraged Hulk or greater), Atom could augment his Quantum energy to himself to enhance any of his abilities to infinite levels (strength, speed, reflexes, durability, endurance, etc...). Surfer could only augment the power Cosmic to his strength to infinity and not his other abilities. Looking at speed, Surfer is faster (only in hyperspace). No doubt. As for reflex speed, it's a toss up, yet Atom could make his reflex speed greater than Surfer's if he wanted. So, I'm confused as to why people think Atom couldn't stand up to Surfer... Then, there's the universe-making feat that Atom has. Surfer has never been able to do that with the power Cosmic. So, that says a lot about the Quantum Field, and how powerful it is. I just think people aren't giving Atom enough credit here, and yet, they are making the Power Cosmic seem like it's too much compared to the Quantum Field. People should really rethink this....

#37 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio

if this is monarch though
surfer is going to die a horrible death

#38 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if this is monarch though
surfer is going to die a horrible death"
I couldn't agree more. But, I'm talking about the original Captain Atom.
#39 Posted by Swagga Boy (3769 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"Ball Buster said:
"Please.Do yourself a favor and stick your head in toilet and flush."
that is known as a swirley"
lol
#40 Posted by Duke Checkmate III (361 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if this is monarch though
surfer is going to die a horrible death"
Why do you keep mentioning Monarch when nobody is talking about him?
#41 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
Duke Checkmate III said:
"Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if this is monarch though
surfer is going to die a horrible death"
Why do you keep mentioning Monarch when nobody is talking about him?"
monarch is captain atom fool
#42 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"monarch is captain atom fool"

Yeah. Same character. Different level of control and power... We're not using Monarch here, pimptight...
#43 Posted by Duke Checkmate III (361 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"Duke Checkmate III said:
"Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if this is monarch though
surfer is going to die a horrible death"
Why do you keep mentioning Monarch when nobody is talking about him?"
monarch is captain atom fool"
No...Tony Stark is Iron Man...It's not the same as Captain Atom being Monarch or Hal Jordan being Parallax...it's a different level of power.
#44 Posted by Static Shock (47329 posts) - - Show Bio

BUMP

#45 Posted by SeSAW (3677 posts) - - Show Bio

Listen

1.Surfer can absorb way more radiation than any version of Cap Atom has been shown to do
2.He can manipulate energy and matter itself

3.He can augment his physical strength past Superman level

4.He is faster than the any version of the Flash

5. His body is almost totally indistructable

6.He can heal people

7.He can alter his size

8.His cosmic awareness enables him to know the weakness of most beings instantly

9.He has some telepathy

10.He can create independant life

11. He can evolve life on a planatary scale

12.He can cast illusions

13.He can phase through solid objects

14.He can access the crunch

15.He can manipulate gravity

16.He can even influence emotion.

http://www.marvel.com/universe/Silver_Surfer



Cap Atom or even Monarch can't do half that stuff, yes I know Atom created a universe and all but what does that matter he still got beat by Superman while Surfer wouldn't lose to Supes.
In anihliation Surfer accessed the crunch to beat 2 Galactus level beings, so that's greater than any feat Cap or Monarch has ever done. Monarch was beaten by SBP. Also both of them need a suit to survive. Without the suit cap or Monarch can't live. Galactus created Surfer his body is indistructable.

Now! Bump or Ball or Bang or do whatever you want to do cause Silver Surfer wins and against regular Cap Atom he wins easy!

#46 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
SeSAW said:
"

Listen

1.Surfer can absorb way more radiation than any version of Cap Atom has been shown to do
2.He can manipulate energy and matter itself

3.He can augment his physical strength past Superman level

4.He is faster than the any version of the Flash

5. His body is almost totally indistructable

6.He can heal people

7.He can alter his size

8.His cosmic awareness enables him to know the weakness of most beings instantly

9.He has some telepathy

10.He can create independant life

11. He can evolve life on a planatary scale

12.He can cast illusions

13.He can phase through solid objects

14.He can access the crunch

15.He can manipulate gravity

16.He can even influence emotion.

http://www.marvel.com/universe/Silver_Surfer



Cap Atom or even Monarch can't do half that stuff, yes I know Atom created a universe and all but what does that matter he still got beat by Superman while Surfer wouldn't lose to Supes.
In anihliation Surfer accessed the crunch to beat 2 Galactus level beings, so that's greater than any feat Cap or Monarch has ever done. Monarch was beaten by SBP. Also both of them need a suit to survive. Without the suit cap or Monarch can't live. Galactus created Surfer his body is indistructable.

Now! Bump or Ball or Bang or do whatever you want to do cause Silver Surfer wins and against regular Cap Atom he wins easy!

"
you are an idiot
i agree surfer could beat a normal captain atom

but the unvierse creating atom would stomp surfer into the ground

and monarch would kill surfer in the blink of an eye

monarch stalemated superMAN prime

and prime would snap surfer in half in the blink of an eye

come back when you have a legit argument chump
#47 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
SeSAW said:
"

Listen

1.Surfer can absorb way more radiation than any version of Cap Atom has been shown to do
2.He can manipulate energy and matter itself

3.He can augment his physical strength past Superman level

4.He is faster than the any version of the Flash

5. His body is almost totally indistructable

6.He can heal people

7.He can alter his size

8.His cosmic awareness enables him to know the weakness of most beings instantly

9.He has some telepathy

10.He can create independant life

11. He can evolve life on a planatary scale

12.He can cast illusions

13.He can phase through solid objects

14.He can access the crunch

15.He can manipulate gravity

16.He can even influence emotion.

http://www.marvel.com/universe/Silver_Surfer



Cap Atom or even Monarch can't do half that stuff, yes I know Atom created a universe and all but what does that matter he still got beat by Superman while Surfer wouldn't lose to Supes.
In anihliation Surfer accessed the crunch to beat 2 Galactus level beings, so that's greater than any feat Cap or Monarch has ever done. Monarch was beaten by SBP. Also both of them need a suit to survive. Without the suit cap or Monarch can't live. Galactus created Surfer his body is indistructable.

Now! Bump or Ball or Bang or do whatever you want to do cause Silver Surfer wins and against regular Cap Atom he wins easy!

"
monarch is a universe buster
he could kill surfer by opening his helmet up

sorry dude but stale mating prime? that already beats anything surfer has or everywill do

monarch could literally kill surfer while exerting zero effort into it

hes on a whole other league and surfer would be a helpless child against him

surfer got beaten down by thanos all the time

a direct hit from prime could kill surfer on the spot

and monarch could kill him by waving his hand
#48 Edited by SeSAW (3677 posts) - - Show Bio
Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"SeSAW said:
"

Listen

1.Surfer can absorb way more radiation than any version of Cap Atom has been shown to do
2.He can manipulate energy and matter itself

3.He can augment his physical strength past Superman level

4.He is faster than the any version of the Flash

5. His body is almost totally indistructable

6.He can heal people

7.He can alter his size

8.His cosmic awareness enables him to know the weakness of most beings instantly

9.He has some telepathy

10.He can create independant life

11. He can evolve life on a planatary scale

12.He can cast illusions

13.He can phase through solid objects

14.He can access the crunch

15.He can manipulate gravity

16.He can even influence emotion.

http://www.marvel.com/universe/Silver_Surfer



Cap Atom or even Monarch can't do half that stuff, yes I know Atom created a universe and all but what does that matter he still got beat by Superman while Surfer wouldn't lose to Supes.
In anihliation Surfer accessed the crunch to beat 2 Galactus level beings, so that's greater than any feat Cap or Monarch has ever done. Monarch was beaten by SBP. Also both of them need a suit to survive. Without the suit cap or Monarch can't live. Galactus created Surfer his body is indistructable.

Now! Bump or Ball or Bang or do whatever you want to do cause Silver Surfer wins and against regular Cap Atom he wins easy!

"
monarch is a universe buster
he could kill surfer by opening his helmet up

sorry dude but stale mating prime? that already beats anything surfer has or everywill do

monarch could literally kill surfer while exerting zero effort into it

hes on a whole other league and surfer would be a helpless child against him

surfer got beaten down by thanos all the time

a direct hit from prime could kill surfer on the spot

and monarch could kill him by waving his hand"

Ha Ha Ha so I just told you that Surfer was able to access a force that allowed him to defeat 2 not one but 2 Galactus level beings. Are you saying that Superboy Prime or Monarch is equal or more powerful than those beings huh? And also you do know that surfer can drain and manipulate energy right even red sun energy he could easily beat Prime. You never read a SS comic before have you. I can tell I have seen your ignorance regarding him in your other posts.
#49 Posted by King Saturn (223829 posts) - - Show Bio
Static Shock said:
"Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"if this is monarch though
surfer is going to die a horrible death"
I couldn't agree more. But, I'm talking about the original Captain Atom."
Wait A Minute... you are using the Captain Atom who was able to create and destroy a Galaxy through Matter Manipulation ?
#50 Posted by Hal_Jordan1986 (292 posts) - - Show Bio
SeSAW said:
"Hal_Jordan1986 said:
"SeSAW said:
"

Listen

1.Surfer can absorb way more radiation than any version of Cap Atom has been shown to do
2.He can manipulate energy and matter itself

3.He can augment his physical strength past Superman level

4.He is faster than the any version of the Flash

5. His body is almost totally indistructable

6.He can heal people

7.He can alter his size

8.His cosmic awareness enables him to know the weakness of most beings instantly

9.He has some telepathy

10.He can create independant life

11. He can evolve life on a planatary scale

12.He can cast illusions

13.He can phase through solid objects

14.He can access the crunch

15.He can manipulate gravity

16.He can even influence emotion.

http://www.marvel.com/universe/Silver_Surfer



Cap Atom or even Monarch can't do half that stuff, yes I know Atom created a universe and all but what does that matter he still got beat by Superman while Surfer wouldn't lose to Supes.
In anihliation Surfer accessed the crunch to beat 2 Galactus level beings, so that's greater than any feat Cap or Monarch has ever done. Monarch was beaten by SBP. Also both of them need a suit to survive. Without the suit cap or Monarch can't live. Galactus created Surfer his body is indistructable.

Now! Bump or Ball or Bang or do whatever you want to do cause Silver Surfer wins and against regular Cap Atom he wins easy!

"
monarch is a universe buster
he could kill surfer by opening his helmet up

sorry dude but stale mating prime? that already beats anything surfer has or everywill do

monarch could literally kill surfer while exerting zero effort into it

hes on a whole other league and surfer would be a helpless child against him

surfer got beaten down by thanos all the time

a direct hit from prime could kill surfer on the spot

and monarch could kill him by waving his hand"

Ha Ha Ha so I just told you that Surfer was able to access a force that allowed him to defeat 2 not one but 2 Galactus level beings. Are you saying that Superboy Prime or Monarch is equal or more powerful than those beings huh? And also you do know that surfer can drain and manipulate energy right even red sun energy he could easily beat Prime. You never read a SS comic before have you. I can tell I have seen your ignorance regarding him in your other posts."
monarch and the guardians of the universe had the power to manipulate energy and rearrange matter at a moleculer level

three guardians each could snap surfer in half by blinking couldnt beat prime

and monrach has energy and matter control at sub atomic levels

he could stlaemate prime

your a marvel fanboy face it dude

prime snaps surfer in half

surfer could try to drain him of his solar energy

but surfer isnt going to survive a hit from prime

monarch whos a 100% universe buster could kill surfer by waving his hand

learn a little bout the comics before you speak my dim witted friend