Captain America vs. Rorschach + Batman (with twist)

Captain America (movie) vs. Batman and Rorschach in a team (movies as well).

Here's the twist: Cap is dressed as Rorschach, Rorschach is dressed as Batman, and Batman is dressed as Cap.

No prep time (so Batman doesn't have time to learn how to use Cap's shield, for example), morals off, Cap and Rorschach are bloodlusted, battle in dimly-lit, rainy NYC street. Who wins?

Even with the change in gear...this is going to end up like Ozy vs Rorschach and Nite Owl.

Who’s strong and brave, here to save the American Way?

Who vows to fight like a man for what’s right night and day?

Who will campaign door-to-door for America,

Carry the flag shore to shore for America,

From Hoboken to Spokane,

The Star Spangled Man with a Plan!

@sheenlantern: utter tripe . that superman wannabe is gonna get his ass handed to him if it were comic versions. movie version probably wins though

Captain America is a Superman Wannabe? How do you figure?

Superman is a Kryptonian

Captain America is Human

Superman can fly, has incalculable strength, Heat Vision, Frost Breath, Super Speed, Super Durability...etc

Captain America Throws a Shield.

@shawnbaby: Throws a shield.....For America ;)

Cap wins, superior in basically every way. That and movie Rorschach was just brutal, not a good fighter

'MURICA!!

Bruce would be the last man standing.

Steve without his shield is at a much bigger disadvantage than Bruce without his utility belt and uniform, especially as Steve is now wearing Roschach's costme, which has no armoring at all and sports a trenchcoat, which impedes movement more than he's used to. Bruce lacks his traditional gear, but still has some armoring from Steve's uniform (which undoubtedly weighs less than his own outfit and gear, giving him more strength, speed, and agility than he's normally capable of.)

Bruce often fights opponents without utilizing his standard equipment, merely relying on his physical attributes and martial skills, whereas Steve almost always relies on his shield, if only to block blows and projectiles. He'll be severely off his game without it, not that he doesn't still maintain major skill in hand to hand combat. Still, the lack of any protection, the loss of his standard defensive and offensive gear, and the fact that Bruce is far more used to fighting without his equipment, still has protection, and is faster, stronger, and more agile than usual (not as weighted down by equipment as he usually would be), not to mention a superior hand to hand combatant, puts Steve in an uncomfortable position, his only advantage being his slight physical advantages.

I don't feel they will be enough, especially when one takes into account that Steve's standard gear going to Bruce would actually include a few smoke and concussion grenades in addition to the shield. Rorschach is really the smallest factor here as he doesn't have the skills to stand up to either character on equal footing, good as he may be. He'll also have no idea what is in Bruce's belt, and is unlikely to stop to figure it out while in the midst of battle. The one piece of equipment he might use is the magnetic grapnel, which is easily recognizable for what it is, and which he wouldn't hesitate to put through Steve's body parts (re-watch the film if you're wondering why I think so), hampering him a bit more in his fight with Bruce if he succeeds. He couldn't win a hand to hand competition unless he did as such.