Captain America vs Green Arrow

Captain America (Marvel movies) vs Green Arrow (Arrow TV show). Both are in-character, random encounter, standard gear, and the fight takes place in an abandoned warehouse. Battle is to the death or incapacitation. Who wins and why?

Cap.

Better stats all around. More impressive feats. Roughly the same fighting skill.

Been done to death, and yeah Arrow has some new feats, but still not enough to put him over cap in a significant way.

@lukehero: AAAAG we disagree on something. Movie Cap has greater strength, agility, and a weapon (the shield) that can fend off any of Oliver's arrows. I hate to admit this (because in general I "like" DC better) but in this particular battle---Captain America wins.

@lukehero: OOOOPS I totally misread your post; we agree that Cap wins. sorry about that (YEEEESH).

I like GA but Ollie gets his ass handed to him here.

What he said.

Cap wins but not in a stomp.

Cap wins under these circumstances.

How many times does Cap have to stomp this fight? Does Arrow stand a chance?

Cap easily. He's much faster, more skilled, stronger, and of course he has his shield.

I'm assuming the premise behind this fight is 1) they're pretty much the top live-action street levelers at the moment and 2) Ollie defeated Deathstroke so he should have a chance here. The problem is, as it was already pointed out, this battle has been done to death. Ollie defeated Slade after he was given the cure so that doesn't really help his case here. No doubt Ollie is a skilled fighter (possibly more skilled than Cap) and he has some truly exceptional reaction feats, but the shield is going to be difficult to get around in a random encounter with no prep, and overall Cap has the better physicals. It's not a stomp, but Captain America wins.

@indomitableregal: No version of Arrow is a better fighter than Cap after he created his own martial art of a mashup of every technique known to man. In Captain America: The Winter Soldier, the director made it clear that Steve has reached that point.

Steve takes another victory!

Batman

Captain America.

Not easily, he's not more skilled, and Arrow has more gear.

Cap ..pretty sure cap can take hawkeye and hawkeye and green arrow are pretty even

Steve does win easily. Oliver is outclassed completely in physicals. Steve is a mixed martial artist, and he knows Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, karate, boxing, Parkour, and Krav Maga (revealed by the filmmakers). Oliver on the other hand knows an unknown number of unknown martial arts; we can guess at which ones and how many, but we don't truly know. But he's done nothing to suggest he has more skill than Steve, considering he's beaten other skilled martial artists who know an unknown number of martial arts. As for Oliver's gear, almost all of the gear he is willing to use in character are damn near inconsequential in fighting Steve. Regular arrowheads are going to bounce off the shield. So overall, Oliver's gear means little.

Captain America takes this one pretty easily.

Cap pretty damn easily

I never heard the director's commentary, but based on on-screen feats, I'm gonna have to disagree. I think Ollie has shown to be at least equal to Cap in skill.

Even though I agree that Steve takes this, his skill is no where near that of Oliver's.

I am starting to think you are an Arrow Fanboy. Please watch Winter Soldier @rbt

Watched it. Loved the movie. Oliver is still more skilled.

Don't tag me.

@rbt no he is not. Bye