Interesting. Don't know whether this has been done already or not but interesting nonetheless. Evidently both are among the best hand to hand combatants in their respective universes. Cap I would say has a physical advantage due to the super soldier serum increasing his abilities to peak human ability in all respects but Batman has a much more strategic mind. Not saying Steve doesn't use strategy just that Bruce is better in that respect. It would be incredibly close but for me, Bruce would find a way to come out on top against Steve. He'd eventually find a weakeness in Steve's fighting style before Steve finds Bruce's weak spot.
Going with Cap. Cap was a soldier who kills. If an opening to kill comes up Bats would ignore it. Cap may kill him. Thats the only advantage i can see.
Batman would have to be a ridiculously better fighter than Cap in order to compensate for super soldier serum. Don't see it happening in Bruce's favor.
Yea Cap wins this in a close fight. Batman is an Olympic Level Human. Cap is one level higher than that - Stronger, faster, quicker and more durable than Bats.
Retro TV Versions (Adam West vs Reb Brown) -Batman wins due to feats and PIS
Movie Versions 1 (Matt Salinger -1990 vs Michael Keaton) -Batman. He is just plain better and more badass
Movie Versions 2 (2011 Film vs Nolanverse) -Cap would punch Bats's head off his neck.
616 Cap vs New Earth Bats (not new 52, I don't know him yet) -Caps win 5.5/10 fights. The crossover may be quasi-canon but it does a great job in reflecting what will happen in a fight between a peak human fighter who's roamed the world learning martial arts from masters here and there against a slightly enhanced human fighter that has learned virtually all martial arts but most of them through "urbanized" masters.
Ultimate Cap vs New Earth Bats -Superhuman Cap would own.
Retro TV Versions (Adam West vs Reb Brown) -Batman wins due to feats and PIS Movie Versions 1 (Matt Salinger -1990 vs Michael Keaton) -Batman. He is just plain better and more badass Movie Versions 2 (2011 Film vs Nolanverse) -Cap would punch Bats's head off his neck. 616 Cap vs New Earth Bats (not new 52, I don't know him yet) -Caps win 5.5/10 fights. The crossover may be quasi-canon but it does a great job in reflecting what will happen in a fight between a peak human fighter who's roamed the world learning martial arts from masters here and there against a slightly enhanced human fighter that has learned virtually all martial arts but most of them through "urbanized" masters. Ultimate Cap vs New Earth Bats -Superhuman Cap would own.
Usually i say Batman in these "Cap vs Bat" battles..however the only real advantage Batman has over him is his gadgets...so i'm giving it to Steve on this one
Ok First off Bruce is peak human.Steve is also peak human but its pretty common knowledge that his stats are better than Bruces (Though not by a tremendous means) Way i see it Steve has an physical edge here,Bruce has a skill edge.In my opinion skill beats stregth every time in comics so i give this to batman
What's this supposed to prove? Concievable,CONCIEVABLE.It's concievable that i will become the UN secretary general one day.
Why is the "conceivable" the word in question? I see more issue with the word "could". It just says Cap has the ability to beat Bats. That's a given. They're pretty much on the same level and people on the same level could beat one another. It does not say Cap "will" surely beat Bats.
Ok First off Bruce is peak human.Steve is also peak human but its pretty common knowledge that his stats are better than Bruces (Though not by a tremendous means) Way i see it Steve has an physical edge here,Bruce has a skill edge.In my opinion skill beats stregth every time in comics so i give this to batman
If Batman has a skill edge over Cap it is not by much at all. As such, I dont think the VERY slight edge in technique will compensate for the physical superiority that Cap has over bats, not to mention that Cap can fight for a hell of a lot longer than Bats.
Tough fight but I'm leaning towards Captain America. He's got the edge with his Supersoldier Serum-enhanced strength, speed, agility and reactions. Bruce is on par with olympic athletes, but Cap borders on superhuman. Won't be easy, but Cap will come on top imo.
Log in to comment