Buffy vs Phoebe Halliwell

Fight until  KO

I will give this to Buffy. Phoebe is capable fighter but not on the same level as Buffy and I don't see how her powers will help her in this fight unless she can somehow channel Buffy's powers with her empathy which I doubt. Levitation may give help her a bit in this fight but I believe that Buffy can still take her.

Buffy 
those witches hardly have any fighting skills

" @hydrabob: Actually in several episodes they showed that they have very decent fighting skills, well at least Phoebe, Paige and Prue although not close to Buffy. Piper didn't rely on physical combat a lot. "

@ queenfrost_Phoebe never could anticipate opponents moves with her premonition power and Buffy has defeated a telepath before !!! I think what gives phoebe a chance is her talent with writing spells, she was always the best. But Buffy could easily knock her out with one punch!!!
BUffy wins she's stronger and a better fighter!

" @ComicMan24 said:

" @hydrabob: Actually in several episodes they showed that they have very decent fighting skills, well at least Phoebe, Paige and Prue although not close to Buffy. Piper didn't rely on physical combat a lot. "

True  Phoebe could possibly channel Buffy's powers, but would only be able to block it. Her levitation could come in handy, plus her premonition, which means she could anticipate Buffy's every move.  Phoebe "

Buffy. 
& I think it's important to remember what kind of witches that Buffy is used to running with. Willow Rosenberg would annihilate the Charmed girls.

Buff.

Phoebe would put up a good fight and Phoebe has used her empathy powers to channel telekenisis and fireballs before...Even though Phoebe has no prep time she does have a few good spells locked up in her head.

Yeah, she channeled those but as SoS said she never used her empathy to channel a physical ability so we don't know if this is even possible. As for the spells,Phoebe doesn't normally uses them in battles except vanquishing spells plus trying to think of a spell while trying to avoid a punch isn't the easiest thing in the world. Also isn't the use of the spells in this battle unfair for Buffy?

" Phoebe would put up a good fight and Phoebe has used her empathy powers to channel telekenisis and fireballs before...Even though Phoebe has no prep time she does have a few good spells locked up in her head. "

" @Son Of Storm:  Urm, okay? Phoebe could easily recite spells under her breath. Plus, Phoebe has fought endless DEMONS, remember? She's survived many hits from them so she could put up a fight against Buffy. If Phoebe can resist fireball and energy ball attacks, she can resist Buffy. "

If it's speed blitz Buffy wins, if not Phoebe wins

I wouldn't call it so much a resistance. More like sloppy writing. I mean in some epsodes, demons would completely annilate someone with their fire and energy balls and in others, only caused some burns. IIRC, there is no Banshee spell, what was said in the season 7 finale was also bad writing IMO. The only way for a witch to become is through the wail of a Banshee. As for the spell to steal powers, that requires a potion (the episode with the Stillman sisters was full of errors).

" @Son Of Storm: IF you actually watched the series, she eventually developed resistance to energy balls and fire balls. Okay it would throw her about a bit and giver her a graze but still. And yes, they would have strong morals, but Phoebe could use the Banshee spell, the turn into an animal spell or even steal her powers spell. "

" I don't think Phoebe would win an all out physical fight with Buffy, but Phoebes sparring partner was a super strong demon with a bunch of other powers, she does not use her combat skills against normal people, she is battle honed to fight demons and warlocks all of which have various degrees of superhuman strength, she can last for a while and her premonition power does give her a degree of intution that allows her to evade being hit which may give a chance to deal with some of Buffys speed (not for long though) 

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

that seems like quite a stretch to me. She's no Paul Muad'dib... "

doesn't matter what you think she did it "

Buffy would swiftly pummel Phoebe. Actually, I've always felt she could take out all the Charmed ones at once.

" Buffy would swiftly pummel Phoebe. Actually, I've always felt she could take out all the Charmed ones at once. "

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

that seems like quite a stretch to me. She's no Paul Muad'dib... "

doesn't matter what you think she did it "

Buffy. Stronger, faster, more skilled and more experienced in h2h combat. :) 

" Buffy. Stronger, faster, more skilled and more experienced in h2h combat. :)  "

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" I don't think Phoebe would win an all out physical fight with Buffy, but Phoebes sparring partner was a super strong demon with a bunch of other powers, she does not use her combat skills against normal people, she is battle honed to fight demons and warlocks all of which have various degrees of superhuman strength, she can last for a while and her premonition power does give her a degree of intution that allows her to evade being hit which may give a chance to deal with some of Buffys speed (not for long though) 

I don't recall her using her premonition power in a balls-out rock 'em sock 'em fight like Buffy will bring. "

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

that seems like quite a stretch to me. She's no Paul Muad'dib... "

doesn't matter what you think she did it "

So how long do you think this little intuition will last? "

I figure it will only be needed to counter Buffys speed or even dodge enough to get off a quick spell.  I doubt Phoebe will go that route (spell casting), but there is the untested "We call upon medusas bones turn their flesh into stone" spell. "

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

that seems like quite a stretch to me. She's no Paul Muad'dib... "

doesn't matter what you think she did it "

So how long do you think this little intuition will last? "

I figure it will only be needed to counter Buffys speed or even dodge enough to get off a quick spell.  I doubt Phoebe will go that route (spell casting), but there is the untested "We call upon medusas bones turn their flesh into stone" spell. "

Do you really think Phoebe would use a spell that "lethal" with "strong morals" on? "

" Buffy would swiftly pummel Phoebe. Actually, I've always felt she could take out all the Charmed ones at once. "

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

that seems like quite a stretch to me. She's no Paul Muad'dib... "

doesn't matter what you think she did it "

So how long do you think this little intuition will last? "

I figure it will only be needed to counter Buffys speed or even dodge enough to get off a quick spell.  I doubt Phoebe will go that route (spell casting), but there is the untested "We call upon medusas bones turn their flesh into stone" spell. "

Do you really think Phoebe would use a spell that "lethal" with "strong morals" on? "

I actually like that spell xD Phoenix your talented xD :D<3
 
But since its high morals, I would give it to Buffy, she doesn't care as long as she gets her job done, but she won't kill Phoebe for no reason. 

" @Charmix said:

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

that seems like quite a stretch to me. She's no Paul Muad'dib... "

doesn't matter what you think she did it "

So how long do you think this little intuition will last? "

I figure it will only be needed to counter Buffys speed or even dodge enough to get off a quick spell.  I doubt Phoebe will go that route (spell casting), but there is the untested "We call upon medusas bones turn their flesh into stone" spell. "

Do you really think Phoebe would use a spell that "lethal" with "strong morals" on? "

I actually like that spell xD Phoenix your talented xD :D<3
 
But since its high morals, I would give it to Buffy, she doesn't care as long as she gets her job done, but she won't kill Phoebe for no reason. 

Yea. Buffy doesn't have to kill her. "

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Charmix said:

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @Son Of Storm said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

" @ninjabot said:

" @Phoenix of the Black Throne said:

because you are focusing on the vision part of it, it gives her heightened intution like when she was able evade the energy balls of the demon that was using Tempus to rewind time so that he could kill the charmed ones, Phoebe was able to sense that something was wrong with the time stream and anticipate his energy attacks. "

that seems like quite a stretch to me. She's no Paul Muad'dib... "

doesn't matter what you think she did it "

So how long do you think this little intuition will last? "

I figure it will only be needed to counter Buffys speed or even dodge enough to get off a quick spell.  I doubt Phoebe will go that route (spell casting), but there is the untested "We call upon medusas bones turn their flesh into stone" spell. "

Do you really think Phoebe would use a spell that "lethal" with "strong morals" on? "

I actually like that spell xD Phoenix your talented xD :D<3
 
But since its high morals, I would give it to Buffy, she doesn't care as long as she gets her job done, but she won't kill Phoebe for no reason. 

Yea. Buffy doesn't have to kill her. "

:D only knock her senseless xD "

Pheobe. Because she's way stronger in power

Phoebe pwns. Charmed witches can literally make up spells and if it rhymes, it happens. Since she can hold her own physically as well, she has time to think one up.

Buffy is not going to let Phoebe sit there and start thinking up a spell. And besides she rarely even does that unless for major threats. Phoebe is not even a good fighter. And her levitation kick is slow as hell. Buffy will knock her out in one or two hits.

Buffy no doubt

Not only can pheobe whip up a spell to take her out, but she can just levitate out of the way and continue to kick her in the head.

@tariqjp: lol

Define "all her powers" Cause if this includes access to the powers of her past lives or the powers she had when she was pregnant with the Source's child then how can she lose

lol. Buffy beats her into ground. Buffy can effortlessly lift steel beams, something that requires at least 8-10 men to do.

@gxrevolution96: if buffy can do that then so can pheobe as her power of empathy lets her copy the powers of her opponents.

@thecannon

Jmarshmallow