Brandon Routh's SUPERMAN vs Christopher Reeve's SUPERMAN

Both bloodlusted

______________________

Morals off

_______________________

This battle for the DEAD

_______________________

Fight for Lois

________________________

2 days sundip. for (Reeve,Routh)

________________________

"Speed feats are equal"

_________________________

Area:Metropolis without "Kryptonite,Civilians"

__________________________

Who wins and WHY ?

vs

IBTL

@allstarsuperman: lock for what ?

Reeve uses this on Routh:

Because Reeve obviously wins

tell me how ?

@dorukesin: Reeve Superman moved the moon with a smile, Took on 3 Kryptonian soldiers, fought his equal evil self, fought a more powerful clone of himself, and had vast amount of random powers. Routh never fought anyone.

@allstarsuperman:

so Routh have unique durability,he lifted a kryptonite continental and pushed it into a space

I think they're supposed to be within the same continuity.

They are

@dorukesin: that's not enough to beat Reeve. and it was a island, I don't think it ever got to continent size.

yes they are but they don't showed identical feats

not really, is Current Thor the same as classic Thor? yes and no

@allstarsuperman: you don't think it but it is.Watch Superman Returns again.Lex showed "full size continent" in the map.

also i mean durability with this feat,not strength

but still, Routh never fought anybody. ever. his only fighting feat is being kicked to crap by Lex.

@allstarsuperman said:

"without his powers(kryptonite)"

I would like to remind you,what could Reeve do without his powers

(i cry every time when i watched this scene)

@dorukesin: OK. I see your point. And that scene is sad. But I see Reeve winning this 10/10. There's no way Routh could win.

@allstarsuperman said:

man,my favorite character is Christopher Reeve.But i don't acting like fanboy there

How could Reeve take Routh down without his speed ?

@dorukesin: Reeve is still stronger. Has fighting experience. And a vast amount of random powers.

Actually, the kneel before Zod part was hilarious. Specially when he realizes the President isn't kneeling and forces him to.

@allstarsuperman: Man,Superman Returns is Reeve's Superman's sequel

So practically,Routh's experience > Reeve's experience

rise before zod is better dude :D

feats alone reeve stomps,routh superman was better than henry in the new one,just a crappy story screwed routh up.

They're the same guy.

Routh wins due to more experience.

Routh Supes wins. Routh Superman is obviously the same Superman that Reeve is, only a lot more experienced, godlike even. Keep in mind that even Kryptonite weakened he threw a continent into space!

Reeve obviously takes the win on this one. There is a reason Routh only had one movie