#1 Posted by TifaLockhart (15470 posts) - - Show Bio

I tried posting this several times earlier today but it wouldn't take I don't think.

The rule for this scenario is that we are debating as if it were the year 1996. Who and why?

#2 Posted by Crom-Cruach (8935 posts) - - Show Bio

Where in the timeline are we talking about with Duncan Macloud? Because his power level increased dramatically as the series went.

#3 Posted by Super_SoldierXII (7178 posts) - - Show Bio

I get that Bone Wolverine can be decapitated. And I get that the Highlander has spent hundreds of years mastering the art of decapitation through swordplay.

But I don't see Wolverine going down to that ... it's very hard to credibly pit a T.V / Movie fictional character against a comic book one as 9/10 the comic character just has far, far better feats. Bone Wolverine has dropped dozens upon dozens of blade wielding ninjas at once for instance ... I mean, has Highlander ever taken on even just a dozen skilled foes at once?

Bone Wolverine carves Macleod up with ease IMHO. Duncan has the skill to take a few perhaps, but not a majority.

#4 Posted by Crom-Cruach (8935 posts) - - Show Bio

Duncan Macloud has taken on dozens of armed foes, many many times. Both in his comic appearances and in the show. Furthermore, each time he killed an immortal he grew better all around stat wise. He earned the dead immortal's skills and memories, his attributes improved as did his abilities. By the end of the series before it became crap, he had over 600 immortals to his name including immortals that were far above wolverine in physical attributes (including Kronos the strongest immortal ever seen in the show). If Duncan is in his final episode iteration he could easily defeat wolverine being more skilled then him and better physically. Don't let the crappy special effects of the show fool you. Duncan was a beast by the end of the series.

#5 Posted by Shawnbaby (11026 posts) - - Show Bio

Wolverine has this due to superior Skill, Speed, Durability, and Ferocity. Duncan is good but has nothing to suggest combat speeds that come even close to what Wolverine is capable of.