Black Canary vs Huntress

No Canary Cry.

No Weapons.

who wins?

Black Canary is a much more skilled fighter than Huntress, so I give it to Canary.

black cannary much better fighter

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zkYdT_FO2iQ

Black Canary

Black Canary isn't going to lose to many people in a straight fight without powers or weapons and definitely not to the Huntress. Canary has this one wrapped up. And if Canary Cry and Weapons were activated, I'd still give it to Canary unless Huntress managed to get the drop on her pre-fight.

Black Canary.

Black Canary

Black Canary rather easily, Helena isn't exactly the best fighter in the Bat Family.

@insanepayne7 said:

Black Canary is a much more skilled fighter than Huntress, so I give it to Canary.

This

Canary's got this.

@tomlikesfries said:

Canary's got this.

Canary stomps hard.

Surprised this isn't locked yet.

In terms of attractiveness it's a dead heat.

In a fight Black Canary wins. Better trained. More experience. More disciplined.

@charlieboy said:

Canary stomps hard.

Even though I believe Black Canary would win, people tend to low ball Helena saying she isn't up there in fighting skill. Let's not forget she's had training from Richard Dragon, who is the top fighter, was chosen by Batman to be Batgirl during No Man's Land, and could hang pretty good with Nightwing in a fight. Also Helena fights dirty.

Dinah wins.

Yes, I would agree with the majority here that Black Canary would win out in the end (at least most of the time) against Huntress and even without her screaming ability aka "Canary Cry." However, I agree with one comment here that stated the underestimation of Huntress by too many.

Dinah wouldn't win as easily as it's been said here and perhaps elsewhere. First off, even though Dinah has mastered more martial arts and had training from some of the best fighters in the DC Universe like Wildcat, Lady Shiva, Cassandra Cain, and Wonder Woman, Huntress is a master martial artist herself and is at least as expert a gymnast as she is. In addition to having training from Richard Dragon, who is also one of the best fighters in the DC Universe, she was impressive enough to be chosen by Batman to be Batgirl during No Man's Land. Her skills were suited enough to surprise and garner some praise from one of DC Universe's master martial artists, Lady Shiva. If it came down to weapons, melee and long range, Huntress is an expert in various types and would more than prove her worth against Dinah.

So no, given all of that, even though overall Dinah would fairly likely win in most cases, it wouldn't be by as big of a margin as most would suggest. Helena would give her at least a fairly rousing fight.

dinah wins 10/10 but huntress isn’t bad (just not on canary’s level)

This. I am really enjoying the fact that Rebirth/New 52 Helena is actually somewhat a really skilled individual

Dinah

Black Canary

Huntress beat Shiva, Black Canary did not