Depends, are you using their comic book appearances or movie appearances?
Big Daddy in the movie was pretty ownage in his fight scene. he was able to take out like a factory of guys all wielding guns. I think there were somewhere around 20 different guys actually.
What's funny is the actors that played both characters kind of look alike with the mustache and all.
Yeah, that was a very ownage fight. I don't even know if movie Batman can do the same.
Big Daddy was able to slowly walk around and own every thug and use their bodies as body armor and their own weapons to mortally wound them all. He made it look easier than me going to the fridge! I don't even think any of them was able to get a single hit off of him or engaged him in any kind of way. I'm glad they had that scene to show his battle prowess.
Did you like the Kick-Ass movie?
haven't seen watchmen in awhile but comedian seemed much more like a soldier than a fighter, don't get me wrong he could probably take any average guy but a fighter like big daddy was shown to be would more likely than not win, in my own opinion.