• 104 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
#1 Posted by YoungGunna (2439 posts) - - Show Bio

No Prep time

Battle starts on a asteroid
No Morals
Start 70 meters away 
Current versions

VS

 WHO WINS
#2 Posted by JediXMan (31268 posts) - - Show Bio

I think John would win after a decent fight.

Moderator
#3 Posted by baron2011 (1155 posts) - - Show Bio

john

#4 Posted by Kallarkz (3295 posts) - - Show Bio
I believe after a very decent fight John could take it. He is a beast with that ring.
#5 Posted by dccomicsrule2011 (26848 posts) - - Show Bio

john wins

Online
#6 Posted by YoungGunna (2439 posts) - - Show Bio

BUMP

#7 Posted by Nefarious (22882 posts) - - Show Bio

John Stewart will win.

#8 Posted by termiteone4ever (7982 posts) - - Show Bio

There is no way BRB beat Bill not in this life time. John got too much feats in speed power and will to defeat Bill .

#9 Posted by Hoboseid (1019 posts) - - Show Bio


I think Bill wins, he doesn't job around like Thor. He is smart enough to go for the energy drain. Plus Bill is more durable than Thor if you get to blast him and get close he can soak a hell of a lot of punishment. If you get close to John he's just a man ready to go splat.

Plus Lanterns don't have many speed feats

 

 

I believe John Stewart would kill Thor though, Thor just doesn't fight smart anymore

 

but a guy like Bill with morals off would win

#10 Posted by King Saturn (225080 posts) - - Show Bio
interesting battle... I want Green Lantern John Stewart to win... but Mystical Mr. Ed is Pretty Intense with his Power Set... I think I will give John Stewart 6 out of 10 here regardless... 
#11 Posted by termiteone4ever (7982 posts) - - Show Bio
@Hoboseid said:
"


I think Bill wins, he doesn't job around like Thor. He is smart enough to go for the energy drain. Plus Bill is more durable than Thor if you get to blast him and get close he can soak a hell of a lot of punishment. If you get close to John he's just a man ready to go splat.

Plus Lanterns don't have many speed feats

 

 

I believe John Stewart would kill Thor though, Thor just doesn't fight smart anymore

 

but a guy like Bill with morals off would win

"
John speed is greater than Beta ray any day . There are a few scans of john speed . if
#12 Posted by Kallarkz (3295 posts) - - Show Bio
@Hoboseid said:
"


I think Bill wins, he doesn't job around like Thor. He is smart enough to go for the energy drain. Plus Bill is more durable than Thor if you get to blast him and get close he can soak a hell of a lot of punishment. If you get close to John he's just a man ready to go splat.

Plus Lanterns don't have many speed feats


"
Are you serious?

If you get close to John hes just a man ready to go splat?
I await the day you pick up your first Green Lantern comic.

Lanterns have no speed feats?
Since they change out Lanterns every time they have to go to another planet because they die of old age.
#13 Posted by isaac_clarke (5479 posts) - - Show Bio


I think John will put of a great fight compared to a lot of other Lanterns, but I'm confident Bill can get through his shielding and his constructs.

And use Stormbreaker to eat up the actually pew pew beams.

 

I think he has a good shot.

#14 Posted by Hoboseid (1019 posts) - - Show Bio
@Kallarkz said:
" @Hoboseid said:
"
If you get close to John hes just a man ready to go splat?
I await the day you pick up your first Green Lantern comic.

Lanterns have no speed feats?
Since they change out Lanterns every time they have to go to another planet because they die of old age.
"

 

Yes he GOES SPLAT

I mean imtimately close, like fist in gut, hammer in face. Lanterns by their nature are mortal human beings protected by the ring's shielding. The ring's contructions have be shattered broke, the rings barriers have been shattered broke, the rinsg shielding has been shattered broke

 

and once you get past a Lanterns defenses they are pretty mortal, they even got killed off like ninjas once Geoffcon started showing how vulnerable they can be

 

Bill and Thor can create shielding too but most of the time they don't bother blocking or shielding, that's because these hammer boys have insane durablity, they don't need to bother sheilding or blocking. They have walked on suns and taken shots from Cosmic Abstracts, blasts and hits right in to their face and battered eachother into a bloody mess and still come back for round 2

Bill has an insane damage soak

 

Lanterns don't, when you get past their shield and get close

THEY GO SPLAT

@Kallarkz said:
" @Hoboseid said:
"
Lanterns have no speed feats?
Since they change out Lanterns every time they have to go to another planet because they die of old age.
"

..
They don't have good reactions compared to say Superman and Wonder Woman or Heralds who themselves have insane reaction feats and many FTL feats

I admit over the years Lanterns have some showings that make them fast but compared to some of the other A-Listers they Lanetrns look slow

Yes I said the Lanterns are they SLOW

#15 Posted by Kallarkz (3295 posts) - - Show Bio

Speed feats and reaction times seem like 2 different things.


Yes once you get past ALL of that they are normal human beings. Not once you go up to them they go "splat". Specifics would have made that more understandable.
#16 Posted by YoungGunna (2439 posts) - - Show Bio

bump

#17 Posted by Zaiyan (461 posts) - - Show Bio

BRB wins but John would give him one hell of a fight

#18 Posted by biggkeem89 (1400 posts) - - Show Bio

Horseface Killah A.K.A. Beta Ray Bill for the win. Though, he may not have the speed of John, Bill has more than enough, strength, durability, and power to take John down. BRB has fought heralds of Galactus on even footing(Stardust and Surfer to a lesser degree). He's destroyed planets with relative ease, and had the knowledge to bring Galactus to his knees(which is a feat. He might not have had the power to fight the Big G, but he figured out how to weaken the Devourer.) Its gonna be a long tough fight, but once Bill gets past John's shielding, he'll crush John's soft, chewy center with Stormbreaker. Two of my favorite characters in a fight, but I got to go with Bill

#19 Posted by karrob (4264 posts) - - Show Bio
@YoungGunna said:
" bump "
#20 Posted by dewboy01 (1499 posts) - - Show Bio

BRB.
#21 Posted by t_swordsman (30 posts) - - Show Bio

This is quite an amazing fight but i have to give it to bill amazing fight though ..

#22 Posted by GhostRider29 (2671 posts) - - Show Bio

Wow, i love this fight. BRB would most likely win, but insane fight. i just believe in BRB better than i believe in John.
#23 Posted by ghostrider fan1 (772 posts) - - Show Bio

BRB he could technically absorb energy from the ring, but even if he cant he still wins in a long hard battle, harder than the fight with Guy for sure

#24 Posted by MutenRoshi (850 posts) - - Show Bio

Beta Ray wins this

#25 Posted by czarny_samael666 (17174 posts) - - Show Bio

BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.

#26 Posted by recordkeeper (374 posts) - - Show Bio

suprised guys actually think john could beat BRB... 
 
BRB FTW... 9/10
#27 Posted by bornstar (1319 posts) - - Show Bio

john stewart from comics but if animated beta ray bill because john no show his real powers in animated

#28 Posted by RoyalDivinity (3157 posts) - - Show Bio

People are seriously downgrading BOTH sides.
#29 Posted by PushMunky (492 posts) - - Show Bio

Make no mistake, Beta Ray Bill is a badass, & he'd give John a hell of a fight, but unless he is able to drain the ring's power, he's no match for a Green Lantern. BRB's power set is a finite one, impressive, though it may be. Stewart has anything he can imagine at his disposal. The guy destroyed a planet. Pretty sure he can take on Bill.

#30 Posted by MarvelJackAss433 (12210 posts) - - Show Bio
@bornstar said:
john stewart from comics but if animated beta ray bill because john no show his real powers in animated
Animated?Why bring up animation?That's pretty random and meaningless.
 
@PunkMastaFlex said:
People are seriously downgrading BOTH sides.

Agreed
#31 Posted by termiteone4ever (7982 posts) - - Show Bio
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
#32 Posted by czarny_samael666 (17174 posts) - - Show Bio
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him. 
BRB will BFR to other dimension.
He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
#33 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (12273 posts) - - Show Bio
@william knowles said:
BRB.
#34 Posted by termiteone4ever (7982 posts) - - Show Bio
  @czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
I can see your argument with brute force but its not enough to take john down. Lets talk about possibilities .. Both characters can drain . Green lantern powers may be limited but comics didnt set any limit on the drain either. Now this is a Fact john will is high enough to take down Beta ray and the constructs and fighting ability speed on John should be more than match to take down bill. If there is no morals John stomps. Again BFR doesnt work on green lanterns. 
#35 Posted by Kallarkz (3295 posts) - - Show Bio
@czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
In what ways is Johns energy limited? 
How or when has it been stated that BRB has unlimited Energy? 
How is BRB draining him? 
When has BRB used his hammer to teleport others to another dimension?
#36 Posted by vuviper (5531 posts) - - Show Bio
@czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
Do you happen to have a scan of BRB draining someone. Also for the dimension banishment, I'd like to see the logistics of it.
#37 Edited by venomoushatred1001 (12273 posts) - - Show Bio
@vuviper said:
@czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
Do you happen to have a scan of BRB draining someone. Also for the dimension banishment, I'd like to see the logistics of it.

I do.  BRB=<Thor: 
 
Absorbs Mags sheilds: 
 

 

Absorbs a galaxy destroying bomb:

 

Absorbs yellow sunlight energy and redirects at at vampires:

 
Drains Kang:  
 

 
Absorbs Thanos' attack and redirects it 1000x: 
 

Absorbs Glory's attack and redirects it to kill him:

#38 Posted by lantian1 (170 posts) - - Show Bio

Green lanterns have access to their battery at any time to recharge

#39 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (12273 posts) - - Show Bio
@lantian1 said:
Green lanterns have access to their battery at any time to recharge

After BRB drains him, he would probably kill/knock him unconcious before that thought would ever cross his mind.
#40 Posted by lantian1 (170 posts) - - Show Bio

Can BRB actually drain will power or any emotion?

#41 Posted by Kallarkz (3295 posts) - - Show Bio

I do not believe that Thor or BRB could actually use their hammers to drain the energy of a GL ring directly from their ring. 
Absorb their energy blasts directed at them probably but not extract the energy. 
 
Nothing in the Marvel universe can compare to a GL ring and few things in DC have been shown to drain a power ring (mostly other rings or manhunters). 

#42 Edited by venomoushatred1001 (12273 posts) - - Show Bio
@Kallarkz said:

I do not believe that Thor or BRB could actually use their hammers to drain the energy of a GL ring directly from their ring. Absorb their energy blasts directed at them probably but not extract the energy.  Nothing in the Marvel universe can compare to a GL ring and few things in DC have been shown to drain a power ring (mostly other rings or manhunters). 


Thor has drained energy that wasn't directly aim at him before: 
 

#43 Posted by velle37 (6037 posts) - - Show Bio

John Stewart
#44 Posted by IZZR (4283 posts) - - Show Bio
@velle37 said:
John Stewart
#45 Posted by Kallarkz (3295 posts) - - Show Bio
@venomoushatred1001 said:
@Kallarkz said:
I do not believe that Thor or BRB could actually use their hammers to drain the energy of a GL ring directly from their ring. Absorb their energy blasts directed at them probably but not extract the energy.  Nothing in the Marvel universe can compare to a GL ring and few things in DC have been shown to drain a power ring (mostly other rings or manhunters). 

Thor has energy that wasn't directly aim at him before: 
 

So this scan shows Thor having the ability to absorb energy from any source? 
Other beings have been shown to absorb energy from different sources in the DC Universe yet they did not show the ability to absorb the power of a GL Ring. 
 
Argue what can actually be proven As in strength, speed feats, durability. 
Thor draining a GL Ring is pure assumption.
#46 Posted by recordkeeper (374 posts) - - Show Bio
@Jake454 said:
Make no mistake, Beta Ray Bill is a badass, & he'd give John a hell of a fight, but unless he is able to drain the ring's power, he's no match for a Green Lantern 
 
 
 
LMAO, suuuurrrrrreeeeee.... 
Draining not even needed, John is simple overmatched here

#47 Posted by venomoushatred1001 (12273 posts) - - Show Bio
@IZZR said:
@velle37 said:
John Stewart

@velle37 said:
John Stewart


How?
#48 Posted by czarny_samael666 (17174 posts) - - Show Bio
@Kallarkz said:
@czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
In what ways is Johns energy limited? How or when has it been stated that BRB has unlimited Energy? How is BRB draining him? When has BRB used his hammer to teleport others to another dimension?
1.He can use his hammer in the same ways Thor can. And he used that power in Annihilators to open portal to Limbo.
2.BRB depends on magic. No one ever drained energy from his hammer, because it uses magic. You would have to unable it to use magic.
3.Rings are limited. Only Kyle's isn't IIRC.
 
@termiteone4ever said:
  @czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
I can see your argument with brute force but its not enough to take john down. Lets talk about possibilities .. Both characters can drain . Green lantern powers may be limited but comics didnt set any limit on the drain either. Now this is a Fact john will is high enough to take down Beta ray and the constructs and fighting ability speed on John should be more than match to take down bill. If there is no morals John stomps. Again BFR doesnt work on green lanterns. 

1.This is not a fact that John could take BRB. It is exaclty opposite. Without morals BRB stomps.
2.Did John ever used his ring to make portals to other dimensions?
3.Both can drain, but John's energy is limited, ergo BRB can drain him.
 
@vuviper said:
@czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
Do you happen to have a scan of BRB draining someone. Also for the dimension banishment, I'd like to see the logistics of it.

Thor used it in few ways. One is just opening portals, second is beam from his hammer that do this, thrid is making something close (in way of appearing ) to black hole, which can suck all people that Thor doesn't want on the field. The last was used in his fight with Durok, the sceond against Loki, first many times, ones against Mangog.
#49 Posted by dccomicsrule2011 (26848 posts) - - Show Bio
@czarny_samael said:
@Kallarkz said:
@czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
In what ways is Johns energy limited? How or when has it been stated that BRB has unlimited Energy? How is BRB draining him? When has BRB used his hammer to teleport others to another dimension?
1.He can use his hammer in the same ways Thor can. And he used that power in Annihilators to open portal to Limbo.
2.BRB depends on magic. No one ever drained energy from his hammer, because it uses magic. You would have to unable it to use magic.
3.Rings are limited. Only Kyle's isn't IIRC.
 
@termiteone4ever said:
  @czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
I can see your argument with brute force but its not enough to take john down. Lets talk about possibilities .. Both characters can drain . Green lantern powers may be limited but comics didnt set any limit on the drain either. Now this is a Fact john will is high enough to take down Beta ray and the constructs and fighting ability speed on John should be more than match to take down bill. If there is no morals John stomps. Again BFR doesnt work on green lanterns. 

1.This is not a fact that John could take BRB. It is exaclty opposite. Without morals BRB stomps.
2.Did John ever used his ring to make portals to other dimensions?
3.Both can drain, but John's energy is limited, ergo BRB can drain him.
 
@vuviper said:
@czarny_samael said:
@termiteone4ever said:
@czarny_samael said:
BRB in normal fight. With drainning it is a stomp. The same with BFR.
Where do you get this Drain possibility when the green lanterns are capable of the same .He is not beating John. HOw are you going to BFR a green lantern who can Go almost anywhere.I am not seen that happening . John isnt going to lose to Beta
John's energy is limitted - BRB's isn't. BRB will drain him.  BRB will BFR to other dimension. He is beating him. In normal brute fight, BRB wins.
Do you happen to have a scan of BRB draining someone. Also for the dimension banishment, I'd like to see the logistics of it.
Thor used it in few ways. One is just opening portals, second is beam from his hammer that do this, thrid is making something close (in way of appearing ) to black hole, which can suck all people that Thor doesn't want on the field. The last was used in his fight with Durok, the sceond against Loki, first many times, ones against Mangog.
Draining is just a assumption Ca who is a way better drainer then BRB or Thor could not do it then they cant either.
Online
#50 Posted by Kallarkz (3295 posts) - - Show Bio

Seeing how even powerful energy absorbers have not been seen to absorb a Green Lanterns ring energy from its ring and how Thor has not stated or been seen to drain energy from any source I do not believe that Thor or BRB can simply drain a Green Lantern ring. 
"Thor drains him" appears to be becoming as common as "Iceman freezes him" even though there has been no evidence to display that Iceman could do this to a being with heightened durability (though what he can do does not apply to this thread). 
 
Lets compare durability, strength and speed feats that are fact. Assumptions never help.