The only way she wins is if he is unarmed and she has her Hanzo sword. While I do believe her to be his superior in cqc, the surface area of an indestructible shield is too big an advantage, combined with his superior stats, he wins.
The people have spoken! Steve's physicals and shield are just too much for Beatrix. A high quality sword means nothing to a shield that tanks blows from Mjolnir. I think if you took away the shield, it would be closer, but Steve would probably still win.
some people actually think a human who isn't even at peak level can go toe to toe with a super soldier?! Did they not watch the winter soldier or the avengers? Cap's shield can't be broken by the hanzo sword. Even if you took away caps shield he's still be too much. Beatrix wasn't that good of a h2h combatant especially compared to Steve. He is at best a low level super human.
Log in to comment