Battle Royale

Rules

• There are 5 teams, all placed in an area (specified later) where they will fight to the death.
• They have no knowledge of who they are going to be fighting.
• They will have no preparation time, other than meeting their team mates if they haven't met.
• All media is canon (unless specified otherwise).
• Standard equipment for all, no more than one weapon.
• Start 1km apart.
• Each character gets a horse (unless specified otherwise).
• They will be fighting here:

Teams

TEAM 1 = The Fellowship of the Ring, at the beginning of the first film. (Aragorn, Legolas,Gimli,Merry,Pippin,Sam,Frodo,Gandalf the Grey,Boromir).

TEAM 2 = Nazgul.

TEAM 3 = Elendil, Isildur, Gil-Galad,Elrond.

+

TEAM 4 = Cave Troll and Mountain Troll.

+

TEAM 5 = Lurtz and 20 Uruk hai.

+

Hope you like :)

@ChaosBlazer: TBH i just searched 20 uruk hai and this pic came up ;)

Why team 1?

Team 2 or 4 stomp.

@Trinity00 said:

Team 2 or 4 stomp.

That doesn't make sense.

@ChaosBlazer:

What doo you see the Hobbits adding?

Any weapon that touches the Nazgul breaks, and the wielder is poisoned.

Elf and Elendil and Isildur are prolly > Aragorn Legolas Gimli and Boromir

One cave troll gave the fellowship a lot of trouble and nearly killed Frodo and so 2 trolls will wreak them, fortunately all the groups can run away lol.

Unlikely that all the teams will have full contingent after first encounters..

@The_Thunderer said:

@Trinity00 said:

Team 2 or 4 stomp.

That doesn't make sense.

@ChaosBlazer:

What doo you see the Hobbits adding?

Any weapon that touches the Nazgul breaks, and the wielder is poisoned.

Elf and Elendil and Isildur are prolly > Aragorn Legolas Gimli and Boromir

One cave troll gave the fellowship a lot of trouble and nearly killed Frodo and so 2 trolls will wreak them, fortunately all the groups can run away lol.

Unlikely that all the teams will have full contingent after first encounters..

The Nazguls are overall the most powerful out of everybody not to mention one stab can incapacitate anybody in this match

The trolls are the deadliest here because of their durability, and they have room to swing the cave troll lost because he did not have a lot of room to move around and the fellow ship could hide and take cover, with no cover the troll runs towards them and smashes them into little bits, while the mountain troll p0wnts the rest.

@Trinity00:

No cover, except all the trees..also run away? easy?

Massive lake = bad for nazguls..

@ChaosBlazer:

That is assuming they find each other in the correct order...

lets say for arguments sake the first encounters are

(i)Trolls VS Elves and Numenoreans VS Nazgul

(ii)Uruks VS Fellowship

then winners (i) VS winners (ii)

@The_Thunderer said:

@Trinity00:

No cover, except all the trees..also run away? easy?

Massive lake = bad for nazguls..

@ChaosBlazer:

That is assuming they find each other in the correct order...

lets say for arguments sake the first encounters are

(i)Trolls VS Elves and Numenoreans VS Nazgul

(ii)Uruks VS Fellowship

then winners (i) VS winners (ii)

The tree's won't provide adequate cover.

and it's not like the nazgul spawn in the lake.

@Trinity00: how will they not?

And have you not seen what Gandalf did to them in Rivendell?

@The_Thunderer said:

@Trinity00: how will they not?

And have you not seen what Gandalf did to them in Rivendell?

Because the tree is narrow not wide the troll can simply stray to the left and smash the beings hiding behind it

PIS or lots of luck.

@IKnowEverything: why?

@VercingetorixTheGreat: In this situation they are gonna get along. Only to the extent he used as gandalf the grey.

@ChaosBlazer: I disagree, these elves and numeroeans are tough. (numenoreans=Elendil and Isildur) plus fellowship will get injured badly. Nazguls horses get trashed by trolls, that disadvantage could be significant.

@IKnowEverything: why?

@ChaosBlazer: Not if they dismount to engage trolls.

If fellowship come across elves/numes they will lose...if I was Gandalf i wold go the water, and then nazgul can't do jack..also gandalf has fire manipulation which will be super helpful.

@ChaosBlazer: I think elves/numen have best chance of winning, cos they are strong against all teams.

Well, let's take a look at the strongest members of the first three teams. Teams 4 and 5 are irrelevant when compared to them.  
 
Gil-galad - king of the Noldor, incredibly powerful elf warrior who went toe-to-toe with Sauron (if only for a few moments before he was incinerated). 
The Witch-King - most powerful of the Nazgul, immortal (despite a curiously convenient loophole), and a match for Gandalf the White (ignoring the uncut footage in the movie, in the books Gandalf the White stalled him at the gates of Minas Tirith). 
Gandalf the Grey - powerful wizard on-par with Durin's Bane while still considered "Grey."  
 
At the end of the day, the Witch-King is the only one who could logically outlast every other participant in this battle (with the very possible exception of Frodo once he puts on the One Ring, but that would just be a bad idea in of itself). We have not seen much from Gil-galad, so we can only assume he was extremely powerful and influential by the time of the Siege of Barad-dur. Though not exactly Maiar-level because of how easily Sauron stomped him, Gil-galad is still a warrior of renown and (because of his heritage as the King of the Noldor) would more likely than not have a few magic aces in his favor.
 
Still, the Witch-King has the best chance of winning here as do the Nazgul. If Gandalf was just a little paler, then this would swing in the Fellowship's direction drastically.  

I say the Fellowship take this one.

@Trinity00 said:

@The_Thunderer said:

@Trinity00 said:

Team 2 or 4 stomp.

That doesn't make sense.

@ChaosBlazer:

What doo you see the Hobbits adding?

Any weapon that touches the Nazgul breaks, and the wielder is poisoned.

Elf and Elendil and Isildur are prolly > Aragorn Legolas Gimli and Boromir

One cave troll gave the fellowship a lot of trouble and nearly killed Frodo and so 2 trolls will wreak them, fortunately all the groups can run away lol.

Unlikely that all the teams will have full contingent after first encounters..

The Nazguls are overall the most powerful out of everybody not to mention one stab can incapacitate anybody in this match

The trolls are the deadliest here because of their durability, and they have room to swing the cave troll lost because he did not have a lot of room to move around and the fellow ship could hide and take cover, with no cover the troll runs towards them and smashes them into little bits, while the mountain troll p0wnts the rest.

Aragon has defeated all of them in the Fellowship of the Ring with only a torch and a sword....

Wouldn't team two be too powerful?

@big_blue_cheese: Gandalf is noot a man he is a maiar

@GhostRider29: not really... why?

@ShootingNova: They aren't big fans of fire or water, both of which Gandalf has here.

@Kaligar Roxom: Gil-Galad is gonna have feats of classic elves from Gondolin i.e. slaying Gothmog greatest Balrog ever..so he is pretty damn awesome, plus Elrond and 2 Numenoreans they are formidable.

@GhostRider29 said:

Wouldn't team two be too powerful?

Gandalf's light is a lot weaker as Grey, but still sufficient to drive the Ringwraiths away, plus his use of fire and water.

@ShootingNova: Plus Aragorn drove them off...

No one think Legolas is influential?

@The_Thunderer said:

@ShootingNova: Plus Aragorn drove them off...

No one think Legolas is influential?

His arrows might puncture weak points, again putting the troll to sleep might help, as in the end of Return of the King, Aragon almost got killed by a troll, although he had been fighting for quite a lot prior to that.

@ShootingNova: IMO he could take all 20 uruks and some of the Elves..

@The_Thunderer said:

@ShootingNova: IMO he could take all 20 uruks and some of the Elves..

Aragon, Gimli, Legolas and Gandalf all owned the Uruk-Hai during the battle of Helm's Deep, and now there's only twenty... Gandalf and Gimli take the Uruks, Legolas and Aragon mop Lurtz, who was already defeated by Aragon alone despite the latter having already fought quite a bit before.

@202122: haha maybe, you reckon PIS ?

@202122: Who is going to use magical attacks on them?

Thread closes in 6 hours when I reveal winner and why they ought to win 9/10 or 10/10

so good luck :)

@202122: @ShootingNova: @GhostRider29: @big_blue_cheese: @Kaligar Roxom:

@The_Thunderer: What do you mean by "tonight"? It's already 9:09 pm in my place and I'm about to go to bed...

@202122: WHEN HAVE THEY DONE THAT IN BATTLE?

@big_blue_cheese said:

It comes down to Gandalf and Witch King, I'm just curious to know if Gandalf falls under the race of man. If he does then Witch king takes it otherwise it comes down to the wire. It's almost 50/50 between Nazgul and fellowship.

The only thing is... Gandalf can use Fire/Water/Light to drive them away, and Aragon can beat them in a duel of swordsmanship, although he did sort of need the torch.... but Gandalf can provide light/fire/water for him...

@ShootingNova: he can provide unquenchable fire

@The_Thunderer said:

@ShootingNova: he can provide unquenchable fire

And he created a thunderbolt so powerful it killed surrounding Goblins.

@Trinity00 said:

@The_Thunderer said:

@Trinity00 said:

Team 2 or 4 stomp.

That doesn't make sense.

@ChaosBlazer:

What doo you see the Hobbits adding?

Any weapon that touches the Nazgul breaks, and the wielder is poisoned.

Elf and Elendil and Isildur are prolly > Aragorn Legolas Gimli and Boromir

One cave troll gave the fellowship a lot of trouble and nearly killed Frodo and so 2 trolls will wreak them, fortunately all the groups can run away lol.

Unlikely that all the teams will have full contingent after first encounters..

The Nazguls are overall the most powerful out of everybody not to mention one stab can incapacitate anybody in this match

The trolls are the deadliest here because of their durability, and they have room to swing the cave troll lost because he did not have a lot of room to move around and the fellow ship could hide and take cover, with no cover the troll runs towards them and smashes them into little bits, while the mountain troll p0wnts the rest.

To be serious.... Gandalf summons thunderbolt, creates fire/water/light + Aragon swinging and dancing with his sword = sliced up Nazgul.

Trolls can get blinded easily and are vulnerable in the daylight, like in the Hobbit, Gandalf can just trick them into staying up until morning and they get frozen lol.

@ShootingNova: Forest will prolly be too dark for that

@The_Thunderer said:

@ShootingNova: Forest will prolly be too dark for that

Gandalf could set it alight... Wrath of Anor/Flame of Udun.

@ShootingNova: @The_Thunderer: I just thought that they were really powerful. Like everyone feared them.

And I vote team one.

@GhostRider29 said:

@ShootingNova: @The_Thunderer: I just thought that they were really powerful. Like everyone feared them.

And I vote team one.

The Nazgul? Aragon didn't, he drove them all off, a similar feat was replicated by Gandalf some time later.

FELLOWSHIP WIN BECAUSE FRODO CAN JUST GIVE ONE RING TO GANDALF. GANDALF THEN HAS 2 RINGS AND STOMPED THE SH!T OUTTA ALL THE OTHERS.

@The_Thunderer said:

FELLOWSHIP WIN BECAUSE FRODO CAN JUST GIVE ONE RING TO GANDALF. GANDALF THEN HAS 2 RINGS AND STOMPED THE SH!T OUTTA ALL THE OTHERS.

Seriously? LOL