#1 Posted by WillPayton (9821 posts) - - Show Bio

Alan Scott vs Cyborg Superman vs Despero vs Fernus vs Silver Surfer

They each fight each other separately in a pool. Rate them in order of who wins the most battles, #1 (most wins) to #5 last place. You can say who wins each battle in the pool, or just rate them.

Conditions: In character, pre-52 for DCs, random encounter, no knowledge. Battle starting on the surface of an alternate reality, deserted Earth, starting 100m apart. Even though in character, each believes the others are evil and must absolutely be defeated. Wins by KO, death, or permanent incapacitation. No BFR.

Go!

#2 Posted by New_World_Order (13516 posts) - - Show Bio

I wouldn't say their Sub-Sky Fathers. Well a full power Alan Scott is above this level.

Morals On-Fernus>Cyborg Superman>Despero>Silver Surfer>Alan Scott

Morals Off (Full Power)-Alan Scott>Fernus>Silver Surfer>Cyborg Superman>Despero

#3 Posted by WillPayton (9821 posts) - - Show Bio

I wouldn't say their Sub-Sky Fathers. Well a full power Alan Scott is above this level.

Morals On-Fernus>Cyborg Superman>Despero>Silver Surfer>Alan Scott

Morals Off (Full Power)-Alan Scott>Fernus>Silver Surfer>Cyborg Superman>Despero

Lets keep it at morals-on, because as you note, without morals Alan becomes a near universal level power. Also, it's rare that we see actual morals-off versions of these characters in comics. Even if they're extremely pissed, usually they're still within their morals range.

#4 Edited by Hyperlight (6580 posts) - - Show Bio

fernus..... despero... silver surfer.... cyborg superman... alan scott

#5 Edited by joeagentofhand1 (4362 posts) - - Show Bio

A morals on Alan has done some crazy things like fight Mordru and fight Parallax Hal Jordan, so I believe it would be:

Fernus, Despero, Alan Scott and Silver surfer(they are about equal), Hank Henshaw

#6 Posted by New_World_Order (13516 posts) - - Show Bio

@thundergodswrath said:

I wouldn't say their Sub-Sky Fathers. Well a full power Alan Scott is above this level.

Morals On-Fernus>Cyborg Superman>Despero>Silver Surfer>Alan Scott

Morals Off (Full Power)-Alan Scott>Fernus>Silver Surfer>Cyborg Superman>Despero

Lets keep it at morals-on, because as you note, without morals Alan becomes a near universal level power. Also, it's rare that we see actual morals-off versions of these characters in comics. Even if they're extremely pissed, usually they're still within their morals range.

Agreed.

#7 Posted by Killemall (18607 posts) - - Show Bio

1. Fernus

2. Despero

3. Silver Surfer (although given defenders vol 4, one can make a case for him being second , that was just totally fresh and well outright awe inspiring power showing from Surfer)

4. Cyborg

5. Alan Scott

(morals off Alan Scott eats everyone for breakfast )

#8 Posted by WillPayton (9821 posts) - - Show Bio

bump

#9 Edited by Wyldsong (5898 posts) - - Show Bio

#

#

1. Fernus

2. Despero

3. Silver Surfer (although given defenders vol 4, one can make a case for him being second , that was just totally fresh and well outright awe inspiring power showing from Surfer)

4. Cyborg

5. Alan Scott

(morals off Alan Scott eats everyone for breakfast )

The fanboy in me wants to put SS as #1, but the realistic part of me basically agrees with this breakdown.