This is a concept I've been hoping will pick up. I didn't put this in the battle threads since it's more focused on the concept than the battle.
Two evenly matched characters, and the winner is based on pure facts. I've worked on a example to see how well people think it works. This is, of course, an example and doesn't mean it is all completely accurate.
Batarang/Smoke Bomb vs. Shield
Edge-Shield. While the Batarang is effective, the shield is much more versatile. Not only does it act as a offensive and defensive tool, but it can block the batarangs and barely get a scratch. The smoke bomb is good for creating cover or getting out of a sticky situation, but that’s about it.
Cowl Vision vs. Super Serum:
Edge-Cowl Vision. Surprising, huh? While the Super Serum does give Cap an advantage, it’s not much of one. Batman has trained constantly to reach his physical and mental maximum. What this also means is that Batman is more use to fighting with his human limitation. While Captain America is a very skilled fighter, Batman has the edge of learning the abilities, and not be given them suddenly. The Cowl Vision might not play the biggest role in the fight, but it will do more help than the serum.
Edge-Batman. Batman has trained in 127 major martial arts. Captain America has mastered a few of his own, and fights with his own mixture of Jujitsu, Boxing, Judo, pressure points. But Batman has him beat, also mastering Karate, Jujitsu, Kung fu, Muay Thai, Aikido, Ninjutsu, and Kobudo.
Ok, so a few questions. Does this method work? Would it work if professionals created it?
Also, do you agree or disagree with my assessment?