Arrow vs Winchester Brothers

I've been having a very interesting discussion about this battle but an acquaintance of mine seems to be dead sure that the winchesters would beat arrow.

Random encounter

Battle takes place in starling city,

Arrow is bloodlusted

The winchesters are on no morals

Who wins?

Cool match.

Home town + blood lust = Ollie puts an Arrow in their chests.

@hudyman: Sam has an angel inside, i don't think the angel would let him die.And if he comes out he would kill Ollie with a snap of his fingers.Without the angel Ollie wins.

@ghostrider2: I meant who would win in a fight, ( not to the death ) just badly beaten and plus the angel can't interfer

Yeah. Ollie stomps. Mismatch.

I strongly doubt the brothers would loose, they have stopped the apocalypse and saved the world dozens of times and faced waaay more tougher enemies than Ollie , and they're in no morals. I don't see this going well for Arrow

@hudyman: what do you mean by random encounter like they are walking down an alleyway and a fight ensues if so winchesters take this.

Oliver beats the crap out of them....but that Winchester backstap is OP.....hmmmmm

@thewinchester: @ownagepants: @buttersdaman000: @sophia89:

For imagery, they are walking down an alley and bump into arrow, they then break out into a fight.

The winchesters have NO supernatural advantage, absolutely none, sam doesnt have any angels in him, just a plain human fight.

@sophia89: Could you show me a video or scan that confirms what you're saying, i've tried looking them up myself but they are all pathetic compared to arrow's skills

1. Deadshot is by far a better shooter than the brothers yet his gun skills didnt help against arrow

Almost every enemy oliver fights in the show has been an expert combatant when they were younger yet somehow it didnt help them against himself

2. Are you really using that as a feat?, hmm i wonder how the people in the asylum felt when they charged at oliver, Or the time when he was bound and interrogated by armed men, the list goes on and on.

3. Really, i think there must be some element of PIS in those cases, your telling me normal humans are able to fight supernatural beings who have super strength and easily beat them?. If that is the case theres no reason why arrow can't do the same.

4. Haha that is very much true, however i have enough faith in arrow's abilities so much that i think he could possibly take out the brothers seeing as he is bloodlusted.

5. Remember this is a complete random encounter, they had no clue they would run into each other, arrow was going in search of someone who killed his entire family but somehow bumps into the brothers and decides to kill them.

The brothers were on their way to find a supernatural being.

Standard items

Do the Winchesters have the Colt? That's a game-decider, here. Arrow is good, but he can't dodge bullets, and the Colt is insta-kill, so one little hit is all they need. If the Winchesters had a normal gun they might get a hit in on Arrow, but i doubt that would stop him. They're not exactly crack-shots, and Arrow is far from weak.

Without the Colt, though, or any other magical weapon/interference, the brothers lose pretty badly, as Arrow's fighting skills and physicality are way above both Sam and Dean's.

@silverrings: They have their standard items but no magical or advantage weapons, im trying to make this fair.

@hudyman said:

So they would have guns, which does make this more even, but Arrow has avoided being shot and taken out armed men before, so this really shouldn't be too hard for him to win.

@sophia89: It doesn't matter if there are 2 of them. They've got guns and Ollie has evaded multiple machine guns being fired at him simultaneously. Their weapons are slow. He never had trouble taking out multiple opponents before. And Dean and Sam has no feats in h2h whatsoever. Yes, they've been trained from childhood but that doesn't make you a good fighter. Especially if the teacher himself has no h2h feats. Arrow should take this in a stomp.

Prep: The brothers win.

Random encounter: Ollie wins.

If Ollie starts to strangle one with his back to the other then the brothers take it otherwise he wins.