ARROW v. Nolan's Batman

Conditions

- Nolan has been watching some Arrow and immediately expressed disdain for Arrow, contemplating that his Batman is the better of the duo in combat. With his almighty omnipotent powers, he orchestrated a fight between these two to occur by manipulating strings of events that lead up to it.

- Batman possesses knowledge on Arrow based on what has been seen in his show when he's out in combat, Arrow possesses knowledge on Batman based on what was seen in Nolan's trilogy when Batman fought against the criminal scum with only intelligence on Batman's gadgets to be batarangs and grapple gun.

- Morals on/in character.

- Arrow has a total of fifteen regular arrows here and one grapple arrow that he uses to move down from buildings, Batman is in possession of ten batarangs, grapple gun, two spiny mini bombs (Batman Begins, used them to break through prison walls), shoe camouflaged bat homing beacon (Batman Begins), and his EMP gun he used in TDKR.

Setting

An abandoned building at the stroke of midnight that appears to be like this:

Arrow starts by walking through the door located on the right of the picture, Batman is located at where the blue monster octopus painting is which is near the middle of the picture, adhere the burgundy coloured pillar/pipe. This entire structure is lighted with a total of four 5 feet by 5 feet ambient lights that hang all over the ceiling.

Who wins?

@Killemall said:

Arrow has been pretty solid thus far, although his fight with Lawton was very very ordinary to say the least. He has some crazy speed, accuracy feat and looks actually better than his comicbook counter version (at least new 52, not so familiar with pre flashpoint version).

While he doesnt have a prolonged combat feat to speak of yet, to be he's looked more agile, faster, and more rutheless than Batman .

I agree. Batman does however possesses superior strength, better technology, and is better suited to fight in this setting. Do you believe it's a fair fight?

@Killemall said:

@PunkMastaFlex: I think its a fair fight, and Nolan's Batman being the more popular thing atm, would likely get more votes.

If this thread would get any votes or debaters that is. :( Should have just made an "Arrow v. Batman, T.v series v. movie version who wins" instead of an in depth, thought out fight.

Oliver takes this but with some hard work.

He acts like an animal which gives him the advantage against ordinary humans.

Also arrow is on tonight apparently an "Iconic" DC character is making an appearance.

Bump.

I'd be obliged to state that Ollie is the smarter of the two and in fact, far more resourceful due to his survival on the island. He seems to be just as proficient at fighting in the darkness than Bruce is as well as being just as stealthy. His accuracy seems to supersede that of even his comic counterpart as does his combat efficiency in close quarters. Considering the locale and the distance, I'd say Bruce has enough cover to avoid some shots off the bat (heh, no pun intended) but Ollie is just as, if not quicker on his feet than Bruce is and the same goes for the skill in hand-to-hand. The accuracy and long range weaponry garner him the advantage overall as he can easily keep a distance between the two of them.

Fantastic set-up though!

@Deranged Midget said:

I'd be obliged to state that Ollie is the smarter of the two and in fact, far more resourceful due to his survival on the island. He seems to be just as proficient at fighting in the darkness than Bruce is as well as being just as stealthy. His accuracy seems to supersede that of even his comic counterpart as does his combat efficiency in close quarters. Considering the locale and the distance, I'd say Bruce has enough cover to avoid some shots off the bat (heh, no pun intended) but Ollie is just as, if not quicker on his feet than Bruce is and the same goes for the skill in hand-to-hand. The accuracy and long range weaponry garner him the advantage overall as he can easily keep a distance between the two of them.

Fantastic set-up though!

Thanks mate. ^^

@PunkMastaFlex: Not a problem! I better be seeing some more of these fantastic battles coming from you mate! ;)

Ollie. At least as skilled or more so, faster (both in terms of how fast he can hit as well has his reflexes) and he'd have no qualms putting an arrow in Bruce's eye. As of the end of TDKR, Ollie most likely has the better physical stats as well.

Strength: Batman; Batman's proved in my mind to pack more 'umph' behind his punches.

Speed: Ollie; He's dodged arrows after they were fired from about thirty feet away, machine gun fire etc.

Durability: Even; Both of them have shown to take inhuman amounts of punishment, I might give a slight edge to Ollie, even with less armor he can take a beating.

Accuracy: Ollie: Ollie's made so pretty remarkable shots in Arrow, he's almost inhumanly accurate enough so that he'd probablly be able to put an arrow through Bruce's mouth or eye.

Fighting skill: Ollie shown top tier martial art skill; he'd be more willing to fight dirty, his looser morals allow him to use techniques Bruce would be unwilling to employ.

Winner: Ollie

It wouldn't be a clean or easy fight but at the end of the day I think Ollie would win about seven out of ten fights.