I think I'm going to play Devil's Advocate and root for team Arrow.
To start off, Bane is a massive weak link. He was moderately skilled in Arkham Origins, but still possessed no modicum of speed to speak of. Given Oliver's outstanding level of speed and precision with his arrows, taking Bane out of the fight almost as soon as it starts should be simple, and without any decent durability feats for Bane, there's no reason to think an arrow to the heart wouldn't work. On top of that, Mirakuru outclasses both venom and titan by a significant margin, so if worst comes to worst Slade could probably take Bane in CQC and impale him with minimal difficulty. I don't think I'm stretching when I say Bane will be next to useless in this fight, everyone in the Arkham-verse besides Batman and Joker were jobbers, Bane shouldn't pose any threat, so it will soon become a 2-on-1.
Now I'm the first guy to root for Arkham Batman in a battle thread, but in my opinion, as a fan of both franchises, Arrow on his own would give Batman a difficult enough fight. The two are very comparable, Arkham Batman is known for taking down rooms full of thugs in quick succession with the freeflow combat system, but Arrow was able to match any of those instances throughout the trilogy when he saved Walter at the end of season 1 and took down a whole warehouse of opponents by himself without getting touched.
Just in terms of sheer numbers, this scene is the equivalent of any combat section from the Arkham games, challenge maps aside. Bottom line is they both mow through cannon fodder like nothing, as expected of any decent street leveler worth his salt. Batman's fight against Deathstroke was impressive, but Deathstroke is pretty much featless in the Arkham verse, if you ask me Oliver's fights against Merlyn are just as flashy, the only difference is that Merlyn has the feats to back himself up as a dangerous combatant. Taking on two Titan goons in Arkham Asylum was very impressive, but after a pep talk from Tommy, Oliver was able to defeat Solomon Grundy with only mid-difficulty at best, handle Roy like he was nothing, and fight on even ground with an unnamed Mirakuru soldier freshly after breaking his knee, and Mirakuru guys are far superior to Titan guys.
In terms of skillful, noteworthy opponents both characters have faced, Arrow has the advantage hands down. Bronze Tiger, Nyssa Al Ghul, Mr. Blank, Malcolm Merlyn, Al-Owal, China White, Slade Wilson, all skilled characters with feats and showings of their own. Ra's al Ghul, Deathstroke, Bane, and Shiva on the other hand, no feats besides fighting Batman and looking cool.
And let's not forget about the Arrow's namesake amidst all this H2H goodness. His archery feats range from impressive to insane, Arkham Batman has always had a distinct lack of reflex showings, so there's no reason to believe Oliver couldn't put one through him sooner or later, as he's managed to tag considerably faster characters (Tiger, Slade, not to mention he beat Deadshot in a gunfight). Batman has his gadgets to even things out, but Oliver's trick arrows can match Bruce's versatility, and Oliver is much more skillful when it comes to the use of his gear.
The best part is I haven't even mentioned Deathstroke yet. If I'm being honest, I would definitely give Batman an edge over Arrow at the end of the day. Mirakuru Deathstroke on the other hand would undoubtedly defeat Batman. Arkham Deathstroke doesn't come close to comparing in terms of strength, reflexes, intelligence, skill, regeneration, just about anything really.
Log in to comment