no prep
morals on
abondonned city
random encounter
who'd win?
All Star Superman vs Christoper Reeves Superman
Edited By deactivated-60d8e8271946e
Disagree.
Reeves was based off the SA Superman.
He moved the moon easily and reversed time.Fought 3 kryptonians, a Superman clone, etc
I heard it took, Supergirl, Powergirl, Superman etc to all move the Moon
what time? superman alone while blue superman did it and while he was blue superman he commented he was more powerful as normal superman implying he could of done it easier, than the fact if superman, wonderwoman, and martain manhunter can move the earth than individually all 3 of them should be capable of moon moving on there own
"@comicdude23: what time? superman alone while blue superman did it and while he was blue superman he commented he was more powerful as normal superman implying he could of done it easier, than the fact if superman, wonderwoman, and martain manhunter can move the earth than individually all 3 of them should be capable of moon moving on there own "
I know they should be able to move the Moon since they moved the Earth.
I think it was in a Titans issue a few years ago, a bit less, they couldn't move the Moon.
Reeves easily did. He can also duplicate.
" @Valtot: Disagree. Reeves was based off the SA Superman. He moved the moon easily and reversed time.Fought 3 kryptonians, a Superman clone, etc I heard it took, Supergirl, Powergirl, Superman etc to all move the Moon "
reeves could gain new powers on plot devices lol SA power...
but anyway in all star superman a much weaker kryptonian put a crack threw the moon by smashing all star superman into it who was weakened at the time than threw him into the earth and all star superman only got a nose bleed? he was extremely weakned at the time and could take that much punishment, now if he wasnt weakened that wouldnt of even effected him and inmagine what the all star superman would be capable of considering what the weaker kryptonian was,
"@comicdude23: reeves could gain new powers on plot devices lol SA power... but anyway in all star superman a much weaker kryptonian put a crack threw the moon by smashing all star superman into it who was weakened at the time than threw him into the earth and all star superman only got a nose bleed? he was extremely weakned at the time and could take that much punishment, now if he wasnt weakened that wouldnt of even effected him and inmagine what the all star superman would be capable of considering what the weaker kryptonian was, "
Reeves was a plot device
There's a difference between cracking the Moon and physically moving it
yes there is cracking is a chain effect of a hard punch while moving it as moving the entire weight. BUt yes im just guessing at all star supermans power as considering he was atleast 3X more powerful than the kryptonian who did that all star superman should be capable of 1 shotting the moon with a punch and moving it
"@comicdude23: yes there is cracking is a chain effect of a hard punch while moving it as moving the entire weight. BUt yes im just guessing at all star supermans power as considering he was atleast 3X more powerful than the kryptonian who did that all star superman should be capable of 1 shotting the moon with a punch and moving it "
AS Superman can't move the Moon.
"@comicdude23: y did he show he was to weak too move it? if you take how powerful weaker kryptonians are and hes post to be many times more powerful its not a stretch to think he cant "
he was struggling to move 200 Quintillion tons. That was 1/30 of Earth
and he struggled
he was holding it up for a while as they had to test him doing it than tell him the results than he pushed it up even higher and broke the machine and seemed to struggle a tiny bit, but that was with a single hand??? it atleast double that than triple it for his limit, 200/ 400/ 1200 quintillion tons. how much is 1200 quintillion tons?
SA Superman>AS Superman> Movie Superman... Movie Superman is supposed to equal SA Superman, thats a lie. SA Superman is the real man of steel.
"SA Superman>AS Superman> Movie Superman... Movie Superman is supposed to equal SA Superman, thats a lie. SA Superman is the real man of steel. "
AS Superman is weaker than Current Superman
SA Superman>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>AS Superman
"@comicdude23: he was holding it up for a while as they had to test him doing it than tell him the results than he pushed it up even higher and broke the machine and seemed to struggle a tiny bit, but that was with a single hand??? it atleast double that than triple it for his limit, 200/ 400/ 1200 quintillion tons. how much is 1200 quintillion tons? "
No. He had a strain in his neck in the first pannel. And in the second pannel he couldn't talk properly.
He was already tripled when he was pushing on it.
"@comicdude23: its not that big of a gap there actually pretty close with all star superman being more powerful than most weaker versions of superman but the stronger versions are more powerful "
I can name plenty of Supermen who are more powerful than AS Superman.
AS Superman is a good book. I loved it. But his power levels are overrated.
KC Superman
SA Superman
Earth 2 Superman
Current Superman
Red Son Superman
SBP or Superman Prime
Christopher Reeves Superman
Kal Kent
etc....
they can all beat AS Superman
i ment by how superman is written? sometimes hes weak as hell than hes a near planet mover..
he displayed feats better than KC superman, earth 2 superman, red son superman
this isnt comparing KC superman to current superman AS superman is totally difffernt and has alot better feats than any of them (his strength is vastly higher than beings who were capable of easily cracking the moon))
"@comicdude23: no he was straining a tiny bit from holding it up than he had a small problem talking when he broke the machine by pushing it against its limits, that wasnt anywhere near his limits and with 1 hand?>< "
No. He couldn't talk properly. First pannel he has a strain, second pannel he can't speak properly
"@comicdude23: i ment by how superman is written? sometimes hes weak as hell than hes a near planet mover.. he displayed feats better than KC superman, earth 2 superman, red son superman this isnt comparing KC superman to current superman AS superman is totally difffernt and has alot better feats than any of them (his strength is vastly higher than beings who were capable of easily cracking the moon)) "
No.
KC Superman>>>>>>Curent Superman>>>>>>>AS Superman.
"@comicdude23: KC superman doesnt have any feats above AS superman name 1 that goes with something AS superman did that he showed he was superour at "
Took a punch from Herc didn't even flinch.
Current Superman>>>>>>AS Superman
KC Superman>>>>>>>Current Superman
KC Superman>>>>Current Superman>>>>AS Superman
"@comicdude23: your still just going current superman >>> AS superman- when that superman was portrayed pretty weak so how is that a feat? im still not hearing any feats putting KC superman above all star superman only ABC logic with someoen who has nothing to do with him "
What?
Current Superman helped move the Earth. That's above anything AS Superman has done.
And KC Superman proved to be more powerful than Current Superman.
the superman he showed himself stronger than wasnt anywhere near a planet mover he was portrayed really weak he couldnt even hear outside of his city
your still comparing KC superman with current superman as if that somehow goes onto all star superman
KC superman is faster than all star superman yes
now what Lifting/moving feat did KC superman do that goes over all star superman
what durability feat
"@comicdude23: the superman he showed himself stronger than wasnt anywhere near a planet mover he was portrayed really weak he couldnt even hear outside of his city your still comparing KC superman with current superman as if that somehow goes onto all star superman "
No. It was Mainsteam Superman. The same Superman that Moved the Earth, fought Darkseid etc
He was potrayed fine.
couldnt hear outside a city.... he gets portrayed differently all the time by different writers and it wasnt even in a superman comic it was in justice society comic so he obviously wasnt portayed right, if KC superman went into action comics he would of been a hell lot more powerful than portrayed
"@comicdude23: couldnt hear outside a city.... he gets portrayed differently all the time by different writers and it wasnt even in a superman comic it was in justice society comic so he obviously wasnt portayed right, if KC superman went into action comics he would of been a hell lot more powerful than portrayed "
But the fact is he is still MAINSTREAM SUPERMAN
Still the same Superman
"off topic didnt you create a all star superman vs KC superman thread? "
There is one but i didn't make it.
But KC Superman wins it.
@Valtot said:
"@comicdude23: main stream maybe he wasnt as powerful as usual though, if earth 22 superman was brought into a action comic or justice league comic where current superman was portrayed as extremely powerful than earth 22 superman would of been far more powerful with better feats "
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment