All Star Squadron (core group) vs Xmen

All Stars Squadron members

• Liberty Bell

Enhanced strength, speed agility courtesy of adrenaline powers. Projects sonic shock waves from hands as a force.

• Johnny Quick

Super speed (near light), vibrate through objects, only DCU speedster who can convert momentum into true flight.

• Commander steel

Steel exo skeleton and artificial lung and heart, servo motors to enhance strength (20 tonnes), speed (60 MPH), and metal alloy mesh armor

• Robotman

Stats simliar to Commander steel but completely steel body with human brain implanted

• Hourman

3 to 5 tonnes strength, 60mph speed, enhanced agility and no feelings of pain for an hour at a time

• Amazingman

Transform to any material he touches but retain movement. can also absor abilities and energy

VS

Xmen

• Banshee
• Northstar
• Wolverine
• Colossus
• Beast
• Rogue

Battle takes place in an abandoned city block

round 1 - impromptu encounter no knowledge of opponents

Round 2 30 minutes prep with full knowledge of enemy for both sides

Round 3 All Stars get 30 minutes prep Xmen do not

seriously, no one has input. I thought I made this a pretty close battle. similar powersets, where one side has an advantage over another ( e.g. wolvie over steel, colossus over Robbie) the other has other advantages to compensate a little ( LB over Banshee, JQ over Northstar)

Couldn't Amazing man just touch Wolvie's claws and start wrecking everybody. JQ would probably have to deal with NS still, same with Liberty. But then everyone else is within reach of a man made of adamantium. That's like fighting a stronger colossus. Of course, Amazing man wouldn't know to do that, but i'm sure he'd figure it out soon enough while everyone else is dealing with their counterpart.

Round 1: I see going to ASS (lol), but barely.

Round 2: I see going to X-men, they'll know to deal with Amazing man. Don't know much about everyone else, but i still see x-men taking it.

Round 3 goes to ASS.

@Soul_Rebel:

that would make him certainly the most durable and strongest. that however wouldn't make him fast enough to say tag Beast or Rogue. similarly Logan could cut steel , hourman and Robbie to ribbons in round 1 before they realize their normal durability isn't enough ( again depending on whether or not he can contend with their speed). Lets not forget rogue's durability and strength and could she copy Am as adamantium??

LB's sonic vibration waves have stopped 2 tonnes of falling metal and hurled it around ( as well as Baron Blizcrieg who's around a 20 tonner strength wise) but could Banshee's power manipulate ??

JQ isn't as fast as the Flash's so Norhstar has a good shot, but he is he only DC speedster who can convert speed into true flight.

Edited OP so abilities of All Stars more readily known.

X-Men, mostly due to Banshee and Rogue

@Lord Shiva said:

X-Men, mostly due to Banshee and Rogue

Interesting.

I actually thought those two were the more evenly matched (what with Liberty Belle's sonic vibrational waves and Amazingman's power copy touch) while the Xmen advantage lay in three of the others ( Wolverine able to slice and dice all three if he's fast enough to do so, Colossus stronger than all three, and Beast more agile and on a par in strength and speed (or close) to the better of them. JQ having a SLIGHT speed advantage (not really enough to matter) over Northstar. The whole reason for round three was the three scientists on the All stars ( Steel, Robbie, Hourman) to try and counter the obvious physical disadvantages maybe.

What is Rogue's powerset??

Good Match-up Beatboks. pretty even..... do feel that X team edges it out in the end. Northstar and JQ match would be cool. As far as the Three All star scientists..... Mr. mcCoy has them beat in the intelligence department, combined.

Maybe adding some more combatants to the mix to make it more interesting? both teams have a lot to pull from......

Squadron all riunds

Squadron.